EPTI can't say how much I disdain each of you who gives so much hate to everyone except day9 (I literally "can't say" because it would get me banned....); of course there is always room for improvement, but this is going way overboard and has nothing to do with constructive criticism
MLG Raleigh Ultimate Feedback Thread - Page 17
| Forum Index > SC2 General |
|
sleepingdog
Austria6145 Posts
I can't say how much I disdain each of you who gives so much hate to everyone except day9 (I literally "can't say" because it would get me banned....); of course there is always room for improvement, but this is going way overboard and has nothing to do with constructive criticism | ||
|
stylepoints
Trinidad/Tobago22 Posts
And yes, one of the supposed "top casters" can't even pronounce a handful of the units' names correctly. How are we supposed to take them seriously. | ||
|
Fadetowhite
Korea (South)302 Posts
| ||
|
Snowfield
1289 Posts
| ||
|
Proxyles
Sweden27 Posts
This does not encourage me or anyone I know to pay for the better quality stream, if we think that we are going to get ripped off. Other that that it was a great event, I even stopped being angry at the stream issue after a while due to day[9]s and JPs shenanigans and excellent work. TLDR- If you sell HQ stream, make sure the stream is HQ Commentators good, games good | ||
|
Proxyles
Sweden27 Posts
On August 31 2010 19:08 Novac wrote: As for the event in general. When it says HD I expect HD. To me this is at least 720p. I think I logged in 20 times just to make sure that I was actually watching the HD stream I had payed for. Also the way you logged into the HD stream was incredibly confusing. I don't know what it is with e-Sport sites and crappy layout and design but I cannot for the life of me figure out why the site doesn't have a dedicated streaming page made to maximize the overview of the event and separate it completely from the rest of the other events of the MLG page. The GOMtv.net page is awful in this regard as well. Also, keep the paying customers i.e. the HD stream on a different server from the regular stream to prevent crashes. When I pay for a service I should get it or receive a refund. Fortunately I got into the stream after about an hour and a half into the event but it still shouldn't happen. Did you actually see ANY difference between the HD and not HD stream? Me and my 4 friends that all watched this together could not. | ||
|
TyPsi5
United States204 Posts
no random seeding | ||
|
jackalope
Taiwan120 Posts
On August 31 2010 20:37 Proxyles wrote: Did you actually see ANY difference between the HD and not HD stream? Me and my 4 friends that all watched this together could not. damn that is shady. | ||
|
Wargizmo
Australia1237 Posts
On August 31 2010 19:25 sleepingdog wrote: people will probably not stop complaining about casters until everyone except day9 has stopped casting - then day9 decides to quit e-sports one day and LOL we are left with nothing I can't say how much I disdain each of you who gives so much hate to everyone except day9 (I literally "can't say" because it would get me banned....); of course there is always room for improvement, but this is going way overboard and has nothing to do with constructive criticism Yep, it seems like basically a lot of people from TL want to see Day9 and no one else. Everyone who isn't Day9 is just going to cop heavy criticism no matter who they are, be it dApollo, HD, Husky or whoever just for taking air time away from Day9. JP has the right idea, he pretty much just gives Day9 most of the mic time adding the occasional insight or play by play but without trying to inflict his own personality on the casts, he still cops tons of criticism but not nearly as much as the others. Husky and HD try to add a lot more of their own personalities and they get burned for it because they're not Day9. | ||
|
Obstbaum
Switzerland224 Posts
On August 30 2010 05:41 itzbrandnew wrote: 3) JP and Sean were so good together... but you know what duo would be perfect? Chill/Sean... I think I just wet myself putting those two names together like that. Make it happen. Id love to see this one ;D Also Totalhalibut/sean would be great!! | ||
|
stylepoints
Trinidad/Tobago22 Posts
Tasteless and artosis for instance are great casters. | ||
|
d_so
Korea (South)3262 Posts
On August 31 2010 13:20 Usurper wrote: All the casters except Day9 were lacking. I am really saddened if those 3 continue to be the "standing elite" of StarCraft II casters, without major improvements. Cause their blabbering sure made me facepalm all the time during the few matches i watched. The critique here is with no pun intended but if someone does get offended, i think this quote i've read on some user here, will shine bright: "People should be less concerned with whether or not they are being insulted, and more concerned with whether or not it's the truth." Day9 He is the king of goofiness and nerdiness in casual and innocent way. He has a style and a vibe, and a vision, and he is never boring even when he is sharing his mundane thoughts that are passing through his head. He's really kind of a monolith in the StarCraft II world. Husky I remember watching your StarCraft I commentaries when you were starting up, and they were really fun. You fail miserably in duo though. No connection with the co-caster, fake hyping all the time and repeating things bazillion times, things like "I can't wait" blagh blagh... Besides your few sentence gems, your overall performance was far from good. JP This guy i noticed on the Day9 countdown party, and i can not see anything why i would like to watch this guy. I mean hes not obnoxious to watch, but he is 0 on the 0-10 entertaining scale. All he does it seems is get by Day9 with just being nerd interested in StarCraft 2. No style, no perceivable passion, no substance in the sentences. Seriously man, what are you doing in the casting world? HD Eewwwwww... How do i say this without you guys thinking it's misplaced angst... Oh well i'll try... You man, are seriously obnoxious to listen to. I think the reason for that i can distribute to your sleaky voice (which might be subjective thing by far), but your sentence construction is in pair with that voice. Now, i know that you might not be able to change voices or something, but i seriously will avoid your commentaries in the future. The players in the tournament were great. Was rooting for the Protoss trio, Kiwikaki, HuK and my main favorite Socke. Darn dude, you put up a hell of a fight, i will closely watch your next appearances. Cheers this post needs to be called out for being fucking horrible. | ||
