Why would you not just let the player stay mute? Modkilling might ruin the game for the other people. It also ruins the balance of the game if you did your job as host.

Just mute the player and let town decide if they want to lynch him. Modkilling + no reveal seems really in favor of mafia.

Koshi

Belgium38799 Posts

April 05 2015 22:58 GMT

#93

What? If you are muted you are removed from the game and you don't need to vote anymore. You are modkilled except that your slot is still in the game. So if town believes you are town, you don't cost them a misslynch.

But if town thinks the muted slot is mafia, it can still be lynched and then it will be flipped.

The problem with modkilling an active player or modkilling inactive slot is that the balance of the game gets disrupted. Muting a modkillable slot or just letting an inactive slot be and not modkill it prevents the balance of the game tipping in a party their favor.

modkill on lynchbait ---> hurts mafia,
modkill on "confirmed" town ---> hurts town because they lose a misslynch.

Koshi

Belgium38799 Posts

April 05 2015 23:03 GMT

#94

I am still pro replacing a slot with < 1 page filter or during the first cycle.

After that replacing is imbalanced and unnecessary.

Koshi

Belgium38799 Posts

April 05 2015 23:19 GMT

#96

Being muted is a bannable offense. You will only be muted if you should otherwise be modkilled.

Koshi

Belgium38799 Posts

April 05 2015 23:35 GMT

#99

On April 06 2015 08:31 GlowingBear wrote:

Show nested quote +

It is still strategical nonetheless

Hmm. Very rarely people are getting strategically modkilled. When it happens it is mostly because they can't handle being lynched as town, so modkilling them mostly helps town unfairly, Muting them on the other hand seems fairer towards mafia.

don't know... Maybe it is too strong in the hands of some mafia players when they do it on "purpose". But I think a lot of games get ruined by town modkills over mafia modkills.

Koshi

Belgium38799 Posts

April 05 2015 23:50 GMT

#102

I think muting is better for the game and for town. But muting a player = modkilling a player. It should almost never be done except when the player in question is really going over the line.

Koshi

Belgium38799 Posts

April 07 2015 08:58 GMT

#267

Will this be the game I will be lynched as town? We will find out.

I won't be posting a lot. Really. This game. I will almost not post.

I would like to enter team D and all grumpy people who don't want to join a team can default in my team. Our Teamname is : "Massagesalon Chantal"

Koshi

Belgium38799 Posts

April 07 2015 09:00 GMT

#268

##vote Vivax

In case I don't return. Most mafia of all.

Koshi

Belgium38799 Posts

April 07 2015 11:15 GMT

#313

If we are going to call people mafia for doing good stuff I am just to get really really bored.

##unvote
##vote: rsoultin

Koshi

Belgium38799 Posts

April 07 2015 13:07 GMT

#355

##unvote
##vote GlowingBear

I might be voting for a townie now. But seriously...

Koshi

Belgium38799 Posts

April 07 2015 13:58 GMT

#365

On April 07 2015 22:28 GlowingBear wrote:
Vivax you still didn't answer me if you think rsoultin is Mafia.
Palmar, who are my partners?
Koshi, give reads.

GB/Holyflare/Vivax

Koshi

Belgium38799 Posts

April 07 2015 14:40 GMT

#372

Koshi

Belgium38799 Posts

April 07 2015 14:57 GMT

#375

I would like to point out that we are also a team.

Koshi

Belgium38799 Posts

April 07 2015 16:50 GMT

#383

Massage Salon Chantal

Should be

Team Massagesalon Chantal

pls fix

Koshi

Belgium38799 Posts

April 07 2015 17:24 GMT

#385

I am also the captain.

Koshi

Belgium38799 Posts

April 07 2015 18:35 GMT

#389

Vivax: He is off.
Holyflare: I don't think I had a real reason.
GB: What Palmar said.

Koshi

Belgium38799 Posts

April 07 2015 18:49 GMT

#394

On April 08 2015 03:41 rsoultin wrote:

Show nested quote +

Vivax - How?

HF - who would it be if not him? (reasons please xP)

GB - so what palmar said and not what damdy said? what do you think about them interpreting GB's post completely differently, yet arriving at the same conclusion?

lol also i think koshi has mentioned trying to not be so UBER KOSHI SPAMMER AMAZING TOWNIE several times over his last several games (joat, the one that hasn't finished yet, etc. etc.) however you usually can't keep it bottled long xP i wouldn't mind posts of more substance even if you're determined to keep them few <3

I am pretty sure Vivax is mafia. His posts are off. I can't/wont explain it yet.

HF could be anything. But he isn't a townread. If he isn't mafia anybody else except Damdred could be mafia.

I don't know what Damdred said. I am reading the thread though. It was probably smart because I like Damdred this game.