Newbie Mini Mafia XXVI

On September 04 2012 05:00 thrawn2112 wrote:


First, as it's been stated several times, no-lynch isn't an option. You say reads are pointless on D1. But how will reads become less pointless during D2 if hypothetically we could choose to no-lynch? Lynching makes people commit to reads.

You just posted so apparently you want to remain in the game. If so you need to vote to avoid being modkilled so who is your vote?

On September 04 2012 05:03 thrawn2112 wrote:
From the OP:

4. You may vote for yourself. You may not vote for anyone dead or outside the game.

Kville do you want to be lynched/replaced/modkilled?

On September 04 2012 05:19 thrawn2112 wrote:


Actually I'm in agreement with this, especially the bolded part.

Kville answer this question. You have played extremely poorly, broken a rule, and there is the evidence in the replacement thread that suggest you wanted to be removed from the game. Do you want to play or not? If you do, then why are you purposely playing so extremely anti-town? I say your bad play is intentional because here are your actions:

-Lurk on 1 post until near voting deadline
-Broke a rule by self-voting
-Make an statement about non-lynching so illogical I don't think anyone would have it as an honest opinion

So why play intentionally bad if you are town?

On September 05 2012 11:24 Xatalos wrote:
I'm in extreme hurry right now, but some comments on the recent events...

Farewell thrawn2112, you will be missed :/ Can't say I'm too surprised about the night kill, though.

kushm4sta, you're severely underestimating my contributions. At the moment I have a pretty good case against Sonic Death Monkey and WeeTee (imcasey), and although the case against Sonic Death Monkey is a bit outdated, the case against WeeTee (imcasey) is quite good IMO. At least I think it's much stronger than the policy lynching of kville or the suspicions toward Stutters695. I agree that I could have been more active so far, but when I look at my own filter, I've scumhunted and/or pushed the discussion forward in every post. Much more than can be said about most players so far.

Now I have to leave, but I'll be able to post again later today. My vote is going for imcasey, as I previously reasoned. I'll be looking at each player's filters later today, though.

##Vote imcasey

(Btw, my vote for Cubu was in real hurry as well, so I indeed should have reasoned it better, but I just had no time. I'll get back to it later!)

I don't think kville is Mafia,

If there is a Vigilante, kville would make for a good shot.

On September 07 2012 03:36 kushm4sta wrote:
Kville just voted for xatalos FYI. Not really sure how to read that. He's not here to say anything or defend himself, but he's here to vote for the other person who is suspected.

On September 07 2012 04:07 KillingTime wrote:
If it is between Kville and Xatalos - I would rather lynch Kville at the moment. Xatalos has atleast got a semi-plausible excuse for why he is inactive and has said he could be more active at the weekend - his play to me seems somewhat consistent with someone who hasn't got enough time to play 100%.

Kville has twice come into the thread at the last minute offering a weak defence and trying to deflect a lynch, as kreb wrote it has been clear for 48h that he might be lynched today and he has done nothing to defend himself - yet he pops up again just like on d1 with an attempt to deflect the lynch away from himself. Of the two I think he is a better bet.

On September 07 2012 04:09 kushm4sta wrote:
I will switch vote to kville if that's the consensus...im just really scared of him flipping green, and I think he probably will.

On September 07 2012 04:35 KillingTime wrote:
Voting for yourself with the reason:
Is pretty much my definition of a weak defence - you were obviously not going to propose another target as you had said that you were not in favour of a D1 lynch - but you knew everyone else disagreed with this and that if you were not lynched then someone else would be.

On September 07 2012 04:48 Sonic Death Monkey wrote:
Kville, if you're townie, do you really think your way of posting is pro-town? If so, why?

I try to make sense of you, but I have no idea what you're doing.

On September 07 2012 05:30 Sonic Death Monkey wrote:
Ok, I'm putting my vote on Kville. Xatalos got the thread started by throwing out those questions d1. It helped getting the discussion past the "do we lynch lurkers" and "what about dem lists" part, which is generally pro-town. I have no idea what his motivation was though, since he disappeared quickly and didn't return until EOD (his military service can be a legitimate excuse or a convenient circumstance). At this point it's a vote against Kville more than it's a vote for Xatalos. I'd rather have a player left who seems to interested in playing the game and contribute than someone who doesn't.

On September 07 2012 05:36 kushm4sta wrote:
@kville
if you are town this is why you dont play like how you are playing... town has to waste a lynch on you now

On September 07 2012 05:56 Stutters695 wrote:


I'm still willing to give you a chance if you actually start helping. You've done nothing except say "hey I'm not scum so you guys are wasting a day. Lynch him instead."

For starters: How do you know he is town? I don't think anyone in this thread has had a townread on him in D2. Do you know something we don't?