|
On September 29 2019 07:14 Branch.AUT wrote:
First of all: I dont think scum is afk, as day 1 lynch was between two townys, therefore no need to interfere, as they werwnt in jeopardy.
Secondly: I read HFs thread summary post but its too long to properly process ar this time of night. Tomorrow if I find time
This doesn't make sense.
Scum is not afk but they didn't participate?
I am so confused.
Secondly, I didn't read you as mafia, that's why I didn't vote you, like with my heart, my will. But between you and Ewya, I preferred Ewya alive.
|
On September 29 2019 04:21 ShoCkeyy wrote:
You seem upset I town read GB but not you, wonder why.
You have me at null or I am mafia, pick one.
|
Btw, HF is clear town.
And now I will go and read GB, but so far I can tell you that with just tone and process he looks town to me.
I can be fooled tho, since apparently he is good when he rolls mafia.
|
Btw, just a small question, how many blues do we have this round?
Just for possible night actions.
|
On September 26 2019 09:39 FreezingFoot wrote:Show nested quote +On September 26 2019 08:23 CopCake wrote:On September 26 2019 07:57 FreezingFoot wrote:On September 26 2019 07:32 CopCake wrote:
Why tho?
Sup GB, how have your games been since we were mafia together?
I am a bit curious of your shennanigans and what not. Sup Cake! I don’t know, I haven’t been playing the game for more than 2 years, if you don’t count my attempt to play last year, where I stopped playing because I completely lost access to my account  About the reads, gut feeling. Except for epóxi-, I simply dislike the possibility that he is playing wit joy reading his role PM Want me tbh? I also feel evil vibes from vivax D: IKR!? I mean, what townie would be hyped to play with me again? That’s insane!
This is a bit strange, but idk if I am seeing things because I am trying to read with HF's eyes.
It is like you are clearing Vivax here while you call him mafia.
|
On September 27 2019 01:56 FreezingFoot wrote:Show nested quote +On September 26 2019 13:58 CopCake wrote:
Lets talk GB, since you seem town.
I have been playing once in a while, last two games were bad. Alright, what do you wanna talk about? Show nested quote +On September 26 2019 19:36 Vivax wrote:
Im leaning mafia on BF for now. But Im aware that when little of value has been posted by others, I might just be paying too much attention to those who actually post.
On a reread, I found it strange that BF found it necessary to comment on nobody posting for six minutes, but mostly I found his reply to GB with the extra spaces forced. I dont see a townie reason for BF to be so distrustful within the first few posts.
GB so far looks like hes having fun so he can go to town pile. Hes a pretty good scum player but he tends to go full emo as mafia and fooled me with it in the past iirc.
FF feeling offended for the mod power thingy rubs me the wrong way too since I never suggested he actually did it. Mostly mentioned it because it was the reason I got to stare at his icon and see a pinocchio. I had the exact opposite reaction to boxerfred's opening. I don't think FF's answer to you was alignment indicative. Also, why are you townreading me and talking about me going full emo as scum? It seems that you're trying to justify a future shift of your read on me. Show nested quote +On September 26 2019 21:44 Eywa- wrote:On September 26 2019 21:13 Branch.AUT wrote:On September 26 2019 21:09 Eywa- wrote:
vote:Branch.AUT
If you guys are really nice, I might even give you his partner before I get night killed. as usual, dead wrong Also, the fact that he immediately is considering that I'm incorrectly voting instead of being mafia... Almost like he knows I'm town which he also has no reason to believe. This feels like you decided he is mafia before finding the arguments to it. This "perfect information" argument isn't convincing. Show nested quote +On September 26 2019 22:08 Eywa- wrote:On September 26 2019 22:01 Branch.AUT wrote:
Right, moving one from this waste of time now. Thanks for the entertaining trail of posts though, had a good laugh Agreed, unfortunately you are being lynched today. We should probably start discussing the day 2 lynch now. If Branch flips town, you should definitely be considering me as an option. I have some ideas for who his partner is, but I'd like to give everyone the opportunity to play. I'd rather hear you now. Could you please share who his partner is? Show nested quote +On September 26 2019 22:18 Branch.AUT wrote:
I like what boxerfred has pasted so far. He seems to be interested in the game and looking for contributions.
