• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
Team Liquid Liquipedia
EDT 07:52
CEST 13:52
KST 20:52
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
Classic Games #3: Rogue vs Serral at BlizzCon0[ASL20] Ro16 Preview Pt1: Ascent9Maestros of the Game: Week 1/Play-in Preview12[ASL20] Ro24 Preview Pt2: Take-Off7[ASL20] Ro24 Preview Pt1: Runway13
Community News
Weekly Cups (Sept 1-7): MaxPax rebounds & Clem saga continues22LiuLi Cup - September 2025 Tournaments3Weekly Cups (August 25-31): Clem's Last Straw?39Weekly Cups (Aug 18-24): herO dethrones MaxPax6Maestros of The Game—$20k event w/ live finals in Paris76
StarCraft 2
General
Team Liquid Map Contest #21 - Presented by Monster Energy #1: Maru - Greatest Players of All Time Weekly Cups (Sept 1-7): MaxPax rebounds & Clem saga continues Classic Games #3: Rogue vs Serral at BlizzCon What happened to Singapore/Brazil servers?
Tourneys
LiuLi Cup - September 2025 Tournaments Maestros of The Game—$20k event w/ live finals in Paris WardiTV Mondays Sparkling Tuna Cup - Weekly Open Tournament RSL: Revival, a new crowdfunded tournament series
Strategy
Custom Maps
External Content
Mutation # 490 Masters of Midnight Mutation # 489 Bannable Offense Mutation # 488 What Goes Around Mutation # 487 Think Fast
Brood War
General
The Korean Terminology Thread Recommended FPV games (post-KeSPA) [ASL20] Ro16 Preview Pt1: Ascent FlaSh on ACS Winners being in ASL ASL20 General Discussion
Tourneys
[ASL20] Ro16 Group B [ASL20] Ro16 Group A Is there English video for group selection for ASL BWCL Season 63 Announcement
Strategy
Simple Questions, Simple Answers Muta micro map competition Fighting Spirit mining rates [G] Mineral Boosting
Other Games
General Games
Stormgate/Frost Giant Megathread Iron Harvest: 1920+ General RTS Discussion Thread Diablo IV S10 Infernal Tides Guide Nintendo Switch Thread
Dota 2
Official 'what is Dota anymore' discussion
League of Legends
Heroes of the Storm
Simple Questions, Simple Answers Heroes of the Storm 2.0
Hearthstone
Heroes of StarCraft mini-set
TL Mafia
TL Mafia Community Thread
Community
General
Things Aren’t Peaceful in Palestine Russo-Ukrainian War Thread US Politics Mega-thread The Games Industry And ATVI UK Politics Mega-thread
Fan Clubs
The Happy Fan Club!
Media & Entertainment
[Manga] One Piece Anime Discussion Thread Movie Discussion! [\m/] Heavy Metal Thread
Sports
2024 - 2026 Football Thread Formula 1 Discussion MLB/Baseball 2023 TeamLiquid Health and Fitness Initiative For 2023
World Cup 2022
Tech Support
Linksys AE2500 USB WIFI keeps disconnecting Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread High temperatures on bridge(s)
TL Community
The Automated Ban List
Blogs
Collective Intelligence: Tea…
TrAiDoS
A very expensive lesson on ma…
Garnet
hello world
radishsoup
Lemme tell you a thing o…
JoinTheRain
RTS Design in Hypercoven
a11
Evil Gacha Games and the…
ffswowsucks
INDEPENDIENTE LA CTM
XenOsky
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 1285 users

Game Design in DotA 2: Icefrog’s Battle with Posit

Blogs > Comeh
Post a Reply
Comeh
Profile Blog Joined July 2008
United States18918 Posts
Last Edited: 2018-01-11 06:01:13
January 10 2018 22:18 GMT
#1
Game Design in DotA 2: Icefrog’s Battle with Positive and Negative Feedback Loops


[image loading]

Good god I’m lazy


This blogpost is an extrapolation of the idea’s behind Game Maker’s Toolkit(GMT) on Feedback Loops. You should watch it because GMT/Mark Brown is wonderful and I apply some of the ideas within DotA 2, albeit loosely. I get kind of lazy on the particulars to be honest, but probably because no one will read it.



DotA2 is an interesting specimen to examine game design and balance, but interestingly enough we see a rather small amount of actual meaty analysis on it; likely this is because DotA 2 is such a ridiculously hard to examine game and is insanely complicated. To look too deeply into the game is to stare into the void, and at the expense of having it chrono us back, I thought it might be interesting to look at some more general concepts behind it.
DotA 2 has long been considered a game with fantastic balance, often being put into the hall of greats alongside Starcraft: Brood War. Over-glorifying this ignores Icefrog’s long term battle to balance games from the winning team getting out of control too quickly, or allowing teams that are behind from recovering too easily. Every patch, he looks to find the sweet spot between these two mechanics, allowing for a reward for bringing yourself to a winning position and for punishing for becoming overconfident.

