|
On December 21 2011 12:51 caradoc wrote:Show nested quote +On December 21 2011 12:44 Brandish wrote:
My main account was disconnected immediately during play. With the whole "Achievements have been disabled until further notice" thing.
My smurf account I find out is banned after "try[ing] to log in".
I'm not sure what is ambiguous about this statement as it clearly says after I TRIED to log in, I find out it is banned How come you 2v2 with your smurf account (Mercurial) and your main account (Brandish) on the same team? http://us.battle.net/sc2/en/profile/2219214/1/Mercurial/ladder/
before my friend bought his own account during the black friday sale I let him use my other account.
heres his new account if you wish to snoop some more
http://us.battle.net/sc2/en/profile/3253956/1/OfficeFork/
umm also...
if you check the match history of mercurial the last match played was 11/24/2011
http://us.battle.net/sc2/en/profile/2219214/1/Mercurial/matches
edit:
also, if you are unaware of this, placement matches do not award or subtract points
|
On December 21 2011 12:54 Brandish wrote:Show nested quote +On December 21 2011 12:51 caradoc wrote:On December 21 2011 12:44 Brandish wrote:
My main account was disconnected immediately during play. With the whole "Achievements have been disabled until further notice" thing.
My smurf account I find out is banned after "try[ing] to log in".
I'm not sure what is ambiguous about this statement as it clearly says after I TRIED to log in, I find out it is banned How come you 2v2 with your smurf account (Mercurial) and your main account (Brandish) on the same team? http://us.battle.net/sc2/en/profile/2219214/1/Mercurial/ladder/ before my friend bought his own account during the black friday sale I let him use my other account. heres his new account if you wish to snoop some more http://us.battle.net/sc2/en/profile/3253956/1/OfficeFork/
Not sure why you'd include your friends new account... don't see how its relevant. Also not sure why you're calling it 'snooping' since you linked your account in the OP and asked people to speculate why you were banned. Snooping kind of implies looking at something private without permission in an unwanted way. I'm posting in your blog to elucidate why the ban occurred, as you requested in the OP.
yeah, noticed that. But I also noticed that the 2v2s on BrandisH didn't award any points for wins/losses, but that it was only the 2v2s that aren't awarded, (3v3s and 1v1s were awarded) and that the two accounts share a 2v2 team, and both are banned.
Seems like a big coincidence.
|
On December 21 2011 12:52 brachester wrote:Show nested quote +On December 21 2011 12:45 zickoray wrote:here just try doing this, giving them a picture ALWAYS seems to work ![[image loading]](http://a2.sphotos.ak.fbcdn.net/hphotos-ak-ash4/385451_2334194483364_1504875980_31940025_1644574835_n.jpg) Edit: Credit to the [sfw] thread  LOL? was it real?
I think so people do this with them quite often they seem to be good spirited about it i've seen on were they drew them a few character designs (really bad ones) for D3 and they had them rendered and email them back to the guy
|
United States4991 Posts
On December 21 2011 12:54 Brandish wrote:Show nested quote +On December 21 2011 12:51 caradoc wrote:On December 21 2011 12:44 Brandish wrote:
My main account was disconnected immediately during play. With the whole "Achievements have been disabled until further notice" thing.
My smurf account I find out is banned after "try[ing] to log in".
I'm not sure what is ambiguous about this statement as it clearly says after I TRIED to log in, I find out it is banned How come you 2v2 with your smurf account (Mercurial) and your main account (Brandish) on the same team? http://us.battle.net/sc2/en/profile/2219214/1/Mercurial/ladder/ before my friend bought his own account during the black friday sale I let him use my other account. heres his new account if you wish to snoop some more http://us.battle.net/sc2/en/profile/3253956/1/OfficeFork/umm also... if you check the match history of mercurial the last match played was 11/24/2011 http://us.battle.net/sc2/en/profile/2219214/1/Mercurial/matchesedit: also, if you are unaware of this, placement matches do not award or subtract points
Maybe your friend hacked on your account (which is pretty much a scumbag thing to do).
|
On December 21 2011 13:00 caradoc wrote:Show nested quote +On December 21 2011 12:54 Brandish wrote:On December 21 2011 12:51 caradoc wrote:On December 21 2011 12:44 Brandish wrote:
My main account was disconnected immediately during play. With the whole "Achievements have been disabled until further notice" thing.