I have to disagree with his GB read though. Most of what GB posted so far seems to be chatting and everything outside the game. It does indeed seem ligh hearted, but well within the range of a good scum player as far as I am concerned. I'm not a good scum player. I am an okay scum player. To be fair, it's not really hard to detect me when I'm scum. I was lynched almost every game I played as scum. The point is: as scum, I usually act as a support. When I flip, people get everything wrong. Which is great . But rest assured that I'm not scum in this game.
(And if I was, I wouldn't be telling you this)Show nested quote +On September 26 2019 23:33 Eywa- wrote:
It is amusing though that you interpret my shit posting as an attempt to flesh out a scum read. Branch is outed scum, I really don't have to make a case for it. Yes, you do, and this tunnel seems very fabricated. ##Vote: Eywa-
So would you say GB is good or not? @Vivax @HF @Anyonewhohasplayedwithhiminthepast
|
On September 27 2019 06:14 FreezingFoot wrote:Show nested quote +On September 27 2019 02:29 CopCake wrote:
I wouldnt touch Ewya this early tho GB I can touch anyone I want, he was consenting, I can prove it. Show nested quote +On September 27 2019 02:53 Eywa- wrote:On September 27 2019 02:50 Eywa- wrote:On September 27 2019 01:56 FreezingFoot wrote:
This feels like you decided he is mafia before finding the arguments to it. This "perfect information" argument isn't convincing.
I can see where you're coming from, but you're wrong. I decided he was Mafia before posting the "arguments", but the "arguments" are not the reason that he's mafia, they are mostly just me mocking "cases". It's not a huge distinction, but it is a significant one. Your post makes it seem like I was looking for arguments to justify why he was Mafia, but I'm not doing that at all. He is mafia, I'm telling you, if my track record is not enough to justify that, then I guess I would say... Sounds like you want to lose. If you're not forcing that read, I'm having a hard time to understand why you think he is mafia. Is it for meta? Please explain to me like I'm a 4 y.o.  Btw, did you read you role pm? Show nested quote +On September 27 2019 03:39 Fecalfeast wrote:
I will say that branch after the eywa baseless accusation has given me feelings.
Also I'm gonna be on a sort of vacation for the next 4 days lmao i probably shouldn't have signed up but I'll grab some time when i can.
No real spammers here I'll be fine Wait for me, I'll be spamming in a pinch. Show nested quote +On September 27 2019 03:39 CopCake wrote:
Because I cant read him correctly and he was right about rayn last game.
And if you poke him he will be like “whatever” because he doesnt care nor engage a convo.
I would say that GB is town.
FF seems town.
Vivax smells mafia.
Shockey smells a little bit as mafia, just a little bit.
I am curious about one thing with you.
And Ewya is null.
Cool. Why is Vivax mafia? Why shockey smells like mafia?Ewayhijole- being right on rayn isn't proof he will be right in this game. Don't you think this is weak reasoning to give up on trying to read Ewaychupazi-? Show nested quote +On September 27 2019 05:06 Vivax wrote:On September 26 2019 21:09 Eywa- wrote:
vote:Branch.AUT
If you guys are really nice, I might even give you his partner before I get night killed. On September 26 2019 21:41 Eywa- wrote:
Branch dismissing me here when he has no reason to believe I'm bad at reading the game is really questionable and just adds onto the many other reasons you guys should be voting here. This is ridiculous? You vote him out of nowhere and complain that hes dismissing you because youre supposedly good at the game. Why should he think that if youre wrong and hes town? And if hes mafia why shouldnt he dismiss you? In abstraction, you have delivered a prime example of damned if I do, damned if I dont. If you dont acknowledge that this is plain BS with a backtrack and a formal apology to the god of logic Im voting you and never unvoting. THAT'S MORE LIKE MY TOWN BUDDY VIVAX (maybe) Show nested quote +On September 27 2019 05:21 CopCake wrote:On September 27 2019 05:02 ShoCkeyy wrote:On September 27 2019 03:39 CopCake wrote:
Because I cant read him correctly and he was right about rayn last game.
