A Classy Game of Mafia - Page 446

Jealous

10170 Posts

March 15 2024 07:03 GMT

#8901

On March 15 2024 15:32 justanothertownie wrote:
That was a really terrible lynch for all intents and purposes except game integrity.

Palmar anything to say about this one? IIRC "anyone who says town did bad" is bad, no?

If your name is not Vivax, name one person who was more worthy of a lynch based on game play alone.

DMB, save your breath too, this is an emotional thing for you.

Jealous

10170 Posts

March 15 2024 07:04 GMT

#8902

On March 15 2024 16:03 Jealous wrote:

Show nested quote +

You can do it at EOD if that makes you feel safer.

Jealous

10170 Posts

March 15 2024 07:05 GMT

#8903

As for me, my next target is Koshi as of right now. But, I will have to do some leg work.

Lol auto corrected it to keg work. Might have to do that too.

Jealous

10170 Posts

March 15 2024 07:25 GMT

#8904

On March 15 2024 13:38 Vivax wrote:

Show nested quote +

I hope it doesn‘t.
Jealous is auto might as well just shitpost tomorrow

If you think scum!Jealous spent 3 cycles* voting for a 1 for 1 with CopCake you need to find an adult.

*caveat being I switched from Cop to Oats.

justanothertownie

16319 Posts

March 15 2024 08:38 GMT

#8905

On March 15 2024 16:03 Jealous wrote:

Show nested quote +

What positive things are there to say here? Our confirmed towns lynched someone they agreed was most likely town. At least people are forced to talk about someone else than CC now for a change. But that was unnecessary. And dmb just went with it in the most opportunistic way possible.

iamperfection

United States9643 Posts

March 15 2024 10:51 GMT

#8906

Guys I get it but this is no time for town depression if your town. The game isn't lost.

I'm going to reread people I may have given pass to especially recently like koshi.

I'll even look into conspiracy theories to see if the crazy is even possible.

iamperfection

United States9643 Posts

March 15 2024 10:53 GMT

#8907

On March 15 2024 17:38 justanothertownie wrote:

Show nested quote +

Didn't like this post btw.

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

March 15 2024 12:38 GMT

#8908

What happened to dick move analysis

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

March 15 2024 12:39 GMT

#8909

I know I can't be all that mad at this game but still a little mad that the shennies was outside my pool

Vivax

22011 Posts

March 15 2024 12:50 GMT

#8910

If I had studied harder I could now pretend to treat DPs tear for free and hack his leg off instead. File it under accidents, replace it with the closest plastic replica.

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

March 15 2024 13:24 GMT

#8911

On March 15 2024 21:50 Vivax wrote:
If I had studied harder I could now pretend to treat DPs tear for free and hack his leg off instead. File it under accidents, replace it with the closest plastic replica.

I was under the impression you were going to lynch me some mafia?

Vivax

22011 Posts

March 15 2024 13:28 GMT

#8912

On March 15 2024 22:24 Palmar wrote:

Show nested quote +

I was under the impression you were going to lynch me some mafia?

I got weak. Didn‘t follow my heart.
I think DP enjoyed playing me.

Vivax

22011 Posts

March 15 2024 13:32 GMT

#8913

There was something sinister about him just asking me.

Jealous

10170 Posts

March 15 2024 16:02 GMT

#8914

On March 15 2024 11:29 Vivax wrote:
Jealous can you do self-wagon analysis? If you know your alignment you should be able to discern where the mafia is somewhat?

Because it's TvT, I don't think there is much analysis to be done to be honest. I was hoping that there would be some pattern to how votes moved throughout the day, but I am becoming more and more convinced that scum just mixed themselves in well in between townie waves of votes. Furthermore, because of the rapidly changing wagons yesterday, some people have been on just about every wagon, which makes it even more difficult.

Notable exceptions:
1. Palmar never jumped on my wagon.
2. JAT never jumped on CopCake.

Overall, because of the rampant tomfoolery, I think most of the votes are NAI. However, if I had to guess and going by my prior reads, I'd say most of the scum is on me. In my mason chat with DP, I mentioned that I feel like I might just be a useful idiot for scum, but I would think that when presented with the option of lynching either me or Cop, most sane individuals would choose to lynch me because I am actually invested in playing and make more posts that make more sense. So, I think it has to be between Palmar, Koshi, JAT, and Rels at the moment.

Previous analysis would point to Koshi, but I am starting to think that Rels' clean play in the first few days as more indicative than I previously did. I'll have to dive both to decide which I think is more likely to be scum at this point, but I am fairly sure there is at least one between the two of them.

iamperfection

United States9643 Posts

March 15 2024 16:48 GMT

#8915

alright lets get these out of the way.

DP

If he is mafia he has been playing more for town then he has for mafia. You literally cant hit all on the filter page anymore. So we have the shot on TTS obviously a pro town move. For mafia DP he may have felt obligated to shoot TTS after announcing that he had the gun in thread which to me the giddiness to announce that he has a gun would more likely to come from town i would think. Mafia DP could have done what would have been the proper play to shut up and then announce the shot like a normal vig would have and made some justification to shoot someone else. If the mafia team just wanted to bus TTS and waste a day on him they could have in this scenario and got the cred on multiple people instead of just DP. He also held the line on Oats several players were confounded by oats play including marv at points and myself obviously so easily could have trumped up some. Now his engagement to cake could come across as scummy i had at times had thoughts of just saying i wasnt going to read cakes posts which in hindsight might have been the correct play as i was confounded by the constant changing of reads and dropping reads on basically a dime. The proper play may have been for DP to just say no more at some point but i think he had the same doubts as me.

Add to that the constant engagement and care for the lynch i think the simplest explanation is that he is just town and if he is mafia we tip our hat and say gg go next and never talk about this game again. If he doesn't die tonight though make sure to request those injury pics for the lols though.

Vivax

So i wanted to go back and see again exactly how and when his claim happened and it actually came a bit later then when i thought it did. Vivax's claim comes about an hour after i ask the whisperers to claim and rayn responded extremely quickly and we ascertain that he is extremely likely to be town. Now could a scum vivax have seen this mini town circle starting to form and want to disrupt it. I guess its somewhat possible but i dont think its likely as there would be several problems with it. What if someone in me marv rayn and sandro turned out to be the JK he would have traded himself and just make that town circle all the more powerful. On top of that what if the JK was anyone else he still is just needlessly trading himself and leaving his team in a worse situation. Using setup speculation we had a cop that was up against a framer and possible millers or godfathers. A jat. a gunsmith which is just a shitty vig. I think adding a JK to that is pretty reasonable from what i understand gracks thoughts on balance.

Similarly with DP he has been extremely active and engaged. If he is mafia what a play and we lynch all claimers day 1 and cite this game until the end of time. The simplest explanation is that he is town.