|
Are you seriously trying to tell me I'm scum because I called him out on bad posting?
What "pre-emptive defense" are you talking about? In that quote I'm talking to VE after he called for votes on johnny, please read the thread properly.
On March 18 2012 15:18 slOosh wrote:
giving obvious advice about using our time without actually doing it himself
I don't understand what you mean here. It sounds like you're suggesting that I'm not taking my time? Please clarify.
Also, please state why you believe johnny is town, I'd be interested to know.
|
Only one thing so far is absolutely clear: Toad_in_pink_dress is our only hope to maintain our town's historic amphibian worshipping ways, now that poor, martyred Toadesstern is no more. If there are any doctors (or better, veterinarians!) among us: know that Toad_in_pink_dress must be protected at all costs!
That important message having been said, at the moment I'm with Nemesis and slOosh. Johnnywup's behavior is coming across to me as townie deer in headlights, rather than amphibian-god-napping scum. On the other hand, grilling the newb to get some sort of reaction is very positive townie behavior as well. Hmph. I don't trust my own reads much.
I think we'll get the most real solid info out of the voting for day 1, as long as we avoid a no-lynch. So I plan to bandwagon on whomever can get close to enough votes. All your reads are likely to be better than mine, and that way I can hopefully prove my town-itude by being a deciding vote on a scum slaying.
|
it's almost always better to trust your own reads than other peoples reads, if you don't know their role.
|
On March 18 2012 15:54 Tobon wrote:
Only one thing so far is absolutely clear: Toad_in_pink_dress is our only hope to maintain our town's historic amphibian worshipping ways, now that poor, martyred Toadesstern is no more. If there are any doctors (or better, veterinarians!) among us: know that Toad_in_pink_dress must be protected at all costs!
That important message having been said, at the moment I'm with Nemesis and slOosh. Johnnywup's behavior is coming across to me as townie deer in headlights, rather than amphibian-god-napping scum. On the other hand, grilling the newb to get some sort of reaction is very positive townie behavior as well. Hmph. I don't trust my own reads much.
I think we'll get the most real solid info out of the voting for day 1, as long as we avoid a no-lynch. So I plan to bandwagon on whomever can get close to enough votes. All your reads are likely to be better than mine, and that way I can hopefully prove my town-itude by being a deciding vote on a scum slaying.
While this post contains a huge amount of fluff you actaully have a scummy stance on the game...
1) You think JW is a new townie player.
2) People grilling him are acting town by doing so
3) You don't trust your own reads - (don't worry just ask your team)
4) Think we're lynching for information
5) Will bandwagon anyone so we get a lynch
6) Push responsibility away from yourself
What a bad post all in all.
You are going about this all wrong. But hopefully you'll figure it out on your own.
@VE: If this is your new style I liked your old one better.
|
Hey guys, just popping in to say hi. My sincere apologies for not contributing so far. It was my dear mother's birthday today and so I haven't been online. There is a lot to read and I am not going to post rubbish stuff just to post. We still have another 36 hours or so, I'll post my thoughts in the morning.
Goodnight
|
Are they actual votes?
Even after i said:
trying to conclude anything from the first couple of hours is risky business.
Dirkzor, it's not like you to be so critical of others. Maybe you know they are on the wrong track?
Do you mind telling us who your teammates actually are?
oblig:
+ Show Spoiler +
|
I'm always critical... Or so I hope to appear.
I've yet to take a stance on JW. I think the votes on him are very weak but you can't really expect anything else at this point in the game.
I think that Tobon's post is pure rubbish which was what i pointed out. He made several newbie mistake in his first real post and while he is a newbie its still a bad post. The good thing is he now have made all those mistake and I expect him to act better going forward.
To answer your question directly: I don't know my teammates yet. Do you?
|
Omg I'm alive...
Damn Toad, that diagram was super informative. 
On March 18 2012 16:54 Dirkzor wrote:Show nested quote +On March 18 2012 15:54 Tobon wrote:
Only one thing so far is absolutely clear: Toad_in_pink_dress is our only hope to maintain our town's historic amphibian worshipping ways, now that poor, martyred Toadesstern is no more. If there are any doctors (or better, veterinarians!) among us: know that Toad_in_pink_dress must be protected at all costs!
