|
On May 12 2017 04:33 LightningStrike wrote:Show nested quote +On May 12 2017 04:27 fuba wrote:On May 12 2017 04:23 LightningStrike wrote: Is it bad I starting to think Palmar might be scum for sheer fact he not much of person who sheep's other people's cases on Day 1? Did he sheep? He said he would which is still not normal on Day 1 in fact he claims his best day as town on finding scum is Day 1. He did mention that he'd sheep you, but he's still voting grack. I don't think it indicates anything.
|
On May 12 2017 04:41 fuba wrote:Show nested quote +On May 12 2017 04:33 LightningStrike wrote:On May 12 2017 04:27 fuba wrote:On May 12 2017 04:23 LightningStrike wrote: Is it bad I starting to think Palmar might be scum for sheer fact he not much of person who sheep's other people's cases on Day 1? Did he sheep? He said he would which is still not normal on Day 1 in fact he claims his best day as town on finding scum is Day 1. He did mention that he'd sheep you, but he's still voting grack. I don't think it indicates anything. Fair play but the thought of thinking of sheeping me still raising my eyebrows.
|
On May 12 2017 04:40 LightningStrike wrote:Show nested quote +On May 12 2017 04:37 Skynx wrote:On May 11 2017 20:35 LightningStrike wrote:On May 11 2017 20:30 Holyflare wrote: LS, find me some mafia and tell me why it's Tumblewood. I don't think Tumblewood is scum? Yes he acting a bit more bold but after my last game with him I can see why he would act bolder. What do you mean by acting bold? He has been very responsive to most of the stuff but not much else, just phrasing thoughts really. See my answer to HE because he asked that same question. I did see that, but again i felt quite the opposite. TW's been mainly reactionary and his list is pretty dull. He hasn't been going after anyone necessarily although he's picking up on possibly scum indicating stuff.
|
|
On May 12 2017 04:44 Skynx wrote:Show nested quote +On May 12 2017 04:40 LightningStrike wrote:On May 12 2017 04:37 Skynx wrote:On May 11 2017 20:35 LightningStrike wrote:On May 11 2017 20:30 Holyflare wrote: LS, find me some mafia and tell me why it's Tumblewood. I don't think Tumblewood is scum? Yes he acting a bit more bold but after my last game with him I can see why he would act bolder. What do you mean by acting bold? He has been very responsive to most of the stuff but not much else, just phrasing thoughts really. See my answer to HE because he asked that same question. I did see that, but again i felt quite the opposite. TW's been mainly reactionary and his list is pretty dull. He hasn't been going after anyone necessarily although he's picking up on possibly scum indicating stuff. Let me recheck his filter because I might of judged it wrong at the time.
|
On May 10 2017 22:27 darthfoley wrote: Does Rayn usually kind of back off like he did with grack when he's town? rereading df's filter this is s oso so so much shit.
|
On May 11 2017 23:36 darthfoley wrote: I think HF is probably town. Or he's buddying the shit out of me. He's probably good enough to do either, but I appreciate that he saw the validity in my post on grack. I'm still waiting on a case from him why TW is the lynch.
Idk what to think about rayn. On one hand he feels equally "shutting up the thread and blowing up when someone insinuates he's not the best mafia player of all time," as he does when he's town. On the other, he's doing a terrible push on me that is based off of one post that actually DOES have merit and trying to discredit me for it. Like there are plenty of other question marks in my mind (LS, Damdred, Skynx, fuba to name the major ones) yet he doesn't seem to care about them at all and only goes after me, which is smart if he's mafia because 1) he doesn't know I'll be active today so active rayn > inactive df and I get ML 2) I'm pretty good at not getting mislynched (only happened in the cell game) so killing me D1 is an added ML bonus. I'm starting to feel like HF v rayn could be TvS but I'm a pussy so I'm gonna try to find mafia elsewhere before I commit to that This post is so so so shit too.
|
On May 12 2017 04:51 LightningStrike wrote:Show nested quote +On May 12 2017 04:44 Skynx wrote:On May 12 2017 04:40 LightningStrike wrote:On May 12 2017 04:37 Skynx wrote:On May 11 2017 20:35 LightningStrike wrote:On May 11 2017 20:30 Holyflare wrote: LS, find me some mafia and tell me why it's Tumblewood. I don't think Tumblewood is scum? Yes he acting a bit more bold but after my last game with him I can see why he would act bolder. What do you mean by acting bold? He has been very responsive to most of the stuff but not much else, just phrasing thoughts really. See my answer to HE because he asked that same question. I did see that, but again i felt quite the opposite. TW's been mainly reactionary and his list is pretty dull. He hasn't been going after anyone necessarily although he's picking up on possibly scum indicating stuff. Let me recheck his filter because I might of judged it wrong at the time. Okay I might of been wrong there I still pretty tired from dealing with all my finals this week.
|
So this should have been the moment where Damdred kinda comes back and picks up the game after being called out. Instead we get this and few more posts that don't really do anything.