My smurf account I find out is banned after "try[ing] to log in".
I'm not sure what is ambiguous about this statement as it clearly says after I TRIED to log in, I find out it is banned How come you 2v2 with your smurf account (Mercurial) and your main account (Brandish) on the same team? http://us.battle.net/sc2/en/profile/2219214/1/Mercurial/ladder/ before my friend bought his own account during the black friday sale I let him use my other account. heres his new account if you wish to snoop some more http://us.battle.net/sc2/en/profile/3253956/1/OfficeFork/ Not sure why you'd include your friends new account... don't see how its relevant. Also not sure why you're calling it 'snooping' since you linked your account in the OP and asked people to speculate why you were banned. Snooping kind of implies looking at something private without permission in an unwanted way. I'm posting in your blog to elucidate why the ban occurred, as you requested in the OP. yeah, noticed that. But I also noticed that the 2v2s on BrandisH didn't award any points for wins/losses, but that it was only the 2v2s that aren't awarded, (3v3s and 1v1s were awarded) and that the two accounts share a 2v2 team, and both are banned. Seems like a big coincidence.
the 2v2's today were placement matches played with some random people I met on ladder named JDMking and richardwin
I played 2 with JDMking and 3 with richardwin.
ah and 1 of them is my "2v2 random team"
And i'm just providing you answers to what you point out as "inconsistencies"
|
On December 21 2011 12:54 Brandish wrote:Show nested quote +On December 21 2011 12:51 caradoc wrote:On December 21 2011 12:44 Brandish wrote:
My main account was disconnected immediately during play. With the whole "Achievements have been disabled until further notice" thing.
My smurf account I find out is banned after "try[ing] to log in".
I'm not sure what is ambiguous about this statement as it clearly says after I TRIED to log in, I find out it is banned How come you 2v2 with your smurf account (Mercurial) and your main account (Brandish) on the same team? http://us.battle.net/sc2/en/profile/2219214/1/Mercurial/ladder/ before my friend bought his own account during the black friday sale I let him use my other account. heres his new account if you wish to snoop some more http://us.battle.net/sc2/en/profile/3253956/1/OfficeFork/umm also... if you check the match history of mercurial the last match played was 11/24/2011 http://us.battle.net/sc2/en/profile/2219214/1/Mercurial/matchesedit: also, if you are unaware of this, placement matches do not award or subtract points
Ah I see, makes sense--- 7 2v2s played, 1 random (4 placement matches remain for random), 3 on one team (2 remaining), 2 on another (3 remaining), and your placement match with Mercurial since you placed in bronze because it is a new season...
but wait a minute, playing a 2v2 match with mercurial in the current season in order to place into bronze would imply that your original story is not accurate, since you claim that you only logged into mercurial after your main was banned, and you found it was already banned.
|
Let us know what happens, im interested.
|
On December 21 2011 13:11 caradoc wrote:Show nested quote +On December 21 2011 12:54 Brandish wrote:On December 21 2011 12:51 caradoc wrote:On December 21 2011 12:44 Brandish wrote:
My main account was disconnected immediately during play. With the whole "Achievements have been disabled until further notice" thing.
My smurf account I find out is banned after "try[ing] to log in".
I'm not sure what is ambiguous about this statement as it clearly says after I TRIED to log in, I find out it is banned How come you 2v2 with your smurf account (Mercurial) and your main account (Brandish) on the same team? http://us.battle.net/sc2/en/profile/2219214/1/Mercurial/ladder/ before my friend bought his own account during the black friday sale I let him use my other account. heres his new account if you wish to snoop some more http://us.battle.net/sc2/en/profile/3253956/1/OfficeFork/umm also... if you check the match history of mercurial the last match played was 11/24/2011 http://us.battle.net/sc2/en/profile/2219214/1/Mercurial/matchesedit: also, if you are unaware of this, placement matches do not award or subtract points Ah I see, makes sense--- 7 2v2s played, 1 random (4 placement matches remain for random), 3 on one team (2 remaining), 2 on another (3 remaining), and your placement match with Mercurial since you placed in bronze because it is a new season... but wait a minute, playing a 2v2 match with mercurial in the current season in order to place into bronze would imply that your original story is not accurate.
