EPThttp://www.bbc.com/sport/0/football/32422362
According to these rules the russian champion will be guaranteed a first seed, possibly at the expense of Barca/Real.
Champions League & Europa League 2014-15 Thread - Page 183
| Forum Index > Sports |
|
Mafe
Germany5966 Posts
http://www.bbc.com/sport/0/football/32422362 According to these rules the russian champion will be guaranteed a first seed, possibly at the expense of Barca/Real. | ||
|
RvB
Netherlands6292 Posts
Edit: it's a decent change but in the end it doesn't really do a lot to close the gap between the top and the rest. There's just too much money going around nowadays. | ||
|
Acrofales
Spain18366 Posts
On April 23 2015 06:15 Mafe wrote: Any opinions on this change: http://www.bbc.com/sport/0/football/32422362 According to these rules the russian champion will be guaranteed a first seed, possibly at the expense of Barca/Real. I think it is completely justified. While I don't think it will make much difference by the time you reach the quarters, I think it will make the groups a lot more interesting, giving "smaller" teams who win a strong local league a shot at qualifying without running the risk of getting put in a group they have no chance in. The champions of the top 7 leagues plus the previous winner seems like a more interesting way to seed than the top 8 teams regardless of league (which could end with something as ridiculous as Barça, RM and Atletico all getting a pot 1 seed). | ||
|
aseq
Netherlands4008 Posts
Picture this happening then: Group A: Bayern, Barca (2nd, lol steve), Liverpool (pot 3 2014), AS Roma (pot 4 2014) Group B: Zenit, Basel (pot 2 2014), Olympiakos (pot 3 2014), Malmo (pot 4 2014). Group C: PSV, Shakhtar, Bilbao, Maribor (same as group B) I only think it adds to the group randomness and it doesn't really add something at all. Yes, some average teams could now make it out of their group, but I think the amount of boring RO16 matches is big enough as it is now. | ||
|
Acrofales
Spain18366 Posts
On April 23 2015 09:46 aseq wrote: I'm not sure. What happens when Real win the Liga, does that mean the nr.8 league (Dutch?) winner get a top seed as well? Picture this happening then: Group A: Bayern, Barca (2nd, lol steve), Liverpool (pot 3 2014), AS Roma (pot 4 2014) Group B: Zenit, Basel (pot 2 2014), Olympiakos (pot 3 2014), Malmo (pot 4 2014). Group C: PSV, Shakhtar, Bilbao, Maribor (same as group B) I only think it adds to the group randomness and it doesn't really add something at all. Yes, some average teams could now make it out of their group, but I think the amount of boring RO16 matches is big enough as it is now. Only if Real wins the league and the CL. The same can be said for Barça (more likely, imho) or Bayern (league is pretty much won already). Hell, even Juve could fit the bill, although I don´t see them reaching the finals vs. any of the other 3 teams, let alone winning it. As for your horror scenario, I still think it´s better to have a good mix, and give more league champions a better chance at getting to the Ro16. It would simply make the Ro16 more interesting than having it be dominated by the Spanish and English teams (who will be there anyway, but they might have to work a bit harder in the groups). | ||
|
Black Gun
Germany4482 Posts
On April 23 2015 09:46 aseq wrote: I'm not sure. What happens when Real win the Liga, does that mean the nr.8 league (Dutch?) winner get a top seed as well? Picture this happening then: Group A: Bayern, Barca (2nd, lol steve), Liverpool (pot 3 2014), AS Roma (pot 4 2014) Group B: Zenit, Basel (pot 2 2014), Olympiakos (pot 3 2014), Malmo (pot 4 2014). Group C: PSV, Shakhtar, Bilbao, Maribor (same as group B) I only think it adds to the group randomness and it doesn't really add something at all. Yes, some average teams could now make it out of their group, but I think the amount of boring RO16 matches is big enough as it is now. well, at first glance, it seems to be a nerf for leagues like the spanish and the portuguese one where two very strong teams take turns at the championship, but are both internationally competitive with a high uefa ranking. in reality, teams like barca or bayern (should they ever lose a bundesliga title again...) will make it out of the group stage, even if they are drawn to each other. the real loser of this new seeding system are those big but not