|
On August 23 2011 23:32 Eufouria wrote: I can't believe the thread turned into this. The only TvP all-in we saw today was a stim timing.
Marine-tank with like a dozen SCV's. Honestly? Its all the exact same shit. The only difference is THAT build has a different defense than the 1-1-1.
|
On August 23 2011 23:29 Zorgaz wrote:
Every1 keeps saying this. It might be correct, but then again it may not? I don't feel this has been proven and it seems rather uncreative to put this argument in the face of everyone who thinks otherwise!?
Every1 keeps saying massing probes does not work against 111, I just beat someone in gold using that ! . It might be correct, but then again it may not? I don't feel this has been proven and it seems rather uncreative to put this argument in the face of everyone who thinks otherwise!?
|
I was wrong on every single bet T_T
|
On August 23 2011 23:33 Phantom_Sky wrote:Show nested quote +On August 23 2011 23:29 Zorgaz wrote:
Every1 keeps saying this. It might be correct, but then again it may not? I don't feel this has been proven and it seems rather uncreative to put this argument in the face of everyone who thinks otherwise!?
Every1 keeps saying massing probes does not work against 111, I just beat someone in gold using that ! . It might be correct, but then again it may not? I don't feel this has been proven and it seems rather uncreative to put this argument in the face of everyone who thinks otherwise!?
In gold league you can pretty much do anything really well and win though.
That doesn't take away from your win though!
|
On August 23 2011 23:33 Phantom_Sky wrote:Show nested quote +On August 23 2011 23:29 Zorgaz wrote:
Every1 keeps saying this. It might be correct, but then again it may not? I don't feel this has been proven and it seems rather uncreative to put this argument in the face of everyone who thinks otherwise!?
Every1 keeps saying massing probes does not work against 111, I just beat someone in gold using that ! . It might be correct, but then again it may not? I don't feel this has been proven and it seems rather uncreative to put this argument in the face of everyone who thinks otherwise!?
Wtf dude?! Just WTF xd. Hope your trolling.
And i don't know how china's gold league is but in the EU gold league I'm quite sure you couldn't win mass probe :D
Don't think it would work in bronze even D:
|
On August 23 2011 23:33 Medrea wrote:Show nested quote +On August 23 2011 23:32 Eufouria wrote: I can't believe the thread turned into this. The only TvP all-in we saw today was a stim timing. Marine-tank with like a dozen SCV's. Honestly? Its all the exact same shit. The only difference is THAT build has a different defense than the 1-1-1. If the defence is different then its not the same is it? They have a similar core, but there are pretty big differences and the only similarity that actually sets them apart from most other Terran all-ins vs Protoss is the use of tanks. Marines and SCVs are used in 95% of Terran all-ins.
|
He's being sarcastic. You're asking to prove that something can't possibly work, which is impossible.
All we can do is combine our own experience, look at the theory for limits on possible responses, and look at how the professionals do it. And the end result is...no one has a clue how to stop it. Not even nearly stop it.
|
On August 23 2011 23:36 Zorgaz wrote:Show nested quote +On August 23 2011 23:33 Phantom_Sky wrote:On August 23 2011 23:29 Zorgaz wrote:
Every1 keeps saying this. It might be correct, but then again it may not? I don't feel this has been proven and it seems rather uncreative to put this argument in the face of everyone who thinks otherwise!?
Every1 keeps saying massing probes does not work against 111, I just beat someone in gold using that ! . It might be correct, but then again it may not? I don't feel this has been proven and it seems rather uncreative to put this argument in the face of everyone who thinks otherwise!? Wtf dude?! Just WTF xd. Hope your trolling. And i don't know how china's gold league is but in the EU gold league I'm quite sure you couldn't win mass probe :D Don't think it would work in bronze even D:
Of course he is trolling. Why are people so angry this days?
|
On August 23 2011 23:11 legaton wrote:Show nested quote +On August 23 2011 23:02 Yaotzin wrote: It certainly used to but after all the void/warpgate nerfs it doesn't anymore.
I mean, if you proxy it and it doesn't get scouted? Yeah, sure. But that's an unreliable cheese. If you straight up 3gate void and they see it early they can hold very easily with bunkers+marines.
