EPTStudent Mafia (New/Newish players welcome)
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Bluelightz
Indonesia2463 Posts
| ||
|
Bluelightz
Indonesia2463 Posts
 then him | ||
|
Bluelightz
Indonesia2463 Posts
| ||
|
Bluelightz
Indonesia2463 Posts
##Vote: Jaybrundage | ||
|
Bluelightz
Indonesia2463 Posts
Hmm My scumreads right now BroodKingEXE Leaning Scum - He has been filling the thread with some post's trying to "distance" him and jay as you can see in Adam's and BH's observation. Also, if JB flips scum we wil have a strong case on BKEXE Next, ey215 is leaning scum, when he says I Am Town but then, I quote Grackaroni On December 07 2011 03:43 Grackaroni wrote: NOBODY IS A CONFIRMED TOWNIE BH, has provided a good enough discussion so, ##Vote: Jaybrundage | ||
|
Bluelightz
Indonesia2463 Posts
My guesses are BKEXE/jay any other guesses? | ||
|
Bluelightz
Indonesia2463 Posts
##Vote: BroodKingEXE | ||
|
Bluelightz
Indonesia2463 Posts
First, since jay flipped scum I was suspicious of BKEXE defending jay and vice versa;' On December 07 2011 14:50 BroodKingEXE wrote: jay - to me jay is another one of those people who is being printed as scum based on the fact that he is opposed to BH in some aspect. I feel that he has provided some solid leads, but has to respond to the attacks by other more often then not. I feel like until he can get a few more unprovoked responses in until I can decide. Turneg- he strikes me as more of a townie. I feel that in the early game he differed in his style vs BH. He instead of using more aggressive response posts, he looked at early posts and methodically made questions out of those. I feel like this is definitely more of a townie behavior. Early in the game he chose to start examining players right away, I feel that a mafia member would not have been able to think so quickly to implement a strategy as hard as this. These same questions have also put him in a bad spot as he is viewed as passively accusing, a behavior I feel is a bit scummy. Next, when I re read the thread BKEXE made a literal smoke screen of posts on page 29 to hide BHs case on JB lastly, see Adams , veli's & others case on him On December 08 2011 13:37 Adam4167 wrote: I don't see what you see at all. I see BKEXE quote BH's book that he wrote on jay, ramble on about policy (a bit late in the piece for this really..), then dump his vote on jay after calling him an idiot. Oh and don't forget declaring how new he is... again. Your case on BKEXE was exactly where I was heading with the next day (assuming I survive the night.). It was well done and did a good job of highlighting exactly how BKEXE has been playing thus far, however I am going to highlight something you missed: BKEXE and jay have been defending each other this entire game: Here Here Here Here Here BKEXE's more recent posts aimed at jay are nothing more than distancing because we have shifted focus onto them. It is just a smokescreen, do not buy into this nonsense. ok so, thats why im voting him. | ||
|
Bluelightz
Indonesia2463 Posts
 | ||
|
Bluelightz
Indonesia2463 Posts
| ||
|
Bluelightz
Indonesia2463 Posts
anyway im gonna look @ people's filter & post my analysis of the one i think is most scummies when i can also gottl sleep cya c: | ||
|
Bluelightz
Indonesia2463 Posts
just didnt feel like posting (>_<)anyway some analysis on Tunkeg First, he voted on ey on day 2 On December 09 2011 06:04 Tunkeg wrote: I've read through EY's filter and I do sense some scumevibe. He have been in on every bandwagon. He came into BByte lynch as a fifth vote and on jay as fourth vote (reaassuring these votes come through without sticking his head out to much). He haven't really been sticking his head out to much for the entire game (except the BH arguement). And finally he is on my probability list. Therefor I will vote for ey215. ##Vote ey215 but he said his vote on him was wrong. Next, he jumped on the BKEXEs band wagon On December 10 2011 22:28 Tunkeg wrote: I am all for a lynch on BroodKingEXE. His post aren't making mucch sense, and this have been the case from the beginning. At first I wanted to cut him some slack, because of newbiefactor. And I thought a lynch on him would be to easy, as in easy for scum to get a bandwagon on. After a passive first day, he came back on the secound day (the end of Day 1 ingame) posting more, as if he had been told by someone to step up his game. He have as you guys have said been defending jay, before he bussed him and took the opposite approach (this after seeing that jay was going to get lynched). And then comes the part that puts it over the top. He sees xtfftc's and my vote on ey215 and jumps on it, as a last resort to save himself. I belive BKE is scum, and he will have my vote. My vote on ey215 seems to be wrong, I may have put to much into my probability lynch case, and I really wanted a lynch on one of those four. Having some small scumreads on ey215 I went with it. As of now my entire probability lynch case seems pretty dead, I think BKE is scum, and jay flipped scum, therefor there can't be 2 scum among those 4. ##Vote BroodKingExe Lastly, on day 1 he voted on xsksc but when he realized it was going to fail he switched to BByte On December 06 2011 07:43 Tunkeg wrote: Having read up on the three most likely candidates for a lynch today (Those three are Adam (2votes in), Bbyte and Hassybaby.), and ElectricBlacks write up on Hassybaby I have the following thoughts: From scummiest to towniest I'd go for Bbyte>Hassybaby>Adam. Bbyte simply have posted to little and to little content. Hassybaby is pretty much a no-read at the time. But one major bad thing is that he haven't posted for ages. Adam I am leaning town on, and I do not want to see him lynched. Seeing that xtfftx have unvoted xsksc, he will not be lynched tonight. And as bad as this looks, I will also post my vote on Bbyte, to avoid any surprises. But I really feel Bbyte have been bandwagoned here, but rather him than the other two. ##Unvote: xsksc ##Vote: Bbyte He has been scumhunting the entire game though so my thoughts on him is neutral. | ||