That important message having been said, at the moment I'm with Nemesis and slOosh. Johnnywup's behavior is coming across to me as townie deer in headlights, rather than amphibian-god-napping scum. On the other hand, grilling the newb to get some sort of reaction is very positive townie behavior as well. Hmph. I don't trust my own reads much.
I think we'll get the most real solid info out of the voting for day 1, as long as we avoid a no-lynch. So I plan to bandwagon on whomever can get close to enough votes. All your reads are likely to be better than mine, and that way I can hopefully prove my town-itude by being a deciding vote on a scum slaying. While this post contains a huge amount of fluff you actaully have a scummy stance on the game... 1) You think JW is a new townie player. 2) People grilling him are acting town by doing so 3) You don't trust your own reads - (don't worry just ask your team) 4) Think we're lynching for information 5) Will bandwagon anyone so we get a lynch 6) Push responsibility away from yourself What a bad post all in all. You are going about this all wrong. But hopefully you'll figure it out on your own. @VE: If this is your new style I liked your old one better.
Yes, awful post, but I'm getting more of a new town vibe off of it. It reminds me of my thought process when I started playing. (Assuming he's new, if he's not, then this turns into a VERY scummy post)
On March 18 2012 10:28 Nemesis wrote:Show nested quote +On March 18 2012 10:17 jcarlsoniv wrote:
##vote johnnywup
I shall join VE on this. My gut supa stronk.
Last post before I go out. DON'T HIDE YE IRISH SPIRIT Mind explaining your vote? I think that right now you guys are jumping on an easy bandwagon. johnnywup is a new player and this is his first game. Newbie mafias are more likely to lurk and be wishy washy with their post as you say. But he did take a stance that he thought jackal was town, which means that he is not avoiding the issue at all.
Explain my vote, eh? Well, I voted quite early in the day. Do you know why? Because I found (and still do find) his posting to be suspicious. So I placed a vote on him. I can find out information this way. But, sorry, I didn't mean to offend you and your scum buddy.
|
jcarlsoniv: Mind explaining why you find his posting scummy? You have yet to provide anything other then pretty colors (i hate colors) and a vote.
While your at it explain your red read on Nemesis?
|
Okay jdub, if you want dis unvote you gots to WORK for it. Tell me who is scum that's not you and give me reason enough to unvote you.
|
On March 18 2012 15:41 xsksc wrote:Are you seriously trying to tell me I'm scum because I called him out on bad posting? What "pre-emptive defense" are you talking about? In that quote I'm talking to VE after he called for votes on johnny, please read the thread properly. Show nested quote +On March 18 2012 15:18 slOosh wrote:
giving obvious advice about using our time without actually doing it himself
I don't understand what you mean here. It sounds like you're suggesting that I'm not taking my time? Please clarify. Also, please state why you believe johnny is town, I'd be interested to know.
Yea I don't like this post - you are sidestepping and not addressing my suspicions.
1) The meat of my suspicions was not at all on your calling out, but your behavior after that.
2) I think it's pre-emptive because you are addressing a past stance in lieu of your present stance.
3) You take half a paragraph to assert that we have a lot of time and implicitly encourage thread stagnation as you do not offer any new discussion points or "push a town agenda"
4) You completely ignore my suspicions on your 'wishy-washy on the fence' nature point in my case.
Add in some misrepresentation (painting me as someone stupid enough to try to convince someone that they are scum) and some more sidestepping (in the form of asking me for my stance without clarifying your own at all) and right now you are my #1 read.
I have already posted why I think johnnywup is town - I'd be happy to explain further but won't be doing so until you give your own stance.
|
Johnnywup's very first post raised the red flag for me:
On March 18 2012 07:41 johnnywup wrote:
I don't buy it from VE, no reason to reveal faction at this stage in the game when no one is even accusing you. You may be trying to get our subconscious trust from the very beginning.
But I don't know. You could be lying but you could be telling the truth. It's too early to say which is more likely. But I've got an eye on you.
A very wishy washy stance, but also trying to establish guilt on VE from the very start.
On March 18 2012 08:32 johnnywup wrote:
I'm not completely sure but I'm inclined more to believe he's town.
It has to do with the way he posts...he's attacking someone who accused him rather than being defensive with his words. If he knows hes innocent he has nothing to hide. The way I see it, he's thinking "if someones already accusing me, he must be scum".
