| Forum Index > SC2 General |
|
flodeskum
Iceland1267 Posts
On May 11 2011 10:24 Jiddra wrote: The show , yes, the pillars, no. Why talk about that things is happening behind the scenes that adds to them not getting togheter? Because what's happening behind the scenes is that JP is playing brink and sean is graduating. Not really the end of the world. | ||
|
kckkryptonite
1126 Posts
...but my god Day9 got destroyed by Grack. He also looked like he was thinkin' "Damnit Nick" when the other Plott jumped back on to say Idra is right, lol. One of my fav eps, | ||
|
turdburgler
England6749 Posts
On May 11 2011 17:49 kckkryptonite wrote: Love the arguments, makes the show more interesting and raw. I don't care so much about who's right, nice to hear real opinions, even if conflicting ones. ...but my god Day9 got destroyed by Grack. He also looked like he was thinkin' "Damnit Nick" when the other Plott jumped back on to say Idra is right, lol. One of my fav eps, i cant believe there are people this stupid who maintain such a long attention span. noone got destroyed. they were arguing completely different ideas, and if you think the game is figured out enough to make massive imba whaa whaa claims you obviously never heard of brood war | ||
|
JKira
Canada1002 Posts
| ||
|
goiflin
Canada1218 Posts
On May 11 2011 20:06 turdburgler wrote: i cant believe there are people this stupid who maintain such a long attention span. noone got destroyed. they were arguing completely different ideas, and if you think the game is figured out enough to make massive imba whaa whaa claims you obviously never heard of brood war There's no reason to start insulting people for their opinion. Day9 was basically stuck in an infinite loop, when the onus was on him to respond to the question: how does zerg scout, or what all-purpose can zerg build to hold all the different pressure builds that the other two races can put out. Basically, all he could say was that it wasn't productive to whine about imba, and while I agree with him in that extent, that's dodging the questions because he has no answer. Saying you should try something new, without giving any suggestions is silly. | ||
|
RvB
Netherlands6274 Posts
On May 11 2011 20:19 goiflin wrote: There's no reason to start insulting people for their opinion. Day9 was basically stuck in an infinite loop, when the onus was on him to respond to the question: how does zerg scout, or what all-purpose can zerg build to hold all the different pressure builds that the other two races can put out. Basically, all he could say was that it wasn't productive to whine about imba, and while I agree with him in that extent, that's dodging the questions because he has no answer. Saying you should try something new, without giving any suggestions is silly. well what idra said was quite vague, not being able to scout early how can day9 respond to that? He has no replays or something he has really nothing to comment on but theorycraft. And basically you can say the weak things for all races and make them seem up while that isn't the case of course. | ||
|
Novalisk
Israel1818 Posts
| ||
|
Tschis
Brazil1511 Posts
On May 11 2011 20:27 RvB wrote: well what idra said was quite vague, not being able to scout early how can day9 respond to that? He has no replays or something he has really nothing to comment on but theorycraft. And basically you can say the weak things for all races and make them seem up while that isn't the case of course. IdrA was quite specific and you don't need replays to comment on something. | ||
|
kardinal
Sweden154 Posts
| ||
|
ComusLoM
Norway3547 Posts
 | ||
|
Mahs
Netherlands171 Posts
| ||
|
Antisocialmunky
United States5912 Posts
On May 11 2011 20:12 JKira wrote: I wish they did SoTG today and provided live analysis of GSL Up and Down matches live. It would be interesting if someone did podcast commentary tracks of the GSL matches. While you can't do commentary vods, some high level commentary would be good... | ||
|
Uhh Negative
United States1090 Posts
On May 11 2011 20:33 kardinal wrote: Day[9] Daily #303 - Zerg Scouting Without Scouting! Yeah too bad any top zerg already does this. This is great for newer players but it doesn't fix anything. Guessing what an opponent doesn't have based on what he does have is very basic for top players. I'm not implying that you are implying anything about the episode, either. I can just see people watching that episode though and thinking, "If only zergs did this". | ||
|
DARKHYDRA
United States303 Posts
| ||
|
altered
Switzerland646 Posts
| ||
|
mcc
Czech Republic4646 Posts
On May 11 2011 20:31 Tschis wrote: IdrA was quite specific and you don't need replays to comment on something. Actually no, Idra was vague a lot. When Day9 said vague I think he meant that you cannot discuss problems of scouting without also mentioning the map and matchup, that was why he was saying that without replay you cannot discuss it. And Idra(and others also I think) did not understand at all the point that Day9 was trying to get across(or was just playing stupid to further his agenda). And yes they were talking about 3 different things or rather on 3 different levels of abstraction. Most of what Day9 said was on the totally abstract level of game balance in general and the rest was him pointing to Idra that discussing balance(scouting) is not possible in short time and without specific replay/map. On the other hand Idra was talking about "specific" problems on some middle level of abstraction. In my opinion his "specific" examples are only good as catchphrases for identifying problematic areas, but Day9 was correct in that discussing scouting without replay or at least a map is pointless as nothing reasonable can be said. | ||
|
Mercadia
United States257 Posts
On May 11 2011 20:31 Tschis wrote: IdrA was quite specific and you don't need replays to comment on something. Yeah man, screw evidence. IdrA should never accept day's offer of doing an in-depth discussion about the matter with replays. Specific (or vague) venting is much more productive than, say, doing a special daily with Day on the subject. It'd probably be one of the most popular dailies ever. I bet there would be a drinking game made for it and everything. | ||
|
staples2
United States216 Posts
| ||
|
L3g3nd_
New Zealand10461 Posts
was really looking forward to it. | ||
|
mordek
United States12705 Posts
On May 12 2011 04:18 mcc wrote: Actually no, Idra was vague a lot. When Day9 said vague I think he meant that you cannot discuss problems of scouting without also mentioning the map and matchup, that was why he was saying that without replay you cannot discuss it. And Idra(and others also I think) did not understand at all the point that Day9 was trying to get across(or was just playing stupid to further his agenda). And yes they were talking about 3 different things or rather on 3 different levels of abstraction. Most of what Day9 said was on the totally abstract level of game balance in general and the rest was him pointing to Idra that discussing balance(scouting) is not possible in short time and without specific replay/map. On the other hand Idra was talking about "specific" problems on some middle level of abstraction. In my opinion his "specific" examples are only good as catchphrases for identifying problematic areas, but Day9 was correct in that discussing scouting without replay or at least a map is pointless as nothing reasonable can be said. This was well said. I could understand what Greg was saying and his frustrations but honestly there was no where for that conversation to go. Day tried to point that out but I'm guessing this came across as dismissing the issue. There is no doubt an issue. Whether it's broken or imbalanced is not a discussion that can be fruitful in that situation. Now if Greg wanted to get together with Day and look at replays/maps/specific instances than there is zero doubt in my mind Day would have happily done that. It's what he loves! When I listened I heard whining, not unjustified or even immature whining. Just whining without the possibility of something that is actually constructive coming out of it. My two cents. | ||
| ||
StarCraft 2 StarCraft: Brood War League of Legends Heroes of the Storm Other Games |
|
Patches Events
GSL
Cure vs herO
SHIN vs Maru
IPSL
Bonyth vs Napoleon
G5 vs JDConan
BSL
OyAji vs JDConan
DragOn vs TBD
Replay Cast
Monday Night Weeklies
Replay Cast
The PondCast
Kung Fu Cup
GSL
[ Show More ] |
|
|
EPT
