|
ST_Bomber IMNestea SlayerSAlicia IMMVP MarinekingPrime oGsMC IMLosira ST_July SlayerSMMA MVP.Dongraegu SlayersRyung SlayerSMin oGsSupernova HungUnPrime anyproPrime oGsInCa oGsNada MVP.Genius MVP.Keen sC.fOu NSHoseo.san TSL.Fruitdealer TSL.Revival LiquidJinro MVP.GuineaPig
This is my ranking based on all Korean matches i've seen in the past 3 months, while more recent matches have more impact.
|
NesTea ... hmm, thinking ... hmm, can`t decide. ... NesTea again? ... yeah!!!
|
Great idea for a thread =)
I'm expecting it be pretty obvious that the top 5 will be some mix of MVP, MKP, Bomber, Nestea, and MC. (Don't bash on MC because of the supertournament result, everyone has their bad games) But it will be interesting to see other people's rankings for the bottom 10.
I'm surprised that so many people are ranking Inca. He's probably top 3 PvP in the world, but from what we've seen of his other matchups he's mediocre at best. I think the only notable non-Protoss he's defeated is Nada. And even then I feel like those were games that Nada lost, instead of Inca won.
It'll also be interesting to see how people rank Dongraegu. I think he's the top contender outside of Code S/A.
|
On May 28 2011 07:36 kNightLite wrote: Great idea for a thread =)
I'm expecting it be pretty obvious that the top 5 will be some mix of MVP, MKP, Bomber, Nestea, and MC. (Don't bash on MC because of the supertournament result, everyone has their bad games) But it will be interesting to see other people's rankings for the bottom 10.
I'm surprised that so many people are ranking Inca. He's probably top 3 PvP in the world, but from what we've seen of his other matchups he's mediocre at best. I think the only notable non-Protoss he's defeated is Nada. And even then I feel like those were games that Nada lost, instead of Inca won.
It'll also be interesting to see how people rank Dongraegu. I think he's the top contender outside of Code S/A.
wow spoiler alert dude
|
really hard to rank as the GSL format makes it possible that very good players are actually not in code S (leenock, dongreagu etc.).
The top 5 for me would be: 1. Nestea 2. ST_Bomber 3. MVP 4. MKP 5. MC
|
Any of you guys live in Korea? Looking for someone to go check out the tourney with in 목동.
|
I'm surprised at how few people have mentioned TOP and HongUn, both very underrated imo.
|
On May 28 2011 09:30 caradoc wrote: I'm surprised at how few people have mentioned TOP and HongUn, both very underrated imo.
i put top at 14 on my list. i think just above san at 15.
|
1. Nestea 2. MC 3. MVP 4. Bomber 5. MMA 6. Nada 7. Losira 8. Alicia (my personal favorite, along with HuK) 9. DRG 10. July
That's just a top 10. Theirs a handful of good protoss - Anypro, San, Hongun, and Genius that float in the mid teens, a few good terran - Jinro, Supernova, TOP, Ryung, and a couple of zerg - Zenio, Min that float around the same level. Shout out to HuK, who if he wins tonight I'd rank in that group of protoss . Beating MMA in a bo3 is no easy feat, and his only losses in televised games are to Losira (2nd best ZvP in the world) and Inca (best PvP in the world). So I feel like he's massively underrated atm.
|
On May 28 2011 09:30 caradoc wrote: I'm surprised at how few people have mentioned TOP and HongUn, both very underrated imo.
Hey, I put TOP in my ranking! I had him around 10th or so I believe. ^^
|
United States23455 Posts
Keep sending them in. More than likely will close off the lists by the end of the Ro64 or a day or two day after that.
|
On May 27 2011 07:55 1Eris1 wrote:Show nested quote +On May 27 2011 02:42 TheDougler wrote:On May 26 2011 15:17 Novalisk wrote:1. Nestea 2. MC 3. MVP + Show Spoiler + 4. Bomber 5. MarineKingPrime 6. Nada 7. July 8. Inca 9. Losira 10. sC 11. MMA 12. DongRaeGoo 13. AnyPro 14. Keen 15. HuK
I love HuK but why does he and Keen make the list when Jinro does not? Neither HuK or Jinro are anywhere near top 15 material atm
Jinro has been lackluster for a while now, even though he's one of my favorite players he has a lot to prove. HuK just made it into Code S with MMA and MKP in his group, and + Show Spoiler +recently beat San to progress into the RO32 of the Super Tournament.
|
On May 28 2011 05:04 supersoft wrote: ST_Bomber IMNestea SlayerSAlicia IMMVP MarinekingPrime oGsMC IMLosira ST_July SlayerSMMA MVP.Dongraegu SlayersRyung SlayerSMin oGsSupernova HungUnPrime anyproPrime oGsInCa oGsNada MVP.Genius MVP.Keen sC.fOu NSHoseo.san TSL.Fruitdealer TSL.Revival LiquidJinro MVP.GuineaPig
This is my ranking based on all Korean matches i've seen in the past 3 months, while more recent matches have more impact. That's a pretty good list I think
|
mh I think the top10 players named in this thread really are these guys...
ST_Bomber IMNestea SlayerSAlicia IMMVP MarinekingPrime oGsMC ST_July SlayerSMMA IMLosira MVP.Dongraegu
would be great if we had a powerrank for sc2. I made this topic up I think about a half year ago, but everyone told me that it was too early... But since we have some really consistent pros like MKP, MC, Alicia, MVP, Bomber, July and Nestea it's getting easier to compare the players.
|
United States23455 Posts
Still going through the mounds of votes.
Keep sending them in. Might end it in two days after the final day of Ro64 or a day or two after Ro32.
|
bump data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c81e3/c81e334f952fa6a3b77a0f55297a8c05972c04b5" alt="" time for the last votes! everyone who hasn't seen this and hasn't voted: take 5min and do it!
|
Just sent mine in! I'm really curious how things will shape up
|
United States23455 Posts
Did not forget this. Still gathering votes. data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c81e3/c81e334f952fa6a3b77a0f55297a8c05972c04b5" alt=""
Please continue sending them in.
|
Ro64 just ended, should really stop now as peoples opinions will definitely change after tonight's HUGE games.
|
United States97274 Posts
On June 01 2011 16:04 Kiyo. wrote: Ro64 just ended, should really stop now as peoples opinions will definitely change after tonight's HUGE games. I know you shouldn't base things off 1 series, but Bomber vs Nestea is going to be HUGE for people's opinions
|
|
|
|