As for the interviews themselves, I really enjoy how in-depth you go, keep it up.
Official CSN Coverage Thread - Page 3
Forum Index > SC2 General |
StallingHard
144 Posts
As for the interviews themselves, I really enjoy how in-depth you go, keep it up. | ||
Shiv.
3534 Posts
This rachel girl just isn't much of a good reporter. I only watched HuK&IdrA, but she seems to be a little too shy in front of the camera and in fact was biased. Telling IdrA his memory is acknowledgeable is fine, but really, I as a viewer of those interviews do not care at all what she thinks about certain things. If you want to comment, get some casting going. Still: I think it's great they covered so many players and such. Keep the work coming, keep improving. | ||
StallingHard
144 Posts
On April 07 2011 13:14 Shiv. wrote: I love the fact they're doing something for the community, but what I think disturbed the whole picture a bit was the following: This rachel girl just isn't much of a good reporter. I only watched HuK&IdrA, but she seems to be a little too shy in front of the camera and in fact was biased. Telling IdrA his memory is acknowledgeable is fine, but really, I as a viewer of those interviews do not care at all what she thinks about certain things. If you want to comment, get some casting going. Still: I think it's great they covered so many players and such. Keep the work coming, keep improving. I'd argue that we should have personalized reporters instead of robot-like reporters. I care what the personalities think, but, to each his own and there are going to be people who have differing opinions. I don't think she was too shy, either. I can see why you'd feel this way, though. To Rachel: Having your hair the way you do creates the feeling for the viewer that you may not be looking into the camera as much (because it covers half of your face). I'd suggest pulling your hair back, or straightening it and letting it fall flat (the pulled back approach is considered more professional, though) Edit: Oh yeah, look at the camera more, not the person you're interviewing. | ||
Shiv.
3534 Posts
On April 07 2011 13:21 StallingHard wrote: I'd argue that we should have personalized reporters instead of robot-like reporters. I care what the personalities think, but, to each his own and there are going to be people who have differing opinions. I don't think she was too shy, either. I can see why you'd feel this way, though. To Rachel: Having your hair the way you do creates the feeling for the viewer that you may not be looking into the camera as much (because it covers half of your face). I'd suggest pulling your hair back, or straightening it and letting it fall flat (the pulled back approach is considered more professional, though) Edit: Oh yeah, look at the camera more, not the person you're interviewing. Approaching journalism on different levels is nothing to fight about, I guess - I personally would have liked it more if she just would have kept interviewing IdrA normally and telling him about how she feels about him later. Maybe I am just spoiled, but I just think if you are doing an interview, you shouldn't have people yelling the stuff you wanted to say at you or even express personal feelings. Then again, that is just me - I, for example, also had the feeling the interviews I have seen (HuK&IdrA, can only comment on those) were greatly focussed on the drama between the both of them. I would rather watch SC II interviews like Sport Center instead of some generic sudser. This obviously is a bit exaggerated, but you get the point. Concerning her being shy: I just rewatched an interview and I figured it had something to do with the way she wears her hair. You pointed that out pretty well. | ||
Torte de Lini
Germany38463 Posts
Lovely videos by the way, Is Torch the cameraman? | ||
StallingHard
144 Posts
On April 07 2011 13:29 Shiv. wrote: Approaching journalism on different levels is nothing to fight about, I guess - I personally would have liked it more if she just would have kept interviewing IdrA normally and telling him about how she feels about him later. Maybe I am just spoiled, but I just think if you are doing an interview, you shouldn't have people yelling the stuff you wanted to say at you or even express personal feelings. Then again, that is just me - I, for example, also had the feeling the interviews I have seen (HuK&IdrA, can only comment on those) were greatly focussed on the drama between the both of them. I would rather watch SC II interviews like Sport Center instead of some generic sudser. This obviously is a bit exaggerated, but you get the point. Concerning her being shy: I just rewatched an interview and I figured it had something to do with the way she wears her hair. You pointed that out pretty well. I can agree with you to a certain extent, and a lot of people are going to feel like you do. | ||
Shiv.
3534 Posts
On April 07 2011 13:48 StallingHard wrote: I can agree with you to a certain extent, and a lot of people are going to feel like you do. Wow, what a nice alternation of what usually happens when people on the interwebz have different opinions on a certain topic ![]() | ||
SeltzerPlease
United States191 Posts
On April 07 2011 13:48 StallingHard wrote: I can agree with you to a certain extent, and a lot of people are going to feel like you do. I appreciate the feedback as I am always looking to improve! Unfortunately for some whose tastes lie more towards completely unbiased reporting, I am still a fan and will have my favorites, but my main goal is to let the players tell their own stories. Please keep watching and letting us know what you would like to see! ![]() | ||
CrunchtimeSC
United States40 Posts
| ||
csa_andrew
United States334 Posts
| ||
SeltzerPlease
United States191 Posts
| ||
Primadog
United States4411 Posts
| ||
FishStix
United States425 Posts
| ||
![]()
bkrow
Australia8532 Posts
![]() Anna > 4th place at MLG :p OT: Thanks for the content Rachel really awesome to see all this stuff! | ||
HEROwithNOlegacy
United States850 Posts
| ||
StrinterN
Denmark531 Posts
hahaha, great interviews ![]() | ||
Piy
Scotland3152 Posts
![]() EDIT: I like how the interviews follow him through and intercut with him playing - gives a much more dynamic feeling to the videos. | ||
-Exalt-
United States972 Posts
Torch is a lucky guy ![]() | ||
csa_andrew
United States334 Posts
Thread: COTH StarTale House | ||
Davidmu
28 Posts
On April 07 2011 13:21 StallingHard wrote: I'd argue that we should have personalized reporters instead of robot-like reporters. I care what the personalities think, but, to each his own and there are going to be people who have differing opinions. I don't think she was too shy, either. I can see why you'd feel this way, though. To Rachel: Having your hair the way you do creates the feeling for the viewer that you may not be looking into the camera as much (because it covers half of your face). I'd suggest pulling your hair back, or straightening it and letting it fall flat (the pulled back approach is considered more professional, though) Edit: Oh yeah, look at the camera more, not the person you're interviewing. Don't do what this person says and look at the camera. EdwardStarcraft does that in some of his interviews and it looks stupid. | ||
| ||