@hf: why is the df wagon okay despite no one trying to stop it? your reasons seem to amount to "he looks scummy", which is fine i guess, but if it's just that he's scummy are you even considering how the wagon forms? like, what would it take to change your mind, or do you just not actually care?

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

November 20 2017 15:26 GMT

#329

On November 20 2017 18:28 Stanislav Petrov wrote:

Show nested quote +

You're trying to stop it right now. The 'nobody is trying to stop it so therefore the accused is innocent' argument sound good in theory but has rarely proved accurate in my experience. And that's without considering how disastrous it would be to let that become meta. The facts are darthfoley is the most suspicious person, so we should lynch him.

ok but consider that
a) this was in reference to a post hf made saying "wagon has no opposition but w/e i think it's good, and
b) the only thing anyone has said in defense of df was a one-off post, by me, before anyone even attacked him, so
in conclusion, this post is really fucking stupid.

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

November 20 2017 15:34 GMT

#333

On November 21 2017 00:24 darthfoley wrote:
I haven't even been a lurker, so even for his standards his lynch preference makes no sense.

I've already said my piece on Oats. He's done nothing and seems content continuing to do nothing.

TW's whole filter is white knighting me while giving some really shallow reason to TR me early on. Feels like he justified his town read on me kind of weirdly

Show nested quote +

Why would I "rail" on my townread? How is it observant? He follows this up by only defending me and not trying to scumhunt. When I flip, he gets to say, "told you so!" without doing much to stop it

not that it's a long filter but i never actually defended you. i townread you in one post and asked a question in another. and that was it, except now i have to defend myself. you think that i, as mafia, would prefer to have 0 scumreads and just defend people (which people hate every time i do it)?
and u would rail on it if you needed to fake-SR someone (as mafia) and you had a decent point to push them with.

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

November 20 2017 15:40 GMT

#338

ok, i'll humor you.
worst filter in the game, palmar aside, is stan's. don't like the jokey-seeming damdred read being actual, or his post on me
i can't talk for much longer (i'll be on at least half an hour before deadline, pinkie promise). ok bye

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

November 20 2017 16:04 GMT

#345

On November 21 2017 00:47 Holyflare wrote:

Show nested quote +

Didn't like his questioning on stan or whatever his name is. Was quite obvious he meant that damdred, if mafia, would have a good town read on ruxxar.

Then his posts he picks out throughout the game just seem really odd. He presses the kelsier point far too much and like I said in my post earlier to you, what is mafia kelsier's motive to lie about a post that stuck out from the thread? Seems really fucking stupid to do and a stupid line of questioning.

He's just picking on things that don't align in my mind with what a towny would pick on. His scum list is basically that he couldn't understand a basic stan read and kelsier bs.

ok i know you said rux was town for dumbtelling, but that seems to have disappeared and you also called ve conftown for the same thing. why is rux not conftown in your mind?

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

November 20 2017 17:36 GMT

#402

On November 21 2017 01:27 Conversion wrote:
I don't like the fact that no one is calling me stupid/bad and that darthfoley is agreeing with me

probably amounts to nothing, but I don't like it

i don't think this is a post scum!conv makes. feels kinda silly but feels right.

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

November 20 2017 17:38 GMT

#405

On November 21 2017 01:27 KelsierSC wrote:

Show nested quote +

This is weird when hf has already said why he doesn't like rux.

it's not weird. i want to know why hf's reasons for scumminess override something that can make someone conftown.

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

November 20 2017 20:00 GMT

#537

On November 21 2017 04:34 Palmar wrote:
I like this conversion guy. Think I’ll sheep him

nah, i don't believe palmar comes back to the thread an hour before deadline and conversion is the guy he sheeps

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

November 20 2017 20:20 GMT

#566

filtering hf real quick & i will give you the verdict

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

November 20 2017 20:23 GMT

#573

yeah i'd prefer hf over df. his reasoning on rux is pretty bs imo, especially with the calling ve conftown thing i yelled at him about

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

November 20 2017 20:25 GMT

#581

imma hold out in case someone comes in last second but at :28 i'm switching to hf, a#uming nothing changes

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

November 20 2017 20:26 GMT

#586

ooooorrrr do that i guess. choo chooooo

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

November 22 2017 01:23 GMT

#852

the new news is that kels is town, and i liked z-boson's case on hapa, which leaves me with almost a scum pool and a town circle

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

November 22 2017 01:32 GMT

#853

reading ve's filter and i sorta hate it. first half is like 20% random really strong reads and 80% fluff. and the second half is like regular but not insightful really