are you dense or something?
mercurial hasn't played any games this season.
i didn't play a placement match with that account.
mercurial hasn't played ANY games since 11/24/2011
http://us.battle.net/sc2/en/profile/2219214/1/Mercurial/matches
the one match missing is my placement match with officefork. not mercurial
who by the way is NOT banned.
|
On December 21 2011 13:15 Brandish wrote:Show nested quote +On December 21 2011 13:11 caradoc wrote:On December 21 2011 12:54 Brandish wrote:On December 21 2011 12:51 caradoc wrote:On December 21 2011 12:44 Brandish wrote:
My main account was disconnected immediately during play. With the whole "Achievements have been disabled until further notice" thing.
My smurf account I find out is banned after "try[ing] to log in".
I'm not sure what is ambiguous about this statement as it clearly says after I TRIED to log in, I find out it is banned How come you 2v2 with your smurf account (Mercurial) and your main account (Brandish) on the same team? http://us.battle.net/sc2/en/profile/2219214/1/Mercurial/ladder/ before my friend bought his own account during the black friday sale I let him use my other account. heres his new account if you wish to snoop some more http://us.battle.net/sc2/en/profile/3253956/1/OfficeFork/umm also... if you check the match history of mercurial the last match played was 11/24/2011 http://us.battle.net/sc2/en/profile/2219214/1/Mercurial/matchesedit: also, if you are unaware of this, placement matches do not award or subtract points Ah I see, makes sense--- 7 2v2s played, 1 random (4 placement matches remain for random), 3 on one team (2 remaining), 2 on another (3 remaining), and your placement match with Mercurial since you placed in bronze because it is a new season... but wait a minute, playing a 2v2 match with mercurial in the current season in order to place into bronze would imply that your original story is not accurate. are you dense or something? mercurial hasn't played any games this season. i didn't play a placement match with that account. mercurial hasn't played ANY games since 11/24/2011 http://us.battle.net/sc2/en/profile/2219214/1/Mercurial/matchesthe one match missing is my placement match with officefork. not mercurial who by the way is NOT banned.
He just wants to be a detective, ok?
|
On December 21 2011 13:15 Brandish wrote:Show nested quote +On December 21 2011 13:11 caradoc wrote:On December 21 2011 12:54 Brandish wrote:On December 21 2011 12:51 caradoc wrote:On December 21 2011 12:44 Brandish wrote:
My main account was disconnected immediately during play. With the whole "Achievements have been disabled until further notice" thing.
My smurf account I find out is banned after "try[ing] to log in".
I'm not sure what is ambiguous about this statement as it clearly says after I TRIED to log in, I find out it is banned How come you 2v2 with your smurf account (Mercurial) and your main account (Brandish) on the same team? http://us.battle.net/sc2/en/profile/2219214/1/Mercurial/ladder/ before my friend bought his own account during the black friday sale I let him use my other account. heres his new account if you wish to snoop some more http://us.battle.net/sc2/en/profile/3253956/1/OfficeFork/umm also... if you check the match history of mercurial the last match played was 11/24/2011 http://us.battle.net/sc2/en/profile/2219214/1/Mercurial/matchesedit: also, if you are unaware of this, placement matches do not award or subtract points Ah I see, makes sense--- 7 2v2s played, 1 random (4 placement matches remain for random), 3 on one team (2 remaining), 2 on another (3 remaining), and your placement match with Mercurial since you placed in bronze because it is a new season... but wait a minute, playing a 2v2 match with mercurial in the current season in order to place into bronze would imply that your original story is not accurate. are you dense or something? mercurial hasn't played any games this season. i didn't play a placement match with that account. mercurial hasn't played ANY games since 11/24/2011 http://us.battle.net/sc2/en/profile/2219214/1/Mercurial/matches
Yeah, to me that is odd-- if you look at 'mercurial's profile, it only shows a 'season snapshot' for season 4, and no games played past 11/24. But if you look at BrandisH, it shows season 5 stats, including bronze with mercurial in a 2v2 team.