quite big enough clubs, say liverpool, dortmund, arsenal or lyon, that draw the short end of the stick and get drawn into one group with barca and bayern. their bad fortune is the price to pay for other teams of their own or even lower caliber that get lucky and cruise to the ro16 in ridiculously easy groups. (only to get roflstomped by the big teams, just now one round later...) but oh well, everything is more interesting than this year's barca/psg/dontevenrememberlol group, or last years bayern/city/bate/cska group (with a difference of 12 points between the 2nd and 3rd place team... 12 points after 6 matchdays...) sure, most fans wont care about who advances from a zenit/basel/olympiakos/malmö group, but with groups like that, one can at least not say "see you at knockout stage" right after the group drawings. so overall, i approve this change. it will make the group stage slightly more interesting. but the semis will continue to consist of "[3 out of bayern/barca/real/chelsea] + 1 outsider team from a top4 league". | ||
|
ViperPL
Poland1775 Posts
I'm really glad Juventus made it all the way to the semis, though the games against Monaco weren't too impressive or interesting. Maybe they can beat Real! EDIT: Actually now that I think about it those new seeding rules won't really change all that much. Teams from pots 1 and 2 will still remain so for the most part, only portuguese and russian teams in pot 1 are out of place but that will just make two pot2 teams lucky and that's it. We won't suddenly get an invasion of mediocre teams from mediocre leagues or a group with Real, Bayern, Juve and PSG. | ||
Pandemona
Charlie Sheens House51493 Posts
Champions League RO8 - Day 4 Results ![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/TzoOseo.png) (0) 1-0 (0) ![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/q1hoQG7.png) Hernandez 88' ![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/xdegOgO.png) (0) 0-0 (1) ![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/9XsILtH.png) Real Madrid & Juventus advance to Semi Finals! | ||
|
sharkie
Austria18701 Posts
They beat the most difficult opponent in the quarterfinals and did so in a pretty commanding way (not dominating the games visibly but never been in danger of being knocked out) AM kept beating RM all year and this time they played without two vital players and did a very good job. | ||
|
Pandemona
Charlie Sheens House51493 Posts
For me Barca vs Bayern/Real would be great, as long as we get to see those games i don't mind the final + semi final draws. Nothing would be more fun than seeing Pep vs Messi and seeing how he handles him or what is more fun than El Classico finals! | ||
|
sharkie
Austria18701 Posts
| ||
|
Pandemona
Charlie Sheens House51493 Posts
| ||
|
danzii
Germany75 Posts
| ||
|
sharkie
Austria18701 Posts
On April 23 2015 18:00 danzii wrote: What is impressive about Barca/Bayern/Real making it to the semis all the time lately is that they never faced off in the finals in recent years so Juventus finalist confirmed? Juve won't be a finalist. Every non Barca/Bayern/Real finalist earned their spot by playing really good football on their way to the final (and kicked out some high profile team in the process) Juve just lucked their way into the semifinals... They shouldn't really belong there imo. | ||
|
jinorazi
Korea (South)4948 Posts
 | ||
|
aseq
Netherlands4008 Posts
1976 - 1985: 16 1986 - 1995: 14 1996 - 2005: 9 2006 - 2015: 5 2016 - 2025: 3  source (dutch) | ||
|
clusen
Germany8702 Posts
| ||
|
Waterboarding
37 Posts
still bosman ruling has its effect for sure | ||
|
clusen
Germany8702 Posts
Ajax/Ajax/Ajax/Bayern/Bayern/Bayern/Liverpool/Liverpool/Nottingham/Nottingham were the winners in a row, with Feyenoord, HSV, Aston Villa and 2 times Liverpool again also winning it from '70-'84 That's 3 different leagues in all those years. Can't be arsed to look up second places, probably won't look much better. | ||
|
Pandemona
Charlie Sheens House51493 Posts
I see the 2016-2025 being higher, i can see PSG maybe making a semi final with a decent draw, English team for sure will make it there again in no time. Then you're back up to 5, maybe a lucky run from Porto/Benfica and you could get a 6th but when the 5 leagues in Europe are so far ahead of the others it makes it hard for your Dutch/Portuguese/Turkish teams to go that far. | ||
| ||