I wanted to look at what Mark Brown (GMT) refers to as “Positive and Negative Feedback Loops”. In DotA 2, these can be filtered into several different concepts that have become popular in our dialogue over the last few years. These ideas come in names such as: Snowballing, Comeback Mechanics, Momentum, Map Control, and others. Each of these concepts look to either accelerate the team or hero that is ahead, or look to bring that advantage back the more they are ahead.
A “Positive Feedback Loops” is pretty easy to explain – a player that is ahead is given advantages to become even more ahead. GMT gives the example of Call of Duty’s Killstreaks Bonuses – getting enough kills will allow you to get bonus airstrikes, which may allow you to get access to helicopter attacks, which will get more kills to get to the next stage, and so on. Simply put, the kills start to snowball once you accrue enough.

Experienced DotA 2 players should recognize this concept immediately. DotA 2 as a whole is built with the underlying core of Positive Feedback Loops – a player that kills another hero receives gold and experience, which makes them stronger and leads to the easier ability to kill more players, where they will grow stronger and earn enough gold to buy powerful items, which allows you to be even stronger, and so on. Not only that, but kills often lead into destroying towers, limiting map control to the other player (making it harder for them to farm safely), opening the map for killing more neutral camps and creeps, and allowing a stranglehold on the enemy. Teams with map control also get easier access to Roshan and the many bounties he provides. The fundamentals of how DotA 2 inherently functions lead to snowballing and momentum – to change these ideas changes how the game is played dramatically.

Its easy to go back to Pre-The International 2 Na’Vi and remember them pushing down bases to weaker teams by 10 to 15 mins, or The International 4’s uneventful finals where games were quickly decided by the 10 minutes mark, with GG’s being called by 20 minutes. Arguably now, we are seeing games be decided very quickly, as Positive Feedback Loops, or perhaps the lack of enough Negative Feedback Loops hinder the possibility for teams to comeback easily (though, the recent Captains Draft Finals may have something to say about that).

[image loading]
Remember when this networth distribution meant the game was over?
(source) youtube I guess XD

Negative Feedback loops provides the counter-point to Positive Feedback Loops in DotA 2. GMT defines them as an advantage being given to a player that is losing or a disadvantage given to a player that is winning that attempts to prevent the lead from becoming out of control. DotA 2 has had this mechanic within it to different degrees. Within the game naturally different concepts and items allow players to come back. Scaling bounties for killing heroes on a killing streak has always provided greater gold returns, and killing heroes of higher level give more experience than lower levels, which helps a player behind get back in the game a little easier if they are able to kill a cocky player out of position. Defending objectives that are being pushed usually offers an advantage – particularly high ground positions (notably the main base) where the defending team will have a bonus from being hit and have more vision over the defending position.

Over time, Icefrog has looked to experiment with Negative Feedback Loops – we’ve seen him give a “comeback mechanic” where the team that is behind gets extra gold based on how far behind his team is, or how poor (or rich) the heroes that get the kills in relation to the heroes that die. This helps smooth out the curve from snowballing, though it has been done too dramatically in the past (most notably after The International 4 in version 6.82, which was slowly walked back after numerous patches). Icefrog has also changed some mechanics, such as allowing an extra Glyph of Fortification after Tier 1 towers are destroyed, in hopes of slowing down “Death Ball” pushing teams. He randomized when Rosh respawns, to make it harder to secure for teams that are ahead via map control. He even added Wells in the base to allow defending teams to heal (though, those have been removed from inside the base).

[image loading]
(source: dotabuff.com)

Icefrog’s battle has been to reward teams for playing well but not so much that the lead becomes insurmountable. He wants to counter-balance this by allowing teams that are behind to not fall too far behind and not give up from any small lead. He ideally wants to provide enough incentive for teams to be able to play themselves back into the game from any disadvantage, but not so much that teams that are ahead lose their advantage too easily. To this day, he still is struggling with that balance – recently removing wells from inside the base from preventing from base defense becoming too easy, allowing pushing teams to glyph their pushing creeps from taking damage, among other measures. He also is tuning the game from snowballing still, making early kills less rewarding than previously, and trying to promote late game play (so teams that are too invested into early game play are punished by teams that can hold on) by some more complicated ideas. He’s constantly looking at this balance, fine tuning heroes and mechanics within the game to get the gameplay just right.