And if you poke him he will be like “whatever” because he doesnt care nor engage a convo.
I would say that GB is town.
FF seems town.
Vivax smells mafia.
Shockey smells a little bit as mafia, just a little bit.
I am curious about one thing with you.
And Ewya is null.
I always smell like mafia every game I play. I just think it’s my posting style I guess... also why can’t we go after Eywa early? Let him act. We can get info from that. Just saying not the best lunch atm. And who would be better? Show nested quote +On September 27 2019 05:47 Eywa- wrote:On September 27 2019 01:56 FreezingFoot wrote:
I'd rather hear you now. Could you please share who his partner is?
This is not a good question, you are voting me... You want me to throw a name out, but you should be thinking... What do I react if he says ______ If the answer is the same regardless, you might as well not ask the question. If you think I'm scum, it's also pointless. I can't be sure if you're scum or not. I will always try to gather as much information as I can to sustain or change my read. I want to understand your thought process. If I can't, you're probably fabricating reads. That's the point. Who is his partner and why?
Dude, you called Vivax mafia with FF/HF
uhhhhhhhh
|
On September 29 2019 10:10 Holyflare wrote:Show nested quote +On September 29 2019 09:45 CopCake wrote:On September 27 2019 01:56 FreezingFoot wrote:On September 26 2019 13:58 CopCake wrote:
Lets talk GB, since you seem town.
I have been playing once in a while, last two games were bad. Alright, what do you wanna talk about? On September 26 2019 19:36 Vivax wrote:
Im leaning mafia on BF for now. But Im aware that when little of value has been posted by others, I might just be paying too much attention to those who actually post.
On a reread, I found it strange that BF found it necessary to comment on nobody posting for six minutes, but mostly I found his reply to GB with the extra spaces forced. I dont see a townie reason for BF to be so distrustful within the first few posts.
GB so far looks like hes having fun so he can go to town pile. Hes a pretty good scum player but he tends to go full emo as mafia and fooled me with it in the past iirc.
FF feeling offended for the mod power thingy rubs me the wrong way too since I never suggested he actually did it. Mostly mentioned it because it was the reason I got to stare at his icon and see a pinocchio. I had the exact opposite reaction to boxerfred's opening. I don't think FF's answer to you was alignment indicative. Also, why are you townreading me and talking about me going full emo as scum? It seems that you're trying to justify a future shift of your read on me. On September 26 2019 21:44 Eywa- wrote:On September 26 2019 21:13 Branch.AUT wrote:On September 26 2019 21:09 Eywa- wrote:
vote:Branch.AUT
If you guys are really nice, I might even give you his partner before I get night killed. as usual, dead wrong Also, the fact that he immediately is considering that I'm incorrectly voting instead of being mafia... Almost like he knows I'm town which he also has no reason to believe. This feels like you decided he is mafia before finding the arguments to it. This "perfect information" argument isn't convincing. On September 26 2019 22:08 Eywa- wrote:On September 26 2019 22:01 Branch.AUT wrote:
Right, moving one from this waste of time now. Thanks for the entertaining trail of posts though, had a good laugh Agreed, unfortunately you are being lynched today. We should probably start discussing the day 2 lynch now. If Branch flips town, you should definitely be considering me as an option. I have some ideas for who his partner is, but I'd like to give everyone the opportunity to play. I'd rather hear you now. Could you please share who his partner is? On September 26 2019 22:18 Branch.AUT wrote:
I like what boxerfred has pasted so far. He seems to be interested in the game and looking for contributions.
