I'm not sure if it's 100% necessary. Depends on who he is (scumread to any extent?) and if his checks are of any use.

It would make today easier though, I guess, if that happened.

Xatalos

Finland9673 Posts

March 22 2017 23:14 GMT

#2430

Now off to sleep for realz

raynpelikoneet

Finland43266 Posts

March 22 2017 23:18 GMT

#2431

On March 23 2017 08:14 Xatalos wrote:

Show nested quote +

I'm not sure if it's 100% necessary. Depends on who he is (scumread to any extent?) and if his checks are of any use.

It would make today easier though, I guess, if that happened.

Yes it is. Because if and when we hit mafia i am a cop too.

Maybe you're not scum after all, that was a terrible night kill.

raynpelikoneet

Finland43266 Posts

March 22 2017 23:19 GMT

#2432

It's Onegu and one of darthfoley and Tumblewood.

raynpelikoneet

Finland43266 Posts

March 22 2017 23:21 GMT

#2433

Okay i take back what i said about the cop claim. Cop doesn't need to claim but that only is true if people believe i am town, otherwise it's just terrible not to claim.

Koshi

Belgium38797 Posts

March 22 2017 23:35 GMT

#2434

I just had the best day of my life. If I died, I would have died a happy man.
I'll catch up tomorrow. gn boys. RIP girl.

AMG

Australia298 Posts

March 23 2017 00:20 GMT

#2435

On March 23 2017 08:21 raynpelikoneet wrote:
Okay i take back what i said about the cop claim. Cop doesn't need to claim but that only is true if people believe i am town, otherwise it's just terrible not to claim.

I never thought you were anything but town.

If you asked me to wait up and not go to bed the other night, to sit around "discussing mafia reads" while being scum the whole time, not only are you a dick, but youre dead to me. IRL.

raynpelikoneet

Finland43266 Posts

March 23 2017 00:23 GMT

#2436

I have to keep that in mind the next time i am gonna roll scum.

AMG

Australia298 Posts

March 23 2017 00:24 GMT

#2437

Tschh you would, wouldnt you!

raynpelikoneet

Finland43266 Posts

March 23 2017 00:35 GMT

#2438

idk. This game has been very hard for me to put any significant effort into in terms of anything other than just dumping out what i think for reasons that are not relevant to this game. It stopped when you joined the game.

Well i think this night kill makes Xatalos town. It's completely weird logic to kill Calix here because the only reasons it makes sense to do so is if it is a cophunt. The kill is also super weird because in case you happen to miss the cop you're suddenly in a situation where you absolutely lose if ANY of your teammates gets killed the next day. It's basically a high risk low reward kill. Even if you manage to shoot the cop then so what? Again if one of your mambers gets killed the next day you're in a situation where the Jailkeeper is suddenly a cop, a cop who also ignores the Godfather. Basically you have 100% chance to shoot a "better" blue than the cop and you take ????% chances to to shoot the other blue?!?!?

Calix' reads in this point don't matter for any smart mafia, because regardless of how right or wrong she is, you can't shoot her.

Xatalos does not do that. Koshi doesn't do that. I find it very hard to believe you would do that.
So i am left with Onegu and one of DF / Tumble.