Hogwarts Mafia

On October 07 2013 21:40 marvellosity wrote:


...fuck.

On October 16 2013 01:17 StorrZerg wrote:
/in

On October 17 2013 07:01 raynpelikonoshi wrote:
Skanjab1s



"guis I am town because I don't know yet the compositions of each House'



"guis I am town because I have no clue how many scums there are"

On October 17 2013 07:19 raynpelikonoshi wrote:

rayn will sign his posts.
Also we will be a beacon of towniness. Don't worry about us.

On October 17 2013 08:30 Mocsta wrote:
Hi all,

---

Firstly,
I'm not sure why Supersoft/Toad want to release the house member distribution so eagerly?

Could either of you please divulge some reasoning behind this play

I know neither of them played GoT; but IIRC, the end-game discussion resulted in agreement between players/hosts that it was in towns best interest NOT to give out the house information. Though the setups are not identical, there are enough commonalities for me to conclude that the reasons in that game, pertain in this game.

i.e. mafia are randomly distributed; and there is potential there is at least one house they have not corrupted. Why give this information to them for free --> especially when we don't know what type of roles they have etc.

---

Secondly,

Raynkonoshi, can you please confirm that because no posts have been signed by Rayn; you are responsible for every post made by your hydra so far?

---

Thirdly,

I have no opinion on the skanjab stuff so far. I'm acknowledging it occured because obvious thats the biggest matter going on in the thread so far; but I need to re-read it all again before stating an opinion.

---

Lastly,
I'm not sure if this is right play to do in a themed closed game. But in a normal I believe you are meant to do this.

I am a self-aware miller.

After my doctor fake-claims as town last game, I can understand those that refuse to believe this.
So if this ends up in my lynch, so be it.

On October 17 2013 10:38 Mattchew wrote:
yo yam, does that mean your thinking what im thinking

On October 17 2013 08:57 LastArgument wrote:


I don't understand any of this reasoning. The only situation where mafia don't understand the exact player make-up of each house is when all the mafia are stacked in 1 or 2 houses. If they're in 3 houses they can obviously deduce the fourth. A mathematician will probably be able to tell you how likely it is that all mafia are in 2 or fewer houses, but I don't think the probability is very high.

What information do you think mafia are being given by releasing the members of people's houses then?

On October 17 2013 09:18 Mocsta wrote:

Out of everything in the thread thus far.

Why is it that you are purely commenting on that item?

Can you guarantee scum know who is what house?

Heres a tidbit.. in GoT... a player took the exact same stance you did... that player flipped scum

What is your opinion on the rest of the thread; for example, what do you make of I-Be-So-Pro interchanges with Supersoft.

On October 17 2013 10:40 Mattchew wrote:

hellz yeah.

what do you think about the houses and who's in each.. im really tempted to just list all my housemates cause i think theres nothing to be gained from a town perspective in keeping them secret