I have to disagree with his GB read though. Most of what GB posted so far seems to be chatting and everything outside the game. It does indeed seem ligh hearted, but well within the range of a good scum player as far as I am concerned. I'm not a good scum player. I am an okay scum player. To be fair, it's not really hard to detect me when I'm scum. I was lynched almost every game I played as scum. The point is: as scum, I usually act as a support. When I flip, people get everything wrong. Which is great . But rest assured that I'm not scum in this game.
(And if I was, I wouldn't be telling you this)On September 26 2019 23:33 Eywa- wrote:
It is amusing though that you interpret my shit posting as an attempt to flesh out a scum read. Branch is outed scum, I really don't have to make a case for it. Yes, you do, and this tunnel seems very fabricated. ##Vote: Eywa- So would you say GB is good or not? @Vivax @HF @Anyonewhohasplayedwithhiminthepast You've played with him as mafia and you quoted his win rates before? Show nested quote +On September 28 2019 13:18 CopCake wrote:
Mafia Win Percentage (Minimum 7 games)
- Hide Spoiler -
Fecalfeast 7/7 = 100.0000%
GlowingBear 10/11 = 90.9091%
Ok, this is something.
Seems a bit artificial to ask this, of course he's good with a 10/11 win rate?
Yeah but he said he sacrifices himself, like since he pushed me and moosy before, I want to know if it is true he also sacrifices.
And by my info (my experience playing with him) I wouldnt call him good.
|
Nah, you are trying to understand why I ask that stuff but it is mostly that I can have one opinion and some other.
The stats could mean that he gets lynched asap (as he saif) but it doesnt mean he is a good mafia, he could had been carried by his team.
|
Ugh I hate phone posting XD so I think I will type slowly here...
He can have more wins
But if it is true he gets lynched asap
Doesnt mean he is good at being mafia, and the wins could be because he got carried.
So I needed info of that, you consider him good enough to fool you but I would love another opinion. Specially he said he is “okeyish”
|
This feels like me playing with myself
Alone
Not fun at all.
|
One thing for sure is that mafia aint mia.
We can agree on that and I came to that conclusion not with your “I got protected” but because it is odd. Specially since the set up is not open and we have few players.
I would say at least one is extremely active.
|
GB if you are here
Who is town
Who is mafia besides HF
Reasons
|
On September 29 2019 05:47 Tubesock wrote:
I think the lynch pool should be Branch, Boxer and I. The “nightkill” could have been a save, vet or afk team. I think it’s too early to claim, but if it was a save we will know soon enough, but if it’s afk team then that obviously changes stuff.
Reasons to lynch Branch: Eywa was town and has a very high correct reads rate. There’s something else I’m going to look at Eywa said, I’ll dig it up.
Boxer: policy, and has afk’ed before as mafia.
Tube: I’ve been afk, and should be forced to play more, otherwise will always be a question.
This is a bad post imo
I mean mostly lazy reads based on activity
|
On September 28 2019 02:30 FreezingFoot wrote:Show nested quote +On September 28 2019 02:29 Tubesock wrote:On September 28 2019 02:24 FreezingFoot wrote:On September 28 2019 02:16 Tubesock wrote:
What do people think of CopCake?
I’m 180 on their reads. Not sure how someone can town Boxer, and don’t like the Vivax, Shockeyy, Branch team. I don't think you need to think of teams now TS. Just vote the scummiest. Who's the scummiest? I’m not thinking of teams. I think that trio is more likely town. Eywa Of the wagons. I’d rather see boxer or copcake be lynched due POE. I'm comfortable in calling CopCake town for now, boxerfred is being boxerfred and his opening sounded townie to me (gut feelings) I won't lynch these guys today
Boxerfred one
|
On September 28 2019 10:30 FreezingFoot wrote:Show nested quote +On September 28 2019 10:18 Holyflare wrote:On September 26 2019 21:47 Eywa- wrote:
What is this!?