So if you think the game is looking a bit instable right now – don’t worry, Icefrog’s looking at it too.

comehDoubleEw,
signing out
[image loading]
today sucked
post-note: sorry, this stuff is probably pretty obvious, but I thought it was kind of interesting to look at some of GMT’s concepts and see how they can apply to the game we love. DotA2 is widely ignored or often discounted in Game Design circles, and I think its cool to take a look at these things occasionally. Something I didn’t mention was how Positive and Negative Feedback Loops affect player mentally and psychology and how they lead to bad manners, feeding, and flaming, but I’m sure you can figure that stuff out.
ヽ(⌐■_■)ノヽ(⌐■_■)ノヽ(⌐■_■)ノヽ(⌐■_■)ノヽ(⌐■_■)ノヽ(⌐■_■)ノDELETE ICEFROGヽ(⌐■_■)ノヽ(⌐■_■)ノヽ(⌐■_■)ノヽ(⌐■_■)ノヽ(⌐■_■)ノヽ(⌐■_■)ノヽ(
bdonballer
Profile Joined October 2014
United States408 Posts
January 10 2018 22:44 GMT
#2
A+ Microsoft paint work
I carry hard!
Comeh
Profile Blog Joined July 2008
United States18918 Posts
January 11 2018 18:47 GMT
#3
On January 11 2018 07:44 bdonballer wrote:
A+ Microsoft paint work

I trained many years for this level of work.

Truthfully I thought about using a better program and spending time, but that sounds like something I wouldn't do.
ヽ(⌐■_■)ノヽ(⌐■_■)ノヽ(⌐■_■)ノヽ(⌐■_■)ノヽ(⌐■_■)ノヽ(⌐■_■)ノDELETE ICEFROGヽ(⌐■_■)ノヽ(⌐■_■)ノヽ(⌐■_■)ノヽ(⌐■_■)ノヽ(⌐■_■)ノヽ(⌐■_■)ノヽ(
tehh4ck3r
Profile Joined August 2013
Magrathea7048 Posts
January 12 2018 04:59 GMT
#4
On January 12 2018 03:47 Comeh wrote:
Show nested quote +
On January 11 2018 07:44 bdonballer wrote:
A+ Microsoft paint work

I trained many years for this level of work.

Truthfully I thought about using a better program and spending time, but that sounds like something I wouldn't do.


should have done it in excel

good read, it’s nice to see some people thinking about the more “game-designy” aspects of Dota since that’s so often overlooked in favor of discussions of the specific meta ay hand
AdministratorIn those days, spirits were brave, the stakes were high, men were real men, women were real women, and small furry creatures from Alpha Centauri were real small furry creatures from Alpha Centauri.
Plansix
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
United States60190 Posts
Last Edited: 2018-01-12 18:15:58
January 12 2018 18:14 GMT
#5
On January 12 2018 13:59 tehh4ck3r wrote:
Show nested quote +
On January 12 2018 03:47 Comeh wrote:
On January 11 2018 07:44 bdonballer wrote:
A+ Microsoft paint work

I trained many years for this level of work.

Truthfully I thought about using a better program and spending time, but that sounds like something I wouldn't do.


should have done it in excel

good read, it’s nice to see some people thinking about the more “game-designy” aspects of Dota since that’s so often overlooked in favor of discussions of the specific meta ay hand

Agreed. To many people focus on the merits/flaw current meta vs the older meta at the professional. The discussion of what makes average players come to and return to Dota 2 is often sidelined. And what drives people away. There should be more discussion about that, because it is what really keeps Dota going.
I have the Honor to be your Obedient Servant, P.6
TL+ Member
Archeon
Profile Joined May 2011
3253 Posts
Last Edited: 2018-01-14 01:30:46
January 14 2018 01:30 GMT
#6
Idk, for me dota was always an interesting example for good game design, but I'm no professional. As a competitive game the negative feedback loop makes sense where it normally might make more sense to just weaken the effects of the positive feedback loop (which IF ofc does as well, see killgold changes).

Does anyone know a good article/video on the motivational psychology of coming back? I mean that's what a negative feedback loop in a positive feedback loop is all about in multiplayer, right?
low gravity, yes-yes!
ironcell
Profile Joined January 2010
Chile1127 Posts
Last Edited: 2018-01-17 17:35:51
January 17 2018 17:34 GMT
#7
Comeh this may seem obvious, but it isn't. You said it, the game is very complex and the people that can read the big picture are scarce, we are not used to think about Dota 2 in terms of positive or negative feedbacks. Most of the player base are casuals (i include myself in that category) so i think that your post has a special value.
Maybe this kind of content will never be too popular. But is unique.
Keep it up
sammyzsum
Profile Joined November 2023
1 Post
Last Edited: 2023-12-05 13:12:13
November 21 2023 21:22 GMT
#8
Hey, game design discussions are always fascinating, especially when diving into the intricate loops that shape gameplay! Icefrog's work in DotA 2 is legendary in that aspect, balancing positive and negative feedback loops to keep the game engaging.