|
Bluelightz
Indonesia2463 Posts
| ||
|
Bluelightz
Indonesia2463 Posts
##Vote: Tunkeg BH, is there any other of his posts that make you have a scumread on him? also, after looking @ BHs case m mind is decided for this day | ||
|
Bluelightz
Indonesia2463 Posts
I have some Quotes on him that justifies my vote, First, On December 13 2011 03:33 Tunkeg wrote: Why is it you think you are the one the doctor (if there is one) should save? It's great to have an ego, but in the end you are just another player in the game, and there is no reason for a doc to prioritize you over anyone else. Hell, you might even be scum trying to get the doc to waste all his saves on you... In this post, he tries to get the doctor we supposedly have to not protect BH so the mafia can kill him tonight. Next, On December 14 2011 07:31 Tunkeg wrote: I'll speak for myself here. I think the entire thread have taken a bad turn after layabout came into play. All he have done is make shitty cases and OMGUS'ing anyone arguing with him. I think he himself is playing an utterly crappy game (if he is town), he is purposly misinterpreting what other writes, twisting and turning every word that is written and his dickish behaviour wants me to straight up punch him in the face. He acts like he is so fucking great at this game, and keep referencing other games and how this game should be played. At the moment I get pissed off just by opening the thread and reading anything he writes, and therefor I find it hard to contribute anything usefull. I'll give him this though, if he is scum he is doing a good job, creating a crappy townenvironment and distracting the town with his shit. I know this is an increadible OMGUS post, and I know it will probably make me look bad, but I don't care, I can't coexist with layabout anyways. So please feel free to jump on me, cause atm I am the third best lynch town can make (green townie who is having a hard time contributing). I will give layabout the benefit of the doubt, I think he is scum and not a crappy asshole of a town... ##Vote: layabout OMGUSing LB lastly, voting LB for no reason other than not liking him | ||
|
Bluelightz
Indonesia2463 Posts
OMGUSING lb and voting him for no reason other than not liking him we're not in the quotes and my comments | ||
|
Bluelightz
Indonesia2463 Posts
First, he doesnt provide enough quotes Second, I'm confused between who is mafia, but i dont want to risk losing a townie because 4-2(todays lynch if we lynch a townie) 3-2(If the doctor is shitty we'll lose a townie/blue) I bolded 3-2 because its is lynch correctly or lose also, when he accuses xtf he doesnt provide enough quotes | ||
|
Bluelightz
Indonesia2463 Posts
| ||
|
Bluelightz
Indonesia2463 Posts
so, my case First, On December 12 2011 01:12 layabout wrote: i understand why people are voting for BroodkingExe but right now i think that 1 player is not making sense and that their behaviour is scummy therefore ##Vote: xtfftc above post was on day 3, he says "I think x(in this case BKEXE) but im going to vote for y(xtf)" On December 11 2011 09:17 layabout wrote: franky i think BXE is the best lynch target at the current moment in time but we still have scum to find and we need to scumhunt (analysis coming tomorrow) so i decided to see why, you made a post in which you began by saying people would ignore you and then went on to make worthless speculation and unjustified assumptions i feel that i have highlighted why this is this case very clearly i cannot believe that you have not adressed any of my arguements but have instead tried to attack my possible motivation and you have mostly just provided fluff justify them then!don't just say i made assumptions we need to in this game that is an entirely worthless statement as was your poker "analogy" you just make general statement about making reads and how reads are more valuable the more time passes. This has nothing to do with what you had written if you make an argument based on reasoning then you better have solid reasoning because otherwise your post holds no weight it is not helpful to town (unless it reveals that you are scum) because your entire argument relies on reason that does not withstand scrutiny i think we are past the point of this being a useful exchange because you clearly don't understand or are ignoring the point that i have made explain yourself and then try to help town by analysing behaviour well, I cant say anything else but, things to consider He & Velinath has been agreeing alot. He's been tunneling xtf preety much since he was in the mafia | ||
|
Bluelightz
Indonesia2463 Posts
| ||
| ||
