Newbie Student Mafia XXVII - Page 3

On October 15 2017 04:09 Oatsmaster wrote:

What do you expect to happen between now and deadline that you dont want to commit???

On October 15 2017 00:42 Holyflare wrote:
I actually think damerion is really really mafia. All you have to do is look at how explanatory his posts are in this game and compare them to hurricane shelter. In hurricane the only thing he talks about are scum reads and they have concrete reasons to be scum leans etc. This game he appears to be constantly on the back foot, all his reads are flimsy town reads.

Looking at his big initial post a lot of them aren't actually town reads either. There's a bunch of flimsy stuff like ruxxar(?) posting good but not alignment indicative stuff??? Which makes the whole paragraph a waste of time and contradictory since good stuff is normally a townie trait and if it's not then why post about it.

He also seems robotic to me.

On October 15 2017 02:10 Holyflare wrote:
After re-evaluating Xenonn (actually reading his filter) I've come to the conclusion that Damdred, the god of tone reads, is actually mafia jumping on an incredibly easy bandwagon.

On October 15 2017 02:12 Holyflare wrote:


^^^^^^

This is all before he has completely switched up his playstyle to now be a mafia read that's not a mafia read, it's just "Interesting" and totally wasn't interesting in the slightest.

Then he just dropped off the face of the planet without talking to anyone.

On October 15 2017 04:17 Oatsmaster wrote:

So if you didnt like his posts and he continued to post things that you disliked, why dont you think he is mafia?

On October 15 2017 04:54 Onegu wrote:
On openings. There are 2 I didnt like.

Ruxxar and Damerion. Ruxxar seemed way to happy. Like way to happy, seemed off to me.

And Damerion was like lets not talk about roles but here is what you should do. Also to wordy. Seemed like he wrote it proof read it thought about it and posted it. Not really a way town thinks./ plays.

Like damdred feeling off about ruxxar says people who make him laugh but the fact he said something first I like.

Boom Oats comes in and slams Rux. I like oats.

HF says the same about Damer I like HF

Damdreds hard defend of Damer I find odd. Like he agrees he is playing different from the previous game but not enough different feels really off now with this defense.

Boom MrLonelyClock hits on Damerion. I like this newbie. He is somewhere inbetween the blue and yellow also!

Ugg but then he just is ok on Damer after one small post. TT why you do this. You null now.

Then votes with oats on Ruxx. Which I do like at this point.

I also like happykrogen at the moment. his response to damer is nice.

Yeah I like HF at the moment. Normally I just ignore him at this point. but meh.

Conversion giveing a town read and then like not saying why and its the same post other people said about Clock and the defense of Damer in the same post. dont like dont like...

Ruxxar like conversion. Makes me like conversion even less...

Ruxxar shits on me. Like Ruxxar even less.

Krogan voteing Rux. I like I like.

My god I like Rux less and less as I read. Like coaching the newbies to look helpful. Bleh I just dont like him at all.

Krogran picks up on it. My HERO!!!

Ruxxar going to try to lynch me I can feel it.

FF giveing Ruxxar a out is meh really.

I really feel weird about people 13 pages in only having town reads. Like not even scum leans its null or town thats it.

Ruxxar with the coaching again. Like I guess its a defense of him self but the way he does it in like a coaching way. Activity is town blah blah blah just rubs me the wrong way.

Grack is forgettable... bleh

HF is back to ignore... The whole krogan/ruxxar thing and HF response to it is making my response ignore HF.

DF I am ok with for now. His post about agreeing with HF on Krogan is bleh. I mean who isnt town reading Krogan right now? And that is a reason to give HF a pass? And I dont really like his Ruxxar town read. But his post isnt bringing any more red flags other than those.

But then the next post is within HF scum range... Lol ok... Still ok with DF.

Oats TMI post is meh. Still like his pushes though....

The whole thing on pocketing people is stupid and I am dumber for reading it.

HUH xenon thinks rux is town so he votes Oats? That cant be a scum play right> Like it just cant. I mean right? Huh?

Oats points out my thought on xenonn but I think 60% lynch bait 40% scum because really?


So I am running out of time so I am going to post this. I am still reading but I am also about to Top 8 a large MTGO tourny. Sooooo.

On October 15 2017 06:18 xenonn40 wrote:


Damerion's vote at the end seems very suspicious to me. He votes for Oats over a vote for Conversion to make himself safe from the lynch. He is last minute scrambling to target someone else. Seems like a desperate attempt to save a fellow mafia.

I am not sure if Godfather shows up as town when lynched, if so, perhaps Damerion is Godfather.

On October 15 2017 04:40 Conversion wrote:


we're at 3:3 right now and I have to leave soon

I'm about to just tiebreak on Damerion and go because I don't want to die to someone who makes 5 posts and AFKs

also where is onegu's post?

On October 15 2017 05:00 Conversion wrote:
well that wasn’t useful. I’m heading out now, I don’t want to die, and no one gave me any reason why damerion is not the lynch today. clockman couldn’t even retort as to why he doesn’t have to same conclusion for damerion besides feelings and because I post more

On October 15 2017 06:10 Conversion wrote:
gg all

On October 16 2017 02:45 Oatsmaster wrote:
Hey onegu, can you explain why the heck you wasted your vote on rux when your other scumread damerion actually had a chance of being lynched?

On October 16 2017 07:39 Damdred wrote:


But didnt you say the whole point was grack and not oats?