|
Snowfield
1289 Posts
On August 31 2010 20:37 Proxyles wrote: Did you actually see ANY difference between the HD and not HD stream? Me and my 4 friends that all watched this together could not. I didn't atleast. | ||
|
stylepoints
Trinidad/Tobago22 Posts
Is it nice to have a great caster like day9? yes. Is it required? Not at all. | ||
|
sleepingdog
Austria6145 Posts
On August 31 2010 19:34 stylepoints wrote: The problem is sleepingdog, that I have never heard you speak, you could even be in bronze league, and I would rather have you casting the games than husky. I am diamond and certainly play "a bit" more than HD with his one game per week; the problem is: I have no interest in devoting my time to casting whatsoever; I'm a teaching and research assistent for law in Austria and can't spend time casting my point is, that many people "claim" that they could do better, but apparantly everybody has better things to do - therefore we should be grateful that there are at least some who cast somewhat regularly furthermore I get the feeling that many of you don't know how all this "casting"-stuff actually started, despite playing the ICCup for a long time; I remember the time before youtube where you just got a replay and an audio-file you could download; then the caster in the audio-file would do something like "game starting in 3-2-1" and right now you had to click "unpause" in the game; you had to move the game-view yourself so many times you didn't look at the right spot the caster was talking about; pausing, forwarding, reviewing, etc. was impossible - you would have to paus the game, alt/tab and pause the audio-file; but then they would be out of synchro nevertheless I was still HAPPY because FINALLY there was a "voice"...somebody who would talk about the stuff that happened and explained things that were going on; nowadays things are so much greater especially due to youtube, I can't even think how I survived back then; but instead of appreciating the rapid progress of coverage which is the main part of e-sport all people do is complain, complain, complain and complain; not contributing constructive criticism but just spelling "this, this and this sucks" in 15093715 different ways; honestly, during the casts of HD and husky I sometimes stopped reading here because all the hatred gave me stomachache | ||
|
stylepoints
Trinidad/Tobago22 Posts
I don't think I could play basketball better than Nenad Krstic, but I know enough to know that he sucks at the pro level. | ||
|
d_so
Korea (South)3262 Posts
On August 31 2010 21:37 stylepoints wrote: No see you are missing the point entirely. I don't think I could do it better, that's why I don't. I DO know however that he sucks. His voice is annoying. He sounds like someone is beating a baby with a cat. And at least find someone who can pronounce zergling and zealot to replace HD. I don't think I could play basketball better than Nenad Krstic, but I know enough to know that he sucks at the pro level. no but what "sucks" in pro basketball can be measured quantitatively. You cannot measure the "annoying"-ness of someone's voice. That's your opinion, of which you are entitled to but if you're deluded into thinking your opinion is some sort of truth, well wake the fuck up and welcome to the real world cuz you are wrong~ | ||
|
stylepoints
Trinidad/Tobago22 Posts
It reminds me of the movie Dumb and Dumber, "the most annoying sound in the world" part. | ||
|
d_so
Korea (South)3262 Posts
On August 31 2010 21:47 stylepoints wrote: Oh I'm sure someone somewhere has done a study on what vocal ranges are the most annoying to the average human ear, making it quantitatively provable. Even ignoring the possibility of quantitative evidence, the amount of people in this very thread complaining should be evidence of something. It reminds me of the movie Dumb and Dumber, "the most annoying sound in the world" part. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0cVlTeIATBs once again, i'm sorry to burst your bubble, but your opinions are not fact. There are 144 instances of the word "husky" in this thread. I searched through all of them. They are not all negative, in fact, there seems to be a healthy balance between the two. Should the positive comments be ignored because they don't fit with your opinion? Should we go test Husky's voice to make sure it's not in your hypothetical vocal range regarding annoying voices? Or maybe it'd just be simpler to have you stfu and stop forwarding what you "know" as fact. You're entitled to your opinion, and this thread is asking for your feedback, of which bitching is a subset. That's fine. But stop talking like you have any sort of authoritative knowledge in this situation. Thanks. | ||
tofucake
Hyrule19057 Posts
2. Octoshape is P2P. Telling people they need to pay $10 for HD is kind of a greedy move. 3. When you offer an HD stream, make sure it's actually HD. 4. ![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/HJhZL.png) 5. People at the live event got to see FPV, but nobody at home did. I'd like to see some FPV every now and then. 6. Map overviews were kind of useless in the finals as all 4 commentators had already stated everything in them numerous times over the past 2 days. 7. More interviews would be great. 8. Get HuK a stool? 9. I don't know how feasible it is, but get some better chairs for the players? They are there playing all day, and even 10 minutes on one of those chairs is really uncomfortable. | ||
| ||
