|
On March 21 2018 15:23 Vivax wrote:
I'm currently thinking mafia are rsoultin, HF, ExO. HF read largely depending on NKs flip if we get that but I suspect shenannies today.
Fefe and Palmar are kind of my lower tier suspects . Disfo and rayn nullish and kind of reserved to be looked at later. Didn't look at much of what df has posted so far so got to keep him null for now. Skimming him makes me think he might be doing the rp thingy to conceal a lack of passion in his posts which is what sticks out to me on the go, but I'm also going to hedge on this one for now.
That's pretty much it when I disregard SL and Rels. I also might be being too generous with not considering Koshi and Moosy but I don't really see a benefit for them in playing like they do if they are mafia which is rather feather ruffling.
I don't usually mention that many big names on a D1 for suspects but when it's so many of them I almost have no choice if I want to tell everyone where my head is at.
I will only be casing ExO among them today though, maybe FF as well. I explained what made me suspicious of rso already and in regards to HF it's pretty much about the way he's going after NK. Should he flip town at some point I'll start casing HF, if NK flips mafia I can abandon that suspicion for a good while.
Are you referring to this post Vivax? Because I don't think there was this much content in this post. You basically said "here are some people and I kinda maybe not really think they might be scum" before going back to spending every post hard tunneling me.
|
On March 21 2018 20:19 Vivax wrote:
And I don't like that your post is basically begging me to unscumread you. I don't hate you ExO I just think you are mafia and I have to lynch mafia to play the game. So please stop giving me a guilty conscience.
Okay this is fine. I'm not mafia, I'm town, but sitting here back and forthing on this will get us no where.
Who are your other top scum reads?
|
yeah i'm not scum @.@
and 'calling me out' has nothing to do with how my reads progress
i think you're town, exo. and you're frankly shit at reading me. so i'd appreciate it if you gave this read of yours the doubt it deserves. it's pretty irritating when someone is this certain i'm scum every game and is this constantly wrong, but never seems to adjust his behavior
@ rayn, yeah idk. i'm not sure on disinfo at all, just would be more comfortable lynching into my five. and the comment about wanting to talk about slam had more to do with my wanting to not lynch him than that making him town lol >< selfishness
|
United Kingdom30774 Posts
I am so lost basically. Not really been able to do anything other than skim.
|
United Kingdom30774 Posts
I'm just gonna scum read the first people that called me town.
|
Koshi's posting style on day 1 drives me crazy because it seems so much like he doesn't give a shit -- but this seems more consistent with town Koshi than scum Koshi. Granted I've only seen scum Koshi one time that I can recall, but was on his team and his post did't have this I dont give a fuck attitude.
|
On March 21 2018 20:25 rsoultin wrote:
yeah i'm not scum @.@
and 'calling me out' has nothing to do with how my reads progress
i think you're town, exo. and you're frankly shit at reading me. so i'd appreciate it if you gave this read of yours the doubt it deserves. it's pretty irritating when someone is this certain i'm scum every game and is this constantly wrong, but never seems to adjust his behavior
@ rayn, yeah idk. i'm not sure on disinfo at all, just would be more comfortable lynching into my five. and the comment about wanting to talk about slam had more to do with my wanting to not lynch him than that making him town lol >< selfishness
I'll admit, I've been bad at reading you in the past, and in general am very susceptible to OMGUSing hard and tunneling hard instead of being to assess and re-evaluate. However I think I raised some very valid points when I posted. You weren't offering any hard reads, were very wishy-washy and were sticking to your one read.
I'll take another look at your filter but you're still pretty high on my list.
Does anybody have an example of a scum game for Noobking I can look at? He's made so many long ass posts and it's hard for me to believe scum could sustain his level of posts like this. A lot of the posts are terrible, but he is at least taking the time to type up all of that consistently.
|
5 mafia would be unbalanced unless town has 3 protection roles so I am assuming 4 mafia.
If there are 5 mafia hosts fucked up. Or should asap change the amount of night kills. So if there are 5 mafia. Contact the hosts that their balance is potentially shit.
Remember mafia has members/2 night kills rounded up. So 4 makes a lot of sense. Calix is probably smart.
|
On March 21 2018 20:31 ExO_ wrote:Show nested quote +On March 21 2018 20:25 rsoultin wrote:
yeah i'm not scum @.@
and 'calling me out' has nothing to do with how my reads progress
i think you're town, exo. and you're frankly shit at reading me. so i'd appreciate it if you gave this read of yours the doubt it deserves. it's pretty irritating when someone is this certain i'm scum every game and is this constantly wrong, but never seems to adjust his behavior
@ rayn, yeah idk. i'm not sure on disinfo at all, just would be more comfortable lynching into my five. and the comment about wanting to talk about slam had more to do with my wanting to not lynch him than that making him town lol >< selfishness I'll admit, I've been bad at reading you in the past, and in general am very susceptible to OMGUSing hard and tunneling hard instead of being to assess and re-evaluate. However I think I raised some very valid points when I posted. You weren't offering any hard reads, were very wishy-washy and were sticking to your one read. I'll take another look at your filter but you're still pretty high on my list. Does anybody have an example of a scum game for Noobking I can look at? He's made so many long ass posts and it's hard for me to believe scum could sustain his level of posts like this. A lot of the posts are terrible, but he is at least taking the time to type up all of that consistently.
