|
On April 10 2019 05:27 KelsierSC wrote:
i bussed grak out of this day phase. so his night actions couldnt resolve same for actions against him. he's in a QT with me and i guess he comes back next phase
i win with town but my role doesnt seem to have anything to do with maths or pythagoras or romans, some shit about unravelling lovers.
hasnt told us anything about what grack said in there though.
so might not be reliable for you to communicate with thread.
(kinda busy at work so will not be super responsive unfortunately)
but yeah ignoring you top lunch would be sent
am kinda 50/50 on ksc. like had a scum lean on him before the role stuff happened and his claim is one of the more dubious ones. what do you (or anyone else actually scumhunting) think on my post of vivax on ksc?
|
team hindu was completely town and all of the great mathemagicians were town.
not impossible that one of the romans and/or private investigators is scum...
but I dont really have a scum read on any of them?
might take a peak at mocsta if i get the time to do so.
random tinfoils:
maybe scum cant choose who gets converted and thats why it cant be prevented? maybe its some formula...
or the hosts rolled one at random cause whole scum team was afk as fuck?
|
I would be careful about putting much weight into the words of dead mafia. You cannot know their intentions other than that they want to confuse us.
|
|
|
It makes no sense why Grack would get removed by mafia since he was converted. Therefore he must have been removed by town. Since no one has claimed another role yet, barring sentinel claiming something, kelsier must be telling the truth
|
maybe they wanted to protect grack from being killed on accident to protect vivax?
sound super far fetched though
|
On April 11 2019 19:52 disformation wrote:
maybe they wanted to protect grack from being killed on accident to protect vivax?
sound super far fetched though
No way. Only possible explanation is if conversion is random, but I'm not going to treat that as likely at this point. But it's possible because converting grack is a bit weird.
|
another random idea i had is that maybe scum converts during the day phase. but we got the "genoa grows" after the night phase...
|
On April 09 2019 07:00 rsoultin wrote:
Eywa-, the Town Hindu-Arabic Mathematician[spoiler]You are a Hindu-Arabic Mathematician.
You are one of the preeminent mathematicians in Pisa working with Hindu-Arabic numerals. In response to Fibonacci’s recent suggestion that the world use your numbering system to achieve greater accuracy and facilitate conversions, a Hindu-Arabic Council is being formed in support. But there is also a Roman Council working to oppose the change.
You win with town.
Alternate win-condition #1: You win if you are recruited and serve on the full Hindu-Arabic Council.
Alternate win-condition #2: You win if all associated with the Roman Council are dead before End of Game.
For the last time, the next person who says i might be mafia i am going to vote for them and never ever do anything else until one of us dies. Like, can't you understand how ridiculously terrible this game has to be if i am mafia? I have the same exact role Eywa does (swap hindu -- roman), I have already won because the hindu arabic coucil which is recruiter + two mathematicians is dead. If i am mafia ia right now 100% telling you who my scumbuddies are, if for nothing else just because the setup would be so terrible (it is even now because it made all the mathematicians conf town from the beginning), but well because i have already won. If i am ever converted to being mafia this game i am going to 100% out all my scumbuddies right away, because see above. Same applies to FF (and MZ).
Is like half of the game really this stupid?
|
I honestly never cared which one of Vivax, Sentinel or Kelsier got lynched last night because i was like 90% sure all of them are mafia (as Grackaroni as i said) -- if there ever even was any mafia in this game, i wasn't sure about that. What's the point of starting to call Grackaroni scum based on what he did when he was not scum? I could easily make a legit town case on him if i knew he was town at the time lol.
Kelsier jails Palmar or he is mafia, he probably is anyways but still. Always auto-lynch Kelsier in case Palmar didn't get jailed, Palmar is the best bet for scum recruiter considering all things, if he is town then it's just tough luck.
|
It's hilarious though how bad the hindu-arabic people were, they just wanted to kill each other for no reason than paranoia.  Sounds liek a normal day in middle-east.
|
On April 09 2019 02:09 raynpelikoneet wrote:
vivax is mafia
I also had the best read in the game N1.
|
United States21170 Posts
With regard to Kels role, it feels mafia-flavored to me. Consider - mafia presumably knew that Grack was converted, and the following day Grack was unable to receive votes. Kels claims his actions was based on YOLO, which taken with everything seems bad.
However I've also filtered Vivax. From early on Vivax was trying to lynch Kels, so I think I wanna take him off the table tomorrow. He had him in sights D1 and was waffley on him D2, but careful to leave him on the table. My own reservations about his role aside, I think lynching Kels tomorrow a bad idea.
Conversely, his most recent reads post pretty heavily downplays a Sentinel lynch as "policy" and "lynch-baity".
Based on Vivax filter I think I'd like a Sent lynch tomorrow the mostest.
|
On April 11 2019 19:41 Palmar wrote:
I would be careful about putting much weight into the words of dead mafia. You cannot know their intentions other than that they want to confuse us.
Pandain dude, i really agree iwth this thing regardless of what Palmar is.
|
|
|
United Kingdom10443 Posts
On April 11 2019 22:50 VisceraEyes wrote:
With regard to Kels role, it feels mafia-flavored to me. Consider - mafia presumably knew that Grack was converted, and the following day Grack was unable to receive votes. Kels claims his actions was based on YOLO, which taken with everything seems bad.
However I've also filtered Vivax. From early on Vivax was trying to lynch Kels, so I think I wanna take him off the table tomorrow. He had him in sights D1 and was waffley on him D2, but careful to leave him on the table. My own reservations about his role aside, I think lynching Kels tomorrow a bad idea.
Conversely, his most recent reads post pretty heavily downplays a Sentinel lynch as "policy" and "lynch-baity".
Based on Vivax filter I think I'd like a Sent lynch tomorrow the mostest.
If it was a mafia role then in the mafia QT vivax just tells me grack is the other SCL and I recruit him N1 winning the game immediately.
|
On April 11 2019 22:54 raynpelikoneet wrote:Show nested quote +On April 11 2019 19:41 Palmar wrote:
I would be careful about putting much weight into the words of dead mafia. You cannot know their intentions other than that they want to confuse us. Pandain dude, i really agree iwth this thing regardless of what Palmar is.
Think that was @ me.
But I agree it's probably very good advice.
|
What do you think about what I said about Kelsier above on this page.
|
@Kelsier can you share your chat with grack?
|
United States21170 Posts
On April 11 2019 23:01 KelsierSC wrote:Show nested quote +On April 11 2019 22:50 VisceraEyes wrote:
With regard to Kels role, it feels mafia-flavored to me. Consider - mafia presumably knew that Grack was converted, and the following day Grack was unable to receive votes. Kels claims his actions was based on YOLO, which taken with everything seems bad.
However I've also filtered Vivax. From early on Vivax was trying to lynch Kels, so I think I wanna take him off the table tomorrow. He had him in sights D1 and was waffley on him D2, but careful to leave him on the table. My own reservations about his role aside, I think lynching Kels tomorrow a bad idea.
Conversely, his most recent reads post pretty heavily downplays a Sentinel lynch as "policy" and "lynch-baity".
Based on Vivax filter I think I'd like a Sent lynch tomorrow the mostest. If it was a mafia role then in the mafia QT vivax just tells me grack is the other SCL and I recruit him N1 winning the game immediately.
Unless you're lying about the whole "Untangle the lovers" thing which not only doesn't make any sense thematically but you've failed to adequately explain yourself.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