Besides, counting the 2v2s in Brandish match history implies that a 2v2 with Mercurial was definitely played according to the remaining placement matches.
Again, I could be off. I realize you're probably feeling attacked or something, but you know as well as I do how common this type of blog is where the OP actually ends up to be hacking.
|
On December 21 2011 13:19 caradoc wrote:Show nested quote +On December 21 2011 13:15 Brandish wrote:On December 21 2011 13:11 caradoc wrote:On December 21 2011 12:54 Brandish wrote:On December 21 2011 12:51 caradoc wrote:On December 21 2011 12:44 Brandish wrote:
My main account was disconnected immediately during play. With the whole "Achievements have been disabled until further notice" thing.
My smurf account I find out is banned after "try[ing] to log in".
I'm not sure what is ambiguous about this statement as it clearly says after I TRIED to log in, I find out it is banned How come you 2v2 with your smurf account (Mercurial) and your main account (Brandish) on the same team? http://us.battle.net/sc2/en/profile/2219214/1/Mercurial/ladder/ before my friend bought his own account during the black friday sale I let him use my other account. heres his new account if you wish to snoop some more http://us.battle.net/sc2/en/profile/3253956/1/OfficeFork/umm also... if you check the match history of mercurial the last match played was 11/24/2011 http://us.battle.net/sc2/en/profile/2219214/1/Mercurial/matchesedit: also, if you are unaware of this, placement matches do not award or subtract points Ah I see, makes sense--- 7 2v2s played, 1 random (4 placement matches remain for random), 3 on one team (2 remaining), 2 on another (3 remaining), and your placement match with Mercurial since you placed in bronze because it is a new season... but wait a minute, playing a 2v2 match with mercurial in the current season in order to place into bronze would imply that your original story is not accurate. are you dense or something? mercurial hasn't played any games this season. i didn't play a placement match with that account. mercurial hasn't played ANY games since 11/24/2011 http://us.battle.net/sc2/en/profile/2219214/1/Mercurial/matches Yeah, to me that is odd-- if you look at 'mercurial's profile, it only shows a 'season snapshot' for season 4, and no games played past 11/24. But if you look at BrandisH, it shows season 5 stats, including bronze with mercurial in a 2v2 team. Besides, counting the 2v2s in Brandish match history implies that a 2v2 with Mercurial was definitely played according to the remaining placement matches. Definitely odd
the "leagues and ladders" page is still for season 4
how could i possibly accumulate 167 + 89 + 22 wins all in one day?
|
On December 21 2011 12:51 caradoc wrote:Show nested quote +On December 21 2011 12:44 Brandish wrote:
My main account was disconnected immediately during play. With the whole "Achievements have been disabled until further notice" thing.
My smurf account I find out is banned after "try[ing] to log in".
I'm not sure what is ambiguous about this statement as it clearly says after I TRIED to log in, I find out it is banned How come you 2v2 with your smurf account (Mercurial) and your main account (Brandish) on the same team? http://us.battle.net/sc2/en/profile/2219214/1/Mercurial/ladder/also, if you look at the main account: http://us.battle.net/sc2/en/profile/2298192/1/BrandisH/ladder/it shows you as playing 2v2s shortly before being banned, but that you were playing 2v2s on a team with 'mercurial', an account you say you forgot about for almost a month. No match points awarded for wins/losses though... so I'd assume any bans are related to this. Not accusing you of anything, just looks like the things are related somehow, whether in a way you are aware of or not.
Well that's that I guess.
|
could possibly be for account sharing i think someone got banned for that before.
|
Maybe there is a hack to make it look like you are hacking and then have you get banned for hacking...
|
On December 21 2011 13:22 Brandish wrote:Show nested quote +On December 21 2011 13:19 caradoc wrote:On December 21 2011 13:15 Brandish wrote:On December 21 2011 13:11 caradoc wrote:On December 21 2011 12:54 Brandish wrote:On December 21 2011 12:51 caradoc wrote:On December 21 2011 12:44 Brandish wrote:
My main account was disconnected immediately during play. With the whole "Achievements have been disabled until further notice" thing.