Of course, I could be overthinking things. But this isn't concrete evidence, and will probably change after different events.
Again, he's ending his post with the caveat: "I could be wrong, so you don't have to listen to me."
On March 18 2012 10:40 johnnywup wrote:
i'm bad at the game first game, that might be a reason why im so bold @_@ i dont know when or when not to be bold with reads.
Using his newbie status to diffuse suspicion on him. Regardless of whether or not this is true, this reminds me VERY strongly of my play in my first and only scum game.
On March 18 2012 16:12 johnnywup wrote:
it's almost always better to trust your own reads than other peoples reads, if you don't know their role.
And yet, he doesn't seem very confident in his own reads.
Johnnywup claims that he is very new to the game, and yet he appears to have a pretty good head on his shoulders when it comes to ideals and posting in the game. However, he is not doing so as a townie. He's climbin' in yo' windows, snatchin' yo people up. He'll lay suspicion on someone, but also disregard his own post by not being firm on it.
Nemesis is a gut read for now.
|
I feel you jcarlson, fo rilla.
I'm willing to entertain Nemesis as a secondary candidate, but I'd like to see more of his posting that isn't just defending jdub.
|
Hmmm, it seems that snarfs and sandroba hasn't posted yet. Hopefully they don't get modkilled as 18 hours have passed since the game has started.
Probulous, I just took a quick look at your history, and you are usually a lot more helpful when you are not scum. You still haven't even made the list you promised before the game started.
Since we're on the subject, we might as well get more discussion. What does the rest of you think about VE's case on jonnywup? That is Jackal, Probulous, and whoever else who haven't given their opinion.
|
Explain my vote, eh? Well, I voted quite early in the day. Do you know why? Because I found (and still do find) his posting to be suspicious. So I placed a vote on him. I can find out information this way. But, sorry, I didn't mean to offend you and your scum buddy.
And what exactly have you found out since you voted for him since you haven't even questioned him one bit?
|
On March 19 2012 01:29 Nemesis wrote:Show nested quote +Explain my vote, eh? Well, I voted quite early in the day. Do you know why? Because I found (and still do find) his posting to be suspicious. So I placed a vote on him. I can find out information this way. But, sorry, I didn't mean to offend you and your scum buddy. And what exactly have you found out since you voted for him since you haven't even questioned him one bit?
I've found out that, when put under pressure, johnnywup has been very keen on trying to clear his name, claiming he's just vanilla townie, and being very defensive in general. If he REALLY wants people to look elsewhere, he needs to start scumhunting for his own sake instead of just trying to be innocent.
Innocent people don't feel the need to be innocent. Guilty people do.
|
On March 19 2012 01:34 jcarlsoniv wrote:Show nested quote +On March 19 2012 01:29 Nemesis wrote:Explain my vote, eh? Well, I voted quite early in the day. Do you know why? Because I found (and still do find) his posting to be suspicious. So I placed a vote on him. I can find out information this way. But, sorry, I didn't mean to offend you and your scum buddy. And what exactly have you found out since you voted for him since you haven't even questioned him one bit? I've found out that, when put under pressure, johnnywup has been very keen on trying to clear his name, claiming he's just vanilla townie, and being very defensive in general. If he REALLY wants people to look elsewhere, he needs to start scumhunting for his own sake instead of just trying to be innocent. Innocent people don't feel the need to be innocent. Guilty people do.
UMM NO, that is very horrible reasoning. People get defensive no matter what their role is when put under pressure. Take a look at chaoser in Mafia Factory where he was town and got lynched for being overly defensive. You are doing the same stupid shit here.
|
Let me ask you this Nemesis. How would you expect a newbScum to react to the pressure I've been applying? You seem to know exactly how a newbTown would react, so surely the converse is true as well, yes?
|
On March 19 2012 01:54 VisceraEyes wrote:
Let me ask you this Nemesis. How would you expect a newbScum to react to the pressure I've been applying? You seem to know exactly how a newbTown would react, so surely the converse is true as well, yes?
What I am saying is that your case against him is crap, and does not reveal his alignment. All it reveals is that he is a newbie player.
|
I like that you dodged answering my question Nemesis. I also like how you seem to not have an opinion on his alignment, in spite of expending all this energy attempting (and failing) to discredit my case against him.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/T5JzT.png)