A perspective slip!
And the crowd goes wild! On September 27 2019 02:50 Eywa- wrote:On September 27 2019 01:56 FreezingFoot wrote:
This feels like you decided he is mafia before finding the arguments to it. This "perfect information" argument isn't convincing.
I can see where you're coming from, but you're wrong. I decided he was Mafia before posting the "arguments", but the "arguments" are not the reason that he's mafia, they are mostly just me mocking "cases". If you think this first post was anything other than a facetious exaggeration I don't know what to say. EITHER WAY, you spent a long, long time saying that Eywa had circular logic and all that baloney only to then say you could see how he would have circular logic after his flip????? Let me just requote your post: I can understand a townie actually believing there was a scum slip and getting annoyed that people wasn't seeing what he was seeing. I don't think his attitude contributed, but I understood him. BUT YOU COULDN'T SEE THAT AND IT WAS ALL A LIE LOL! I first thought it was a newbie scum trying to bring a bad argument against another newbie. He was over the top and evasive when I started pressuring him Then I re read the game and I thought that branch’s reaction was scummy, and eywa’s posts started to make sense to me Why do you think it’s is scummy? Btw when I said “boxerfred being boxefred” o meant he is usually a lurker as far as I remember.
Boxer 2
|
On September 27 2019 13:06 FreezingFoot wrote:
Ok, I've re-read the game and I think Eywa- is right about Branch.
##Unvote
##Vote: Branch.AUT
Fair question HF
Let's say GB is mafia
If that is true that would make Brach town, correct?
I mean look at the times of the votes.
It was a tie between Brach and Ewya
On September 27 2019 23:21 Grackaroni wrote:
Day One Vote Count
Branch.AUT (2): Eywa, FreezingFoot
Eywa (2): FreezingFoot, Vivax, ShoCkeyy
FecalFeast (0): FreezingFoot
Not Voting (5): FecalFeast, CopCake, Tubesock, Branch.AUT, Boxerfred
Branch.AUT is currently set to be lynched.
Please let us know if you notice any mistakes! The deadline is Friday, Sep 27 6:00pm GMT (GMT+00:00), which is in
Why wouldn't mafia save his mafia partner?
I mean, he has thrown his mafia partner to the lynch pile before so he gets towncred, but it is stupid to do it here, at least now considering how many players we have and more importantly, how we are playing.
If I was mafia GB I would have just stuck my vote on Ewya since "town" read her as mafia. If he didn't care who he voted for because he is mafia then that makes Branch also town.
Also it is strange that Branch didnt vote for Ewya to save himself.
|
Post #435
On September 29 2019 04:13 ShoCkeyy wrote:Show nested quote +On September 29 2019 04:11 CopCake wrote:On September 27 2019 05:04 ShoCkeyy wrote:
You essentially ignored Branches question, I’m positive you couldn’t have missed it unless it was done on purpose and you actually have no reason and are trying to save your mafia partner?!? So tell me, now that you saw that Ewya flipped town, am I still mafia? Idk? It’s 50/50. You’re the scummiest so far in my reads however. Between you and Tube
Me and Tube are the kings of being scum but then you share this
Post #450
On September 29 2019 04:34 ShoCkeyy wrote:
At least I’m posting? Lol... Boxer and Tube haven’t posted. And I’ve played on mafia team before with boxer and that’s his style as mafia. The no kill tonight was odd in general, problably afk, so I can assume that part of the mafia team is within the people that didn’t vote the first day.
but let's forget that I know that the meta of Boxer is that he asks and that is his style as mafia, totes not important to share because tube and cake forever mafia yo.
|
On September 29 2019 13:50 Alakaslam wrote:
Why do you call Eywa she?
My mental image of Ewya is Margaery from Game of Thrones.
and also the name reminds me of a character from Lord of the rings, Eowyn
|
Am I in the right thread or why is a teacher posting?
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