A cheese being the only counter to something is obviously broken. Specially if you have to bring some kind of "double" cheese. 3 gate / VR was the original counter to the 1-1-1, abusing the small window you had between building 3 structures and start pumping units. But then, it was nerfed. With the changes of VR, they start doing less damage and they become a less optimal counter because they didn't kill marines and stuff fast enough. Therefore, to make it work now, not to miss that small windows (low count of marines), you have to proxy the VR... 1-1-1 is broken, and a bad thing for the game because it forces protoss to play like crap, because they have a very limited set of options to hold a 1-1-1. That's why Genius went proxy-VR two times, and why Killer always goes 15nexus. These are two blind counters to 1-1-1. Now, protoss is playing blind, and that gives an enormous advantage to terran. If he goes 15nexus, all terran builds let you 2rax/3rax/4rax and attack. If he goes ultra-defensive style, you can always just expand and benefit from a huge lead.
im a zerg player and we always play blind vs terran and toss!
i think the game is balanced now. I used to play terran in diamond league and i just saw genius counter 1-1-1
|
So reacting to a protoss FFE with a fast third < 5minutes is playing blind? pls dont add zerg whine to the 111 discussion alrdy
|
|
On August 23 2011 23:32 Eufouria wrote: I can't believe the thread turned into this. The only TvP all-in we saw today was a stim timing.
Mods are asleep or just don't care.
|
On August 23 2011 23:46 Clicker wrote: 0-4 argh your fault for not believing in GENIUS!
|
On August 23 2011 23:17 aebriol wrote:Show nested quote +On August 23 2011 22:34 sleepingdog wrote: Gah, just read one of the multiple threads on 111 if you lack this kind of understanding... This is actually just wrong. The easiest way to hold the 1-1-1 is by going straight into colossus and stay on one base. Problem is of course, that you might be far behind if anything else is done. 1 gate into expand or nexus first gets 'more stuff faster' but push it back in time, so you won't have colossus out in time to stop any sort of push so you are stuck with immortals - whereas you could otherwise get out 1 immortal 1-2 colossus (no range). Terrans are doing 1 base pushes because they can't easily be stopped by forcefields. If Z had the same option, they'd be doing the exact same thing. 1 gate expand IS greedy, because it sacrifice early tech and units for later econ and more units but much later tech. And that tech is what's needed.
Stop talking balance and stop spreading lies and misinformation in the live thread. There's a reason why we see the 1 gate robo +expo/Nexus first/1g+FE kind of style instead of a one base thing. It's because it's works and is more standard. I don't know what league you are in but if it was that easy don't you think people would already had figured it out?
I have done some testing also and colossus with all those is one of the more worse compositions to get since your gateway army will be so small and tiny. Banshees will eat you alive. So again please don't "The easiest way to hold the 1-1-1 is by going straight into colossus and stay on one base" because it's JUST wrong.
|
United States97276 Posts
3/4 on lb. one i was most sure of failed
|
thx top and genius for not totally wasting my liquibet today.
Keen played really well today.
|
Can anyone recap what happened in the Genius vs Virus match series? I miss it. All 3 games of 1-1-1?
|
On August 23 2011 23:34 TOCHMY wrote: I was wrong on every single bet T_T
I was right on every single one. Good day :D
I have a feeling OGSTop is underrated. He'll win something soon.
|
On August 24 2011 00:05 covetousrat wrote: Can anyone recap what happened in the Genius vs Virus match series? I miss it. All 3 games of 1-1-1?
1 game of tank marine stim SCV timing and 2 games of void ray.
|
On August 24 2011 00:05 covetousrat wrote: Can anyone recap what happened in the Genius vs Virus match series? I miss it. All 3 games of 1-1-1? 1st game Virus did a marine/tank/(late)medivac stim allin which killed Genius. Next game Virus did some weird 2rax with marauders into 1/1/1 allin which died to Genius's proxy void allin. Third game Virus did marauder expand which died to Genius's proxy void allin.
Sadly void allin chances > surviving 1/1/1 chances so..
|
|
|
|