MaNa vs Dream is the first truly interesting decision imo. On one hand MaNa has great longetivity with good tournament results in both 2010 and 2018. Whereas Dream is the polar opposite. He (alongside Dark) was hyped up by the community as one of the big up-and-coming players in 2015, and he almost seemed to live up to those expectations during those few months. He played two of the best series in HotS against Life. And then... nothing.
I do wonder how consistency will be mesure against burst of greatness.
For exemple I was quite surprise to see how many vote Jinro got vs Snute (more than Ut and Lilbow vs SpeCial if we stay with foreigner) despite the fact the he was only trully great for like 3-4 month and then fell of, finishing his carrer with a win rate bellow 50%.
A similar question can be ask for Creator I think, does his 8 year carrer where a good 6 of them were pretty average detract or benefit his case for greatness?
Also people votting for Squirtle-Serral are Artosis and his alt.