I'm still interested in other people saying whether they got his PM or not. Additional info is helpful when you're trying to make an informed decision.

Fishball

Canada4788 Posts

August 03 2009 20:13 GMT

#846

So we're all RCing to Ver now?

Fishball

Canada4788 Posts

August 03 2009 20:15 GMT

#847

I also find it funny that the majority of posts in this thread are the same handful of people.

Should have a mafia game that does not allow talking. Only votes.

Canada4732 Posts

August 03 2009 20:19 GMT

#848

I cba to PM you, but I'm a conscript, so put that down in your cute little list :3.

Infundibulum

United States2552 Posts

August 03 2009 20:47 GMT

#849

On August 04 2009 04:48 Zato-1 wrote:

Show nested quote +

I'm still interested in other people saying whether they got his PM or not. Additional info is helpful when you're trying to make an informed decision.

I got the PM. I didn't answer it though!

Canada4732 Posts

August 03 2009 21:12 GMT

#850

So, after rereading Ver's post and Ace's reply, I'm wondering why Ver is trying to go along with a plan that he could have relayed through Ace, given that he seems to know Ace was willing to kill Clazz and can rolecheck (NKVD or Rebel).

Ver clearly doesn't trust Ace, and Ace's reply gives away that Ace doesn't trust Ver.

Ver's post essentially gives the town information that it already has: Kuja was already slated to be our next target, was discovered earlier, and Clazz already died. Ver is trying to position himself as the reason for both of these despite Ace and Scaramanga actually being responsible for both.

So what does this mean? You decide!

Canada4732 Posts

August 03 2009 21:13 GMT

#851

Also: I didn't get a Pm.

Ver is afraid of me. Probably because I've called him out twice (that last post makes 3) times this game thusfar.

Ver

United States2186 Posts

August 03 2009 22:27 GMT

#852

I don't fully trust ace he has made several bad moves so far this game (most notably lynching vivi over clazz and then revealing clazz prematurely) and while his behavior mostly fits that of an innocent it's the question of did he just make some unusual mistakes or is he mafia? Not all too easy to answer right now and I'd rather just sidestep it.

I can't reveal the mafia because a) it would give them a point to rally around and b) it would compromise certain individuals.

I didn't pm certain people for a variety of reasons. For some I was already certain of their alleigance/role, for others I didn't want them to stir up unnecessary trouble (i,e you L, as I certainly have no reason to be afraid of you).

I have 20 roles so far, keep em coming! Guess a lot of people are inactive or something. Really the most important are the vigis which I still need.

Btw I'm not out to steal thunder but I do have an ulterior motive for doing this, besides as an experiment, for I am well aware the tenuous circumstances of doing this move now ^_^

Railxp

Hong Kong1313 Posts

August 03 2009 22:36 GMT

#853

On August 04 2009 04:23 Zato-1 wrote:

Show nested quote +

Neither did I. I wonder if he's trolling us with his claim that he PM'ed 40-45 people.

PMing many people isnt exactly hard to do. its just copy pasting and some clicking.

Ace

United States16096 Posts

August 03 2009 22:42 GMT

#854

On August 04 2009 07:27 Ver wrote:
I don't fully trust ace he has made several bad moves so far this game (most notably lynching vivi over clazz and then revealing clazz prematurely) and while his behavior mostly fits that of an innocent it's the question of did he just make some unusual mistakes or is he mafia? Not all too easy to answer right now and I'd rather just sidestep it.

I can't reveal the mafia because a) it would give them a point to rally around and b) it would compromise certain individuals.

I didn't pm certain people for a variety of reasons. For some I was already certain of their alleigance/role, for others I didn't want them to stir up unnecessary trouble (i,e you L, as I certainly have no reason to be afraid of you).

I have 20 roles so far, keep em coming! Guess a lot of people are inactive or something. Really the most important are the vigis which I still need.

Btw I'm not out to steal thunder but I do have an ulterior motive for doing this, besides as an experiment, for I am well aware the tenuous circumstances of doing this move now ^_^

ok step back and think about this for a second...

You send me a PM telling me to change my lynch to clazz. You don't even have any surefire evidence that clazz is Mafia, and all I have is your word.

WHY WOULD I LYNCH CLAZZ WITH NOTHING TO GO ON?

It was a very smart play from my side. I have no info on clazz, and I also had no info on you. Literally it's the same thing as if L PM'd me and said hey, lynch Elemenope. Why would I do it for no reason?

And to top it all off, I wasn't even here. I told Caller to lynch Vivi57 if I win as I wasn't going to be around. So on both accounts you're wrong. I had to hold back on lynching Clazz because I can't trust the word of an unconfirmed player with nothing but a hunch.

Ace

United States16096 Posts

August 03 2009 22:44 GMT

#855

also I HIGHLY doubt 20 people have roleclaimed to you. There is nothing to be afraid of in releasing those names. They can't rally around the people you name because a.)everyone is going to PM them false claiming and b.)they aren't even confirmed Mafia.

Release the names now and stop wasting time.

Elemenope

Burkina Faso1704 Posts

August 03 2009 22:46 GMT

#856

On August 04 2009 07:42 Ace wrote:
It was a very smart play from my side. I have no info on clazz, and I also had no info on you. Literally it's the same thing as if L PM'd me and said hey, lynch Elemenope. Why would I do it for no reason?

We all know you wouldn't lynch me anyway =3

Elemenope

Burkina Faso1704 Posts

August 03 2009 22:46 GMT

#857

EBWOP:

scum

Ace

United States16096 Posts

August 03 2009 22:49 GMT

#858

that depends on how well you warded the jungle lulz

Elemenope

Burkina Faso1704 Posts

August 03 2009 22:52 GMT

#859

no u

coltrane

Chile988 Posts

August 04 2009 01:04 GMT

#860

On August 04 2009 07:44 Ace wrote:
also I HIGHLY doubt 20 people have roleclaimed to you. There is nothing to be afraid of in releasing those names. They can't rally around the people you name because a.)everyone is going to PM them false claiming and b.)they aren't even confirmed Mafia.

Release the names now and stop wasting time.

To ver:

No, dont release the list, send it to a couple of people that you are sure they are not mafia. Realising a list of roles is to give away the advantage that mafia dont know each other.

I didnt get a PM, i supose you have a call for me, keep it, i wont send you my role, i alredy wrote it in the thread.