Speaking of game mechanics, have you ever explored casual games like solitaire cash review? They can be surprisingly well-crafted and a great way to appreciate game design from a different angle. Icefrog's approach to balancing feedback loops is a masterclass!
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
Replay Cast
10:05
Maestros of the Game Ro24 B
Serral vs ZounLIVE!
Ryung vs ByuN
CranKy Ducklings205
LiquipediaDiscussion
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
ProTech82
StarCraft: Brood War
Britney 48856
Bisu 1593
Shuttle 1545
Flash 914
BeSt 643
EffOrt 535
Larva 437
Mini 355
Stork 322
actioN 298
[ Show more ]
firebathero 278
sSak 263
Backho 187
Barracks 186
Last 161
Light 143
Mind 100
hero 94
Soma 92
Mong 80
Rush 70
ZerO 68
TY 61
PianO 56
Liquid`Ret 52
zelot 45
Sharp 40
Movie 37
Nal_rA 28
Sacsri 22
Noble 18
yabsab 17
soO 15
sorry 12
scan(afreeca) 11
HiyA 10
Hm[arnc] 8
Icarus 7
Shine 4
Terrorterran 0
Dota 2
Dendi840
XaKoH 449
qojqva296
BananaSlamJamma238
Counter-Strike
olofmeister1225
shoxiejesuss524
x6flipin480
edward56
allub25
byalli2
Other Games
singsing1534
B2W.Neo671
crisheroes331
DeMusliM258
Mew2King40
QueenE26
ZerO(Twitch)8
Organizations
Other Games
gamesdonequick772
StarCraft: Brood War
UltimateBattle 25
StarCraft 2
Blizzard YouTube
StarCraft: Brood War
BSLTrovo
sctven
[ Show 14 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• LUISG 31
• iHatsuTV 12
• AfreecaTV YouTube
• intothetv
• Kozan
• IndyKCrew
• LaughNgamezSOOP
• Migwel
• sooper7s
StarCraft: Brood War
• BSLYoutube
• STPLYoutube
• ZZZeroYoutube
Dota 2
• WagamamaTV387
League of Legends
• Jankos992
Upcoming Events
Kung Fu Cup
8m
ByuN vs HeRoMaRinE
MaxPax vs Creator
TBD vs Classic
OSC
4h 8m
Moja vs Babymarine
Solar vs TBD
sOs vs goblin
Nice vs INexorable
sebesdes vs Iba
Nicoract vs TBD
NightMare vs TBD
OSC
12h 8m
ReBellioN vs PAPI
Spirit vs TBD
Percival vs TBD
TriGGeR vs TBD
Shameless vs UedSoldier
Cham vs TBD
Harstem vs TBD
RSL Revival
22h 8m
Cure vs SHIN
Reynor vs Zoun
Kung Fu Cup
1d
The PondCast
1d 1h
RSL Revival
1d 22h
Classic vs TriGGeR
ByuN vs Maru
Online Event
2 days
Kung Fu Cup
2 days
BSL Team Wars
2 days
Team Bonyth vs Team Dewalt
[ Show More ]
BSL Team Wars
2 days
RSL Revival
2 days
Maestros of the Game
3 days
ShoWTimE vs Classic
Clem vs herO
Serral vs Bunny
Reynor vs Zoun
Cosmonarchy
3 days
Bonyth vs Dewalt
[BSL 2025] Weekly
3 days
RSL Revival
3 days
Maestros of the Game
4 days
BSL Team Wars
4 days
Afreeca Starleague
4 days
Snow vs Sharp
Jaedong vs Mini
Sparkling Tuna Cup
5 days
Afreeca Starleague
5 days
Light vs Speed
Larva vs Soma
LiuLi Cup
6 days
Liquipedia Results

Completed

Copa Latinoamericana 4
SEL Season 2 Championship
HCC Europe

Ongoing

BSL 20 Team Wars
KCM Race Survival 2025 Season 3
BSL 21 Points
ASL Season 20
CSL 2025 AUTUMN (S18)
LASL Season 20
RSL Revival: Season 2
Maestros of the Game
Chzzk MurlocKing SC1 vs SC2 Cup #2
BLAST Open Fall 2025
BLAST Open Fall Qual
Esports World Cup 2025
BLAST Bounty Fall 2025
BLAST Bounty Fall Qual
IEM Cologne 2025
FISSURE Playground #1

Upcoming

2025 Chongqing Offline CUP
BSL Polish World Championship 2025
BSL Season 21
BSL 21 Team A
EC S1
BLAST Rivals Fall 2025
IEM Chengdu 2025
PGL Masters Bucharest 2025
MESA Nomadic Masters Fall
Thunderpick World Champ.
CS Asia Championships 2025
ESL Pro League S22
StarSeries Fall 2025
FISSURE Playground #2
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2025 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.