My smurf account I find out is banned after "try[ing] to log in".
I'm not sure what is ambiguous about this statement as it clearly says after I TRIED to log in, I find out it is banned How come you 2v2 with your smurf account (Mercurial) and your main account (Brandish) on the same team? http://us.battle.net/sc2/en/profile/2219214/1/Mercurial/ladder/ before my friend bought his own account during the black friday sale I let him use my other account. heres his new account if you wish to snoop some more http://us.battle.net/sc2/en/profile/3253956/1/OfficeFork/umm also... if you check the match history of mercurial the last match played was 11/24/2011 http://us.battle.net/sc2/en/profile/2219214/1/Mercurial/matchesedit: also, if you are unaware of this, placement matches do not award or subtract points Ah I see, makes sense--- 7 2v2s played, 1 random (4 placement matches remain for random), 3 on one team (2 remaining), 2 on another (3 remaining), and your placement match with Mercurial since you placed in bronze because it is a new season... but wait a minute, playing a 2v2 match with mercurial in the current season in order to place into bronze would imply that your original story is not accurate. are you dense or something? mercurial hasn't played any games this season. i didn't play a placement match with that account. mercurial hasn't played ANY games since 11/24/2011 http://us.battle.net/sc2/en/profile/2219214/1/Mercurial/matches Yeah, to me that is odd-- if you look at 'mercurial's profile, it only shows a 'season snapshot' for season 4, and no games played past 11/24. But if you look at BrandisH, it shows season 5 stats, including bronze with mercurial in a 2v2 team. Besides, counting the 2v2s in Brandish match history implies that a 2v2 with Mercurial was definitely played according to the remaining placement matches. Definitely odd the "leagues and ladders" page is still for season 4 how could i possibly accumulate 167 + 89 + 22 wins all in one day?
That is a possibility, but still, looking at the placement matches, it doesn't show brandish as on a 2v2 team with officefork, nor does it show officefork as on a team with brandish in either the placement matches remaining, or in the current team listing.
Instead, on the brandish account, we see 7 2v2 games played in the match history, and in the placement matches, the following (http://us.battle.net/sc2/en/profile/2298192/1/BrandisH/ladder/):
2v2 random - BrandisH (4 remaining) (1played)
JDMKING - BrandisH 3 remaining (2 played)
BrandisH - richardwin 2 remaining (3 played)
and that is all... 7 games, placement matches remaining account for 6 of them. No other listing for 2v2 placements.
as we all know, if you have played on a 2v2 in a previous season, you only need 1 placement match to place...
on the BrandisH account, there is no other ranking displayed for any other 2v2 team... EXCEPT for with Mercurial.
Therefore, BrandisH played a game with mercurial in season 5, which just started, which on the surface appears to contradict the claim in the OP that this did not happen.
In addition, both BrandisH and mercurial are both banned, and share a 2v2 account.
I would say it is likely that the reason for the ban is here. The fact that the story seems at odds with the information suggests to me that not everything has been explained and that you're possibly aware of more than you let on, including the likely reason for the ban.
but I've been wrong before, just my thoughts.
|
|
|
hmmmm, yeah, I see-- well, it's definitely less clear now.
*shrugs* well I'm stumped. What I said previously could be 100% correct, or it could be a result of the weird way that leagues/ladders are displayed. There isn't an actual way to get that information from the battlenet pages. So I no longer have any good intuition about this.
Still though, the fact that both accounts are banned and share a 2v2 account is probably where the reason lies, whatever it is.
Also, sorry if you're actually being earnest and find/found me aggressive-- we all love a good puzzle, and to be honest, I don't know you so if I'm actually trying to figure this out, I need to take what you say as just another piece of it, which includes the possibility of you lying. It's not that I think you are, it's just that it needs to be considered as a possibility in order to figure the puzzle out. It's different than when you talk to someone face-to-face.