-shrugs- you can be wrong. but i think i'm just as entitled to be annoyed by it. it's not like i really ever get mislynched barring highly unusual circumstances lol ><
but if you want real talk for your future rsoul reading i'll give it to you
i don't make shit up. my reads are what they are, and i don't misrepresent my certainty. i'm not an arrogant shit who thinks she's right all the time when experience has proven otherwise. that's why you see waffles
anyway, carry on. i've expressed my annoyance and it's not terribly relevant to the game
|
United Kingdom30774 Posts
Is my filter even good to be town read?
|
On March 21 2018 20:32 Koshi wrote:
5 mafia would be unbalanced unless town has 3 protection roles so I am assuming 4 mafia.
If there are 5 mafia hosts fucked up. Or should asap change the amount of night kills. So if there are 5 mafia. Contact the hosts that their balance is potentially shit.
Remember mafia has members/2 night kills rounded up. So 4 makes a lot of sense. Calix is probably smart.
-shrugs- idk. i think assuming there's 5 isn't awful, because if we're wrong we just win earlier \o/ or...were not going to win anyway? lol
|
On March 21 2018 20:36 Holyflare wrote:
Is my filter even good to be town read?
eh...not really. certainly not for hard town reads. then again, i have trouble confidently reading you town anyway -shrugs-
|
I'd lynch kelsier and ff as alternative to exo.
FF cause he marginally looks like he doesn't want to be seen doing nothing, since he posted lists.
|
@rsoultin,
Can you explain your initial comment saying "I don't think noob is scum, but I could vote him because I'm bored". I don't understand how that post can come from a town player.
If Slam isn't the lynch today who would your second choice be and why?
|
On March 21 2018 20:36 Holyflare wrote:
Is my filter even good to be town read?
No. Which is why I don't really get how rayn just tr you like that. seems fishy
|
On March 21 2018 20:38 rsoultin wrote:Show nested quote +On March 21 2018 20:32 Koshi wrote:
5 mafia would be unbalanced unless town has 3 protection roles so I am assuming 4 mafia.
If there are 5 mafia hosts fucked up. Or should asap change the amount of night kills. So if there are 5 mafia. Contact the hosts that their balance is potentially shit.
Remember mafia has members/2 night kills rounded up. So 4 makes a lot of sense. Calix is probably smart. -shrugs- idk. i think assuming there's 5 isn't awful, because if we're wrong we just win earlier \o/ or...were not going to win anyway? lol
Artanis and you are so alike.
11vs3 is a normal game. So you think it is fine to add 66% more mafia while adding less than 40% townies while making it so that mafia has 300% more killing power than normal, well let's say 250% more on average with roles.
If this isnt 16 vs 4 I will be so sad. More townies is balanced with a shitton more nk power.
|
United Kingdom30774 Posts
On March 21 2018 20:36 Holyflare wrote:
Is my filter even good to be town read?
Read it. It's not.
The hunt begins.
|
On March 21 2018 18:50 rsoultin wrote:
@NK, don't agree on conv, but your slam point is solid.
@KSC...I still don't remember reading his filter. Would have to check the filters of the people voting him. Which I'll probably do, but honestly I don't want to lynch him anyway because:
- viva read feels genuine to me <- this was my hesitance earlier
- focus on finding scum in those scumreading him feels super natural from town
- he's actually trying to engage me on slam <- entirely selfish reason
Removing disinfo from the lynch pool
Can you point to where you found vivax Scum hunting? Maybe my lenses are clouded here, but it looks to me like he hasn't done a lot of this. Again, it looks to me like he's tunneled me without really even analyzing my posts, and outside of that not scum hunted at all.
|
On March 21 2018 20:41 Vivax wrote:
I'd lynch kelsier and ff as alternative to exo.
FF cause he marginally looks like he doesn't want to be seen doing nothing, since he posted lists.
That's really kinda interesting to me. Are you trying to imply I'm on a scum team with kelsier?
Yeah I'm not sure I'm buying that as a real read.
|
Leaving for work.
@Vivax I'm really curious to see your response and explanation to wanting to lynch Kelsier while also I'm your #1 scum read.
@rsoultin responses to the above would be appreciated.
I'll be back in ~45 minutes but only for about 15 before I start work
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
