|
On July 07 2010 08:22 Bill Murray wrote:Show nested quote +
fine, let's go with this rule (that came out of nowhere tbh, i haven't seen this in the OP but w.e)
then we have a mafia-town tie, still not a mafia win
no. no. no. the mafia have 1 kp per night voldemort gets an AK every other night you cant block you all can only protect one of you every night you all have NO lynch power, and NO kill power you all were fucked
i dont know how voldy's AK works because obviously none of this was in the rules so you can make up whatever the hell you want, but we have lynch power, consequently we have kill power. unless you want to go with your "day is infinitely paused at tie" rule in which case it's going to be a tie.
i'm not sure why you're still arguing though, it's pretty clear it was a very likely but not 100% mafia win
|
On July 07 2010 10:05 JeeJee wrote:Show nested quote +On July 07 2010 08:22 Bill Murray wrote:
fine, let's go with this rule (that came out of nowhere tbh, i haven't seen this in the OP but w.e)
then we have a mafia-town tie, still not a mafia win
no. no. no. the mafia have 1 kp per night voldemort gets an AK every other night you cant block you all can only protect one of you every night you all have NO lynch power, and NO kill power you all were fucked i dont know how voldy's AK works because obviously none of this was in the rules so you can make up whatever the hell you want, but we have lynch power, consequently we have kill power. unless you want to go with your "day is infinitely paused at tie" rule in which case it's going to be a tie. i'm not sure why you're still arguing though, it's pretty clear it was a very likely but not 100% mafia win
if mafia have 1 kp in addition to voldy's AK every other night, then mafia DID win 100%. Radfield can pardon twice, including himself, so that means that either this night or the night after, mafia would be able to use their 1 KP in addition to Voldy's AK. You two can only protect one person, so one of you dies, which makes it 2v1. You guys had no way to kill the mafia in the next two days due to pardons, which gives us time to wait for Voldy's AK.
|
On July 07 2010 10:09 DarthThienAn wrote:Show nested quote +On July 07 2010 10:05 JeeJee wrote:On July 07 2010 08:22 Bill Murray wrote:
fine, let's go with this rule (that came out of nowhere tbh, i haven't seen this in the OP but w.e)
then we have a mafia-town tie, still not a mafia win
no. no. no. the mafia have 1 kp per night voldemort gets an AK every other night you cant block you all can only protect one of you every night you all have NO lynch power, and NO kill power you all were fucked i dont know how voldy's AK works because obviously none of this was in the rules so you can make up whatever the hell you want, but we have lynch power, consequently we have kill power. unless you want to go with your "day is infinitely paused at tie" rule in which case it's going to be a tie. i'm not sure why you're still arguing though, it's pretty clear it was a very likely but not 100% mafia win if mafia have 1 kp in addition to voldy's AK every other night, then mafia DID win 100%. Radfield can pardon twice, including himself, so that means that either this night or the night after, mafia would be able to use their 1 KP in addition to Voldy's AK. You two can only protect one person, so one of you dies, which makes it 2v1. You guys had no way to kill the mafia in the next two days due to pardons, which gives us time to wait for Voldy's AK.
remember we have disarm, and since i'm pretty sure mafia had voldy doing the killing, the disarm would disarm both the ak and the nightkill
/shrug
|
On July 07 2010 10:13 JeeJee wrote:Show nested quote +On July 07 2010 10:09 DarthThienAn wrote:On July 07 2010 10:05 JeeJee wrote:On July 07 2010 08:22 Bill Murray wrote:
fine, let's go with this rule (that came out of nowhere tbh, i haven't seen this in the OP but w.e)
then we have a mafia-town tie, still not a mafia win
no. no. no. the mafia have 1 kp per night voldemort gets an AK every other night you cant block you all can only protect one of you every night you all have NO lynch power, and NO kill power you all were fucked i dont know how voldy's AK works because obviously none of this was in the rules so you can make up whatever the hell you want, but we have lynch power, consequently we have kill power. unless you want to go with your "day is infinitely paused at tie" rule in which case it's going to be a tie. i'm not sure why you're still arguing though, it's pretty clear it was a very likely but not 100% mafia win if mafia have 1 kp in addition to voldy's AK every other night, then mafia DID win 100%. Radfield can pardon twice, including himself, so that means that either this night or the night after, mafia would be able to use their 1 KP in addition to Voldy's AK. You two can only protect one person, so one of you dies, which makes it 2v1. You guys had no way to kill the mafia in the next two days due to pardons, which gives us time to wait for Voldy's AK. remember we have disarm, and since i'm pretty sure mafia had voldy doing the killing, the disarm would disarm both the ak and the nightkill /shrug
>>. Yeah, I don't really know all the spells / the whole setup. Could you guys have disarmed and protected on the same night? If so, it would have been up to us/you guys to pick the right targets, etc. and get in the vote race too.