If you are being disingenuous though, you've got nerves of steel and are doing a hell of a good job of it. Most people would get pretty aggressive if they were lying by this point-- its the natural progression as the story starts to crack apart, people result to attacking the messenger and distracting attention away from the facts, and generally start to show emotion as the edifice starts to crumble. =P
EDIT: oh and...
On December 21 2011 13:51 cmen15 wrote:
Sorry to here man but really that unicorn email is fckin amazing lolol. I want a picture of that NOW!!!!
yeah, its pretty hilarious!
|
Sorry to here man but really that unicorn email is fckin amazing lolol. I want a picture of that NOW!!!!
|
On December 21 2011 13:44 caradoc wrote:hmmmm, yeah, I see-- well, it's definitely less clear now. *shrugs* well I'm stumped. What I said previously could be 100% correct, or it could be a result of the weird way that leagues/ladders are displayed. There isn't an actual way to get that information from the battlenet pages. So I no longer have any good intuition about this. Still though, the fact that both accounts are banned and share a 2v2 account is probably where the reason lies, whatever it is. Also, sorry if you're actually being earnest and find/found me aggressive-- we all love a good puzzle, and to be honest, I don't know you so if I'm actually trying to figure this out, I need to take what you say as just another piece of it, which includes the possibility of you lying. It's not that I think you are, it's just that it needs to be considered as a possibility in order to figure the puzzle out. It's different than when you talk to someone face-to-face. If you are being disingenuous though, you've got nerves of steel and are doing a hell of a good job of it. Most people would get pretty aggressive if they were lying by this point-- its the natural progression as the story starts to crack apart, people result to attacking the messenger and distracting attention away from the facts, and generally start to show emotion as the edifice starts to crumble. =P EDIT: oh and... Show nested quote +On December 21 2011 13:51 cmen15 wrote:
Sorry to here man but really that unicorn email is fckin amazing lolol. I want a picture of that NOW!!!! yeah, its pretty hilarious!
I guess that's where me and u disagree then, because he does seem pretty aggressive. You were trying to help him from the beginning, and all he could do in return was call you dense. Hah. Obligatory 1 star.
|
On December 21 2011 14:02 danl9rm wrote:Show nested quote +On December 21 2011 13:44 caradoc wrote:hmmmm, yeah, I see-- well, it's definitely less clear now. *shrugs* well I'm stumped. What I said previously could be 100% correct, or it could be a result of the weird way that leagues/ladders are displayed. There isn't an actual way to get that information from the battlenet pages. So I no longer have any good intuition about this. Still though, the fact that both accounts are banned and share a 2v2 account is probably where the reason lies, whatever it is. Also, sorry if you're actually being earnest and find/found me aggressive-- we all love a good puzzle, and to be honest, I don't know you so if I'm actually trying to figure this out, I need to take what you say as just another piece of it, which includes the possibility of you lying. It's not that I think you are, it's just that it needs to be considered as a possibility in order to figure the puzzle out. It's different than when you talk to someone face-to-face. If you are being disingenuous though, you've got nerves of steel and are doing a hell of a good job of it. Most people would get pretty aggressive if they were lying by this point-- its the natural progression as the story starts to crack apart, people result to attacking the messenger and distracting attention away from the facts, and generally start to show emotion as the edifice starts to crumble. =P EDIT: oh and... On December 21 2011 13:51 cmen15 wrote:
Sorry to here man but really that unicorn email is fckin amazing lolol. I want a picture of that NOW!!!! yeah, its pretty hilarious! I guess that's where me and u disagree then, because he does seem pretty aggressive. You were trying to help him from the beginning, and all he could do in return was call you dense. Hah. Obligatory 1 star.
Heh-- don't get me wrong-- I'm not saying I believe he's telling the truth. Just that I'm not 100% convinced that he isn't. If I were to put money on it, I'd say its some type of account sharing, and he possibly knows about it.
But I'm covering both possibilities. Probably cuz I'm a nice upstanding guy, but also because his story about officefork checks out-- officefork played a single 2v2 on 12/20/2011, on scorched haven, which was a loss, and BrandisH's only 2v2 loss in the current season was also on scorched haven and on 12/20/2011.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