On May 11 2017 06:34 Damdred wrote: I powered through the thread while I was up.
To start off questions
@PrisonBreak (I believe), my initial assessment of LS scum etc was a joke. My follow up post of Rayns towniness was not a joke, it came from sort of bad reasoning as he can fake it potentially as scum. But I really liked that his first post was trying to discern who you were so that (presumably) he could better read you and come to a better conclusion. I would generally see thi scome from more town than scum as scum would not want that information really to come to life. But as I said it is partially a bad reason at that point.
As to people who said Damdred can do this as scum, YES! I can, I have and I will do it as both alignments. I've always tried to shape my game where I can do whatever I want from solving the game (or trying to), giving up teammates etc as either alignment. Though I know I still have some ticks as mafia I have a hard time getting rid of. But kind of meh about DF (I believe it was) who only looked at me negatively because of it.
As for my reads here we are:
These are the people i'm ok reading town currently
LS Rayn Palmar Prison Break Skynx
Maybe town: Grack HF
I would normally want to make a call about tumble, and my initial reaction to some of his off the collar commentary I think would come from his town game rather than his scum game. But I am horrid at looking at him so i'm just kind of ignoring him currently.
I disliked DF so far, Vivax has been awkward in some of his postings so far but I am not sure that it makes him scum currently.
Fuba is someone also that I think might be worth a look into later, initial reaction was he might be town just as a gut feeling. His reasoning for following PB I felt was a bit lakluster and was something i've seen mafia do to shift the blame to the person they sheep instead of taking personal responbility for it. Also him refusing to post reads to push the game forward bothered me, or rather him thinking they wouldn't push the game forward. I still sort of see him as a big bag of blah null for now.
Currently I just kind of want to lynch DF for some below average postings for him and him picking on me :'(
If rayn is full town why grack and hf is different? What particular thing makes him stand out of the trio? And rest is just similar style soft accusations or townleans. Just say they haven't done much to have a definitive read? I mean you telling us not liking DF doesn't help anyone because we don't know the basis. Same with fuba and vivax.
I feel like this post is like a massive effort to make ppl feel you have reads and you're scumhunting but it actually doesn't say anything.
|
I still think HE is scum but can consolidate if given a good case
|
give me something on TW and Damdy rayn
|
town and idk, not lynching damdred here since i have actual scumread(s)
|
Yes Damdred could well be mafia
|
rayn, grack, ls, probably prison break are all town. Palmar Hf vivax sl not worth lynching d1 for various reasons. anyone else I would at least consider today. but fuba promised to do stuff and didn't so I am sticking on him unless you try to go lynch like grack
|
|
On May 12 2017 04:56 LightningStrike wrote: I still think HE is scum but can consolidate if given a good case How confident are you on HF?
My problem with this game is that trio made it impossible for me to vote on them for simple interaction based reasons and I'm yet to see a conclusive case.
Palmar and PB is town, fuba and sl is afk all day.
So that leaves df, you, damdy, vivax and tw.
I liked your approach to the game after reading your filter, you seem genuine and i feel like you are town. Vivax's case on me wasn't good and I'm inclined to vote for him, just re-reading gracks reasons on him now. DF i dunno really damdy is bad tw i can't really conclude anything.
This game is hard.
|
On May 12 2017 05:01 Tumblewood wrote: rayn, grack, ls, probably prison break are all town. Palmar Hf vivax sl not worth lynching d1 for various reasons. anyone else I would at least consider today. but fuba promised to do stuff and didn't so I am sticking on him unless you try to go lynch like grack Why are we not lynching sl and vivax?
|
damn this town list is actually pretty good. I would hard defend any of them
|
On May 12 2017 05:02 Skynx wrote:Show nested quote +On May 12 2017 04:56 LightningStrike wrote: I still think HE is scum but can consolidate if given a good case How confident are you on HF? My problem with this game is that trio made it impossible for me to vote on them for simple interaction based reasons and I'm yet to see a conclusive case. Palmar and PB is town, fuba and sl is afk all day. So that leaves df, you, damdy, vivax and tw. I liked your approach to the game after reading your filter, you seem genuine and i feel like you are town. Vivax's case on me wasn't good and I'm inclined to vote for him, just re-reading gracks reasons on him now. DF i dunno really damdy is bad tw i can't really conclude anything. This game is hard. Pretty confident I wish I was good at making cases
|
On May 12 2017 05:03 Skynx wrote:Show nested quote +On May 12 2017 05:01 Tumblewood wrote: rayn, grack, ls, probably prison break are all town. Palmar Hf vivax sl not worth lynching d1 for various reasons. anyone else I would at least consider today. but fuba promised to do stuff and didn't so I am sticking on him unless you try to go lynch like grack Why are we not lynching sl and vivax? sl never really plays d1, basically NAI no matter what. vivax can pull off scum for one day and no more.
|
|
|
|