EPTYeah, I've seen the rep and thought Artosis had it but given he disconnected a regame is a legitimate decision. With that in mind Artosis' whining is unacceptable.
[TLI] Live Results - Page 11
| Forum Index > StarCraft 2 Tournaments |
KwarK
United States43593 Posts
Yeah, I've seen the rep and thought Artosis had it but given he disconnected a regame is a legitimate decision. With that in mind Artosis' whining is unacceptable. | ||
|
UltraVires
United States241 Posts
On May 09 2010 06:08 Plexa wrote: Artosis has been disqualified since he has failed to cooperate with the referees. We appreciate that he had an advantage in the game but we felt that Slush did have a legitimate chance to stage a comeback. Since Artosis was at fault in the game (he disconntected), we decided a regame was in order. This decision was made in accordance withe regulations we outlined for TSL. It is unfortunate that Artosis had to act the way he did, but we wish him all the best for the future and we are sorely disappointed he had to be eliminated this way. Lmao Artosis is like an inadequate clone of Idra. Similar but worse style of play, and bad bad manners. Honestly, who disconnects and then claims victory... In other news, I'm loving Huk v. Cauthon right now. Hoping for Huk to come back for at least a game 3! Edit: No... Huk!!! I'll be rooting for you in 3/4 decider. | ||
|
Elric
United Kingdom1327 Posts
| ||
|
Islandsnake
United States679 Posts
Djwheat + Chill + day9 is pretty awesome | ||
|
finalboss
United States39 Posts
On May 09 2010 06:13 PanzerDragoon wrote: Thank god mods didn't bend to e-fame and enforced the rules evenly +1 | ||
Xxio
Canada5565 Posts
| ||
|
Gont
Germany239 Posts
but atleast i think it is stupid to take default lose instead of regame | ||
|
Orome
Switzerland11984 Posts
| ||
|
KwarK
United States43593 Posts
On May 09 2010 06:14 UltraVires wrote: Lmao Artosis is like an inadequate clone of Idra. Similar but worse style of play, and bad bad manners. Honestly, who disconnects and then claims victory... epic fail If you watch the rep you can see why he'd claim it. Slush lost a big battle and three of his five bases. He was down to a single mining base and Artosis' army was at it. Slush's army was largely 1-0 mutalisks while Artosis had a fair number of 3-2 hydralisks attacking it. It wasn't like he didn't have a case. In my opinion the key problem is that he disconnected rather than a neutral disconnect. | ||
Plexa
Aotearoa39261 Posts
Artosis decided to play the regame afterall. + Show Spoiler + Slush won | ||
|
Jyvblamo
Canada13788 Posts
| ||
|
Inspyr
Australia41 Posts
| ||
|
Senx
Sweden5901 Posts
On May 09 2010 06:17 Plexa wrote: UPDATE: Artosis decided to play the regame afterall. + Show Spoiler + Slush won + Show Spoiler + Yeah Artosis FE:d against Slushs 9 pool. GG | ||
|
Jyvblamo
Canada13788 Posts
| ||
|
DeMusliM
United Kingdom401 Posts
On May 09 2010 06:13 Liquid`Nazgul wrote: If you disc and your opponent has as much as a 1% chance it's a regame. It's you who discs and who's at fault plenty of systems give you a loss for that. If the rule would be any different it would allow people to gain advantages and disconnect after with no chance of a comeback for their opponents. Right, completely agree with you although obviously it is frustrating, i've had games for example where i've been 50 food vs 80+ with 1 base vs 3 and won, i mean it's not clear cut. I also believe that it depends alot actually on who discs - if i'm REALLY far ahead, and my oppo discs - i'm likely as an admin to be less likely to regame it, rather than the guy in the lead discing. This has happened at several tournaments before, and 1 particular moment i remember was Grubby vs Zeus at ESWC 2006 for wc3, grubby had the advantage the PC's crashed, admins declared regame as it wasn't over - grubby got so angry and almost walked out. In General i think if you play a straight up macro vs macro game and your winning you should take the regame to just again proove that you are indeed better and more consistent, and technically "win again". Although after saying all that - i'd like to see the game just so i could actually see what went on, badluck for Artosis. Edit: wrote this before i found out they regamed - thought he got DQ'd. | ||
|
teamsolid
Canada3668 Posts
On May 09 2010 06:16 KwarK wrote: If you watch the rep you can see why he'd claim it. Slush lost a big battle and three of his five bases. He was down to a single mining base and Artosis' army was at it. Slush's army was largely 1-0 mutalisks while Artosis had a fair number of 3-2 hydralisks attacking it. It wasn't like he didn't have a case. In my opinion the key problem is that he disconnected rather than a neutral disconnect. Wow... that really sucks for Artosis... that's like 99.9999% won. I don't know any player who wouldn't be really pissed off that they had to regame. | ||
|
condoriano
United States826 Posts
If you watch the rep you can see why he'd claim it. Slush lost a big battle and three of his five bases. He was down to a single mining base and Artosis' army was at it. Slush's army was largely 1-0 mutalisks while Artosis had a fair number of 3-2 hydralisks attacking it. It wasn't like he didn't have a case. In my opinion the key problem is that he disconnected rather than a neutral disconnect. LOL I agree with the admin decision, but this says a lot about slush, he could have just accepted the loss since he had a chance to watch replay. Props to artosis for regaming, admins did what they had to do, slush is someone i will always cheer against from now on lol edit: and he 9 pools the regame, damn. Feel bad for Dan, 5 am and he has to deal with this. | ||
|
I_Love_Bacon
United States5765 Posts
As a random story; the worst technical error that comes to mind was in MLG (Halo3) last year. The favorites to win the tournament were literally 1-2 second away from winning a series and advancing to the Semi finals (maybe finals) when the xbox crashed. MLG rules stated that regardless of score/situation it is always a regame. The team that was 1 second away from winning then lost the next 2 games and then lost in the losers bracket to be eliminated from the tournament. | ||
|
heishe
Germany2284 Posts
| ||
|
KwarK
United States43593 Posts
On May 09 2010 06:21 condoriano wrote: LOL I agree with the admin decision, but this says a lot about slush, he could have just accepted the loss since he had a chance to watch replay. Props to artosis for regaming, admins did what they had to do, slush is someone i will always cheer against from now on lol Artosis deserves no props. He delayed the tournament for a long time by arguing with the refs. Refs spent a long time watching the rep and debating, it's not like they didn't consider his case. You can't argue with the refs and he ignored ultimatums and got himself disqualified. It was only after he was disqualified by Plexa he realised he wasn't going to win this argument and gave in. It sucks for Artosis but ref decisions must be respected. | ||
| ||
