Newbie Student Mafia XXX - Page 18

On October 03 2019 12:38 Holyflare wrote:
Killing boxerfred as part of the plan I made was to make the game mylo instead of lylo. Then we no lynch the next day for more info and another cycle to talk.

If shockey is town then lynching him in mylo would lose us the game. That's part of the reason I scum read gb because he said he was following the plan and then advocated for a shockey lynch directly after.

Maybe he doesn't wanna do it now because it proves me town if shockey is town?

On October 04 2019 01:16 CopCake wrote:


But I am the one that started the shockey train, I would be the one to blame.

And the whole “if shockey is town it clears me” only applies here, not in the other one.

On October 04 2019 01:44 CopCake wrote:


Sooo opportunistic lmao

On October 04 2019 01:45 CopCake wrote:


If we lynch GB and he flips town...

Are you ok with being the next lynch or would it be just a shit read?

If GB flips town who is the mafia by poe?

On October 04 2019 02:07 Holyflare wrote:
It actually feels like 2 people are playing on her account even because this is a stark difference from her relatively townie rest of the game.

On September 27 2019 22:56 CopCake wrote:


To answer you I will have to quote you.

You are questioning me for locking Ewya town, is my read period.

Just like GB is a locked town to me.

Reads I feel confident.

But instead of telling me “you are wrong, Ewya could be mafia here are some reasons” you are just pointing fingers at me, lowkey I suppose calling me mafia for “budding up” with someone I dont get along.

Have the guts and call me mafia and make a better case for it because being “oh but you are calling ewya town so early” is just bullshit.

Care to share your reads and not being just small voice trying to pretend to do something?

On September 27 2019 23:15 CopCake wrote:


And a “magia Eywa” would just throw a randol name and expect people to follow him?

That is his mafia game?

I am basing my read on interactions, if he changes his personality because early game I didnt see it, then his normal self showed off in the way he answered GB with the random list dot org page.

Not saying he is right on his read, if you see I havent voted because my mafia read is Vivax.

I dont see the “fallacy”

Could you please point me what makes Ewya mafia?

A bad read? Early game? Trying to take the charge of town? When we have other two “Veterans” to yell at each other?

On September 27 2019 23:56 CopCake wrote:


Why would you make this question for a joke?

Even worse if it was obvious which FF has the pinocho icon.

On September 28 2019 00:03 CopCake wrote:
Boxer is town.

On October 04 2019 02:10 CopCake wrote:
Yeah because calling you mafia makes me mafia.

On October 04 2019 02:20 CopCake wrote:


Can you quote me the explenation of your breadcrumb?

I am at work and I cant filter dive.

I got the idea of you being mafia yesterday when I woke up to get water and decided to check the thread and then it came to my mind “How did HF got to know GB got targeted if he is tracker”

Then my theory of HF + Shockey team made sense.

Either way if it makes you happy Ill vote GB but if he flips town you die the next day.

Your reasons to mafia read him do not satisfy me.

“He wouldddddf have yelled i aammmm mafiaaaa always he goes long ways tooooo proveee it he is trying to buddy meeee look at his gif he knows i am towwwnn”

On October 03 2019 04:27 Holyflare wrote:
My n1 check was copcake and she went nowhere. I was deciding between copcake and GB and just flipped a coin, deal with it.

The clues I've been dropping all day was because I made my breadcrumb the most elaborate fucking thing I could think of that was like an 8 layer deep mafia misdirection. It makes it look like I say something regarding GB and TS so that mafia may shit themselves and shoot me (which apparently they did, whether it's because of the crumb I don't know) but if you look into the "game" I was posting today, it should reveal the puzzle.

The clue was a quote from Nietzsche. I used a Nihilist cipher with a key that decoded that phrase into digits. If you add up the digits they lead to a post from Copcake. I thought she was looking a bit more towny just before n1 ended but I was out and couldn't be bothered to change my check last minute.

On October 03 2019 04:45 Holyflare wrote:
If anyone doubts this they are fucking stupid, my key was literally the word track:

+ Show Spoiler +

The remaining clues were:

Clue 3: Stop! You'll need a key to pass through. What is my action?
Clue 4: Have you ever heard of the phrase, the sum of two halves?
Hint 4: (Sum and add the 2 numbers dodo)
Clue 5: Now find that post!

Pretty sure it led to copcake's first post or something, I don't remember.