|
Radfield
Canada2720 Posts
On July 07 2010 10:13 JeeJee wrote:Show nested quote +On July 07 2010 10:09 DarthThienAn wrote:On July 07 2010 10:05 JeeJee wrote:On July 07 2010 08:22 Bill Murray wrote:
fine, let's go with this rule (that came out of nowhere tbh, i haven't seen this in the OP but w.e)
then we have a mafia-town tie, still not a mafia win
no. no. no. the mafia have 1 kp per night voldemort gets an AK every other night you cant block you all can only protect one of you every night you all have NO lynch power, and NO kill power you all were fucked i dont know how voldy's AK works because obviously none of this was in the rules so you can make up whatever the hell you want, but we have lynch power, consequently we have kill power. unless you want to go with your "day is infinitely paused at tie" rule in which case it's going to be a tie. i'm not sure why you're still arguing though, it's pretty clear it was a very likely but not 100% mafia win if mafia have 1 kp in addition to voldy's AK every other night, then mafia DID win 100%. Radfield can pardon twice, including himself, so that means that either this night or the night after, mafia would be able to use their 1 KP in addition to Voldy's AK. You two can only protect one person, so one of you dies, which makes it 2v1. You guys had no way to kill the mafia in the next two days due to pardons, which gives us time to wait for Voldy's AK. remember we have disarm, and since i'm pretty sure mafia had voldy doing the killing, the disarm would disarm both the ak and the nightkill /shrug
Disarming doesn't stop the mafia KP. Only a medic protect can stop the mafia kp. I sent in our Mafia KP every night and it went through every time, even when I was roleblocked. Also, I could just use my AK as a daykill in the thread if I wanted to make sure it went through.
|
On July 07 2010 11:27 Radfield wrote:Show nested quote +On July 07 2010 10:13 JeeJee wrote:On July 07 2010 10:09 DarthThienAn wrote:On July 07 2010 10:05 JeeJee wrote:On July 07 2010 08:22 Bill Murray wrote:
fine, let's go with this rule (that came out of nowhere tbh, i haven't seen this in the OP but w.e)
then we have a mafia-town tie, still not a mafia win
no. no. no. the mafia have 1 kp per night voldemort gets an AK every other night you cant block you all can only protect one of you every night you all have NO lynch power, and NO kill power you all were fucked i dont know how voldy's AK works because obviously none of this was in the rules so you can make up whatever the hell you want, but we have lynch power, consequently we have kill power. unless you want to go with your "day is infinitely paused at tie" rule in which case it's going to be a tie. i'm not sure why you're still arguing though, it's pretty clear it was a very likely but not 100% mafia win if mafia have 1 kp in addition to voldy's AK every other night, then mafia DID win 100%. Radfield can pardon twice, including himself, so that means that either this night or the night after, mafia would be able to use their 1 KP in addition to Voldy's AK. You two can only protect one person, so one of you dies, which makes it 2v1. You guys had no way to kill the mafia in the next two days due to pardons, which gives us time to wait for Voldy's AK. remember we have disarm, and since i'm pretty sure mafia had voldy doing the killing, the disarm would disarm both the ak and the nightkill /shrug Disarming doesn't stop the mafia KP. Only a medic protect can stop the mafia kp. I sent in our Mafia KP every night and it went through every time, even when I was roleblocked. Also, I could just use my AK as a daykill in the thread if I wanted to make sure it went through.
well that just makes no sense
i guess i shouldn't assume anything about this game based on how every other mafia game is run =\
edit: i guess the roleblock in this game isn't a roleblock at all, and only an AK/dt block :x
|
My only complaint is the rather boring and anti-climactic ending.
There wasn't even like a MAFIA WIN!
Just like.. started saying everyone's roles. And I was like, "Oh, I guess they won."
Anyway, thanks for modding the game BM, it was pretty crazy and I enjoyed spectating after getting my dumb ass temp banned! AHHHH!
|
|
|
So I want to know why masons were so insanely gimped in this game.
Like why Ron knew that I was a mason but I didn't know he was a Mason in reverse.
and also the threat of modkilling due to ANY breadcrumbing pretty much made me a green townie with nothing to do but sit with a thumb up my ass.
|
FREEAGLELAND26781 Posts
Wait what the fuck?
looooool Roffles and Radfield held on.
|
Radfield
Canada2720 Posts
On July 08 2010 14:31 flamewheel wrote:
Wait what the fuck?
looooool Roffles and Radfield held on.
Yeah I thought we were done for sure once the name claiming started. Scrimgeour and Aberforth are such side characters, but we were lucky that someone was actually Flitwick. If Jugan hadn't skipped out on the thread due to irl stuff, I think roffles or myself would have gotten lynched. It was basically us vs 2 pairs of masons, 3 people who had been checked, and Harry Potter. Lucky lucky.
|
|
|
|
|
ROFLMAO thank you very much for the find. Glad to know my behaviour encouraged mafia to target me, one way or another.
|
United States3652 Posts
Wow...-_-
"That leaves Jayme, Jugan(Ron Weasley), Whatchamacallit, Amber(traitor?) and the three of us. We need to seriously get rid of opz, yellowink and jeejee. Someone keeps roleblocking me as well. Probably Jugan or Yellowink."
FU Radfield...xD
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
