On October 08 2016 17:11 Calix wrote:
I still think JAT is the scummiest player in the thread. As flagged up earlier, I get the impression that he just pops in to make leading comments that serve the mafia agenda. It's a Saturday morning so no harm in me reading his filter now.

And I think the other two are among you, Damdred, Superbia because I think the majority of the scum are passive/ lack influence.

You could add Palmar/ Koshi but I think those two are town.

I have yet to see a reason from you not to vote Damdred.

NeverUnlucky

Canada1622 Posts

October 08 2016 12:36 GMT

#2202

On October 08 2016 21:29 Calix wrote:
On Day 1, I town-read him.

I didn't have one for most of Day 2 since he didn't do anything.

Now I'm skeptical because of that horrendous vote.

Would you kindly share your opinion on Oats?

Personally, my town-read of him is fading out.

He asks for others' opinions more than he gives his.
He mischaracterizes stuff sometimes.
Connects with 1 - no read progression/I don't know why he is voting X.
Was pretty defensive over his vote D1 when no accusations against him were made. Much of an overreaction.

(NAI) His fake-voting puzzles me. Really.

NeverUnlucky

Canada1622 Posts

October 08 2016 12:42 GMT

#2206

On October 08 2016 21:37 justanothertownie wrote:

Show nested quote +

My priorities in a town game besides lynching mafia are the following:

1. Don't get mislynched/establish innocence.
2. Push the game in a good direction. This means don't allow people to not explain their shit, ideally have 2 wagons day1. Stuff like that.

Ok, he's just bad. He can be town for now.

NeverUnlucky

Canada1622 Posts

October 08 2016 12:52 GMT

#2208

On October 08 2016 21:29 Calix wrote:
On Day 1, I town-read him.

I didn't have one for most of Day 2 since he didn't do anything.

Now I'm skeptical because of that horrendous vote.

I mean, I don't see a single good vote in the train you are leading. Plam is sheeping you, Grack ???, Oats ???, and you are not confident in him being scum anymore. It seems like you just want him lynched to get things cleared though I don't know what exactly.

Frankly, I don't know why you scum-read him now. And he makes a good point when he says that no cases were made on him D2 re: if there were cases on him, they are outdated and maybe connect with his interaction with BS who flipped town.

So... why do you and the others on the train sr him?

Who would your vote be going to otherwise?

NeverUnlucky

Canada1622 Posts

October 08 2016 13:07 GMT

#2212

On October 08 2016 21:56 justanothertownie wrote:

Show nested quote +

If everyone on TL was as good at this as I am then town would never lose a game. Just sayin.

Oh, I have no doubt about that with the way you push your scum-reads. Other people who've played with you in the past considered your play to be naturally underwhelming.

Self-centered, egoistical players do not make town win. Sorry to say.

Your ego: [image loading]

NeverUnlucky

Canada1622 Posts

October 08 2016 13:20 GMT

#2215

On October 08 2016 22:10 Calix wrote:
That's a lovely self-portrait, NU.

Why, thank you.

Also, why did you do a "tl;dr" for a one-liner, lmao?

NeverUnlucky

Canada1622 Posts

October 08 2016 13:21 GMT

#2217

Oh, I get it. :3

NeverUnlucky

Canada1622 Posts

October 08 2016 13:25 GMT

#2218

"And this is odd because I swear he was scum-reading/ voting for HF earlier and I have no idea how his read changed from the end of D1 to this post."

He is still clearly scum-reading HF in this post you quoted ("Hf might be the mafia vig that would be interesting", mafia vig, wtf lol). There is no incongruity there.

I don't get point 1. Point 2 is ok.

NeverUnlucky

Canada1622 Posts

October 08 2016 14:22 GMT

#2225

NU likes Koshi's points.

NU is but a simple sheep. NU agrees with Koshi, NU sheeps Koshi.

NeverUnlucky

Canada1622 Posts

October 08 2016 14:24 GMT

#2226

On October 08 2016 23:11 Koshi wrote:
superbia is mafia as well.

Not sure I agree, but I would lynch him nonetheless for stopping to make funny posts.

NeverUnlucky

Canada1622 Posts

October 08 2016 15:03 GMT

#2232

On October 08 2016 23:59 Palmar wrote:
Wow I go afk and the narrative changes... who would've thought??

lalalala can't hear you over how much mafia you are

lul

NeverUnlucky

Canada1622 Posts

October 08 2016 15:10 GMT

#2233

Palmar's first two filter pages are town except for his rude modkill post. Me not sure if Palmar is scum.

NeverUnlucky

Canada1622 Posts

October 08 2016 15:19 GMT

#2235

My modkill benefits scum, so it is a scummy thing to say, yes.

NeverUnlucky

Canada1622 Posts

October 08 2016 16:29 GMT

#2237

On October 08 2016 23:53 Calix wrote:
I'll drop my vote before I leave.

I also like Koshi's point about "playing right above not getting lynched" as a descriptor of Palmar's posts, it's quite accurate imo. I'll consider it.

Would also consider voting for Scott.

As it stands, I'm just unvoting for now.

Yes, it is accurate. Is it scum-AI though?

NeverUnlucky

Canada1622 Posts

October 08 2016 17:21 GMT

#2244

I just town-read him because he was funny and wanted him around. Now I don't mind him eating rope.

+ Show Spoiler [*giggles*] +

On September 29 2016 19:10 Superbia wrote:
I will roll PR or mafia this game.

I can feel it in my bones.

And he probably did not roll PR.

NeverUnlucky

Canada1622 Posts

October 08 2016 17:28 GMT

#2247

I'm down for a Superbia shenannie.

[image loading]

NeverUnlucky

Canada1622 Posts

October 08 2016 17:29 GMT

#2248

Also liking the new Jat.

Calix, do you still think Jat is the scummiest player?

NeverUnlucky

Canada1622 Posts

October 08 2016 17:37 GMT

#2252

Yeah yeah yeah, a pretty good case.

I don't feel strongly about Palmar. I would not say that he is town, but other Koshi's survivalist argument, I can't find reasons to think he is mafia. His two first filter pages gave me town vibes.

Palmar / Super makes sense given their interactions. Damdred would be the other one. Damdred pretty much fits in every scum team as he plays the game so distantly. Maybe Grack.