EPT[M][N] Murder on the Cruise Trip Mafia - Page 13
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
NeverUnlucky
Canada1622 Posts
| ||
|
NeverUnlucky
Canada1622 Posts
| ||
|
NeverUnlucky
Canada1622 Posts
The empty slot. Enters the game by asking Calix if she is town. Not really telling though I am leaning to think this is more of a townie question than a scum question. On October 04 2016 07:47 Stutters695 wrote: What is peeking? Theoretical / not game-relevant question. On October 04 2016 10:04 Stutters695 wrote: Is calix this abrasive when she's town generally? Another question about Calix's alignment. I think it is a genuine one for I cannot see it as a shade-throw. He looks interested in finding Calix's alignment. More town than scum post. On October 05 2016 12:26 Stutters695 wrote: Goddamn you guys post too much. Catching up. Last thing we've heard from him. He never caught up. Unlike what I I remembered of Stutts' filter, none of his posts are scummy. Replaced by Scott: On October 07 2016 06:20 scott31337 wrote: Hey all - I'm at like page 71 and catching up. NAI. On October 07 2016 12:23 scott31337 wrote: Koshi - Carefree Koshi, leaning town for now. Calix - He hates it when I put him in the tinfoil town pile, so I'll do it again.  marvellosity - town, pretty confident of - if he got mafia again he'd be all mopey and shit Palmar - Null/Leaning Scum - Trying to coast, doesn't give much for info. (Lynch Calix) justanothertownie - leaning scum, he's doing the not getting info/shitposting JAT - which is a mafia trait for him. Damdred-slight townlean/almost null - very little to go on. NeverUnlucky - town, probably #2 - lots of info, somewhat helpful. Oatsmaster - townlean - points out some inconstistencies in posts that I've seen Superbia - Uggg - kind of like last game - not very helpful - null Grackaroni - like last game too but nothing of help/doing/etc. That's where I'm at now - Lynch Palmar/JAT preferred, Poke Super and Grack some more. It feels like the explanation he gives for his reads do not match the player he associated them with. ie Oats pointing out inconsitencies, me having lots of info, JAT shitposting. His reads criteria are inconsistent too - Palmar lean-scum, Damdred lean-town, Super + Grack null for essentially the same reasoning. Also am uncertain of the validity of his read on Marv. This post going somewhat along thread consensus left many questions unanswered which he still has not addressed. Scummy-ish post for the mischaracterizations of the players and a very measly contribution (if any). On October 07 2016 12:25 scott31337 wrote: Why aren't you voting for him then? Where's the phat case? This post is NAI as well imo. My conclusion: No real reason to scum-read this slot at the moment. \0 at its best. | ||
|
NeverUnlucky
Canada1622 Posts
| ||
|
NeverUnlucky
Canada1622 Posts
| ||
|
NeverUnlucky
Canada1622 Posts
On October 08 2016 01:06 Oatsmaster wrote: you think both marv and palmar are mafia? Who do you think are the mafia, hmm? ^^ | ||
|
NeverUnlucky
Canada1622 Posts
 | ||
|
NeverUnlucky
Canada1622 Posts
On October 07 2016 18:44 justanothertownie wrote: The fact that there is nothing new in itself is a reason to scumread palmar btw. Yes, he is a lazy asshole as town but not when he is the designated lynch. First I want to address this. You say that Plamar is lazy as town unless he is set to be the lynch. Considering that he has made some attempts to contribute this morning, why is your vote still on him? What makes him scummy? My understanding of your vote was that it was a pressure vote to get him to contribute, which he has done to an extent. Therefore, unless you think he is scummy and can show me how, I don't understand why your vote is still on him. On October 07 2016 19:16 justanothertownie wrote: I am lynching Palmar right now and have said that and also voted him for ages. That should be pretty obvious. I would love to keep listening to your bullshit but unfortunately I have to work now. | ||
|
NeverUnlucky
Canada1622 Posts
On October 08 2016 02:25 justanothertownie wrote: And I will immediately prove myself as a giant hypocrite by sayng that as long as Palmar and marv keep scumreading each other the likelihood that I will vote outside of those 2 is very low and I think not solving this today would be a big mistake. Why Plam over marv may I ask? Marv is the scummier of the two in my eyes. | ||
|
NeverUnlucky
Canada1622 Posts
Let's say you weren't committed to voting Marv/Palmar depending on their interactions (Which may never evolve given Plam's recent apathy), who would you be voting? | ||
|
NeverUnlucky
Canada1622 Posts
| ||
|
NeverUnlucky
Canada1622 Posts
If not, what is your opinion on Scott/Stutts? What is your opinion on my simili-filter-dive of that slot? Also, I've seen you say that you "null-scum" read Calix. Care to go more in detail? If there is any other subject of discussion you can come up with, I am all ears. | ||
|
NeverUnlucky
Canada1622 Posts
On October 08 2016 02:54 justanothertownie wrote: On the other hand I did not have that much of a problem with his content and he said he was sick. Maybe he will get replaced. Similarly, you said that Stutters would get modkilled if he was town (Or I think that was you...). Does him not being MKed but instead replaced make you feel he is town/scum or do you think that your previous argument was just bad? | ||
|
NeverUnlucky
Canada1622 Posts
Pros: + Show Spoiler [Pre-flip associations are bad bad bad…] + I cannot think of a scumteam that makes sense for him with bats and HF dead. Did not like Calix's 'case' on him (Maybe it's my distrust of her, idk) Don't remember Plam nor Oats stating why they were voting for him ie indication of a bad train. He is pugnacious. Cons: Seemed defensive No town tone (To me that's a big one) | ||
|
NeverUnlucky
Canada1622 Posts
| ||
|
NeverUnlucky
Canada1622 Posts
On October 08 2016 03:57 marvellosity wrote: most of the game is just other people asking people (e.g. me) to 'do things' as if that's doing something themselves. it isn't. no-one is actually doing anything. That's my biggest FM pet peeve. On October 08 2016 04:02 marvellosity wrote: i wish you guys had just gone along with me more on the palmar thing, because he had a half hour flurry of decent posts and now he's coasting on it because everyone went 'oooh that looked nice'. it's so dull :/ What is your Jat read? | ||
|
NeverUnlucky
Canada1622 Posts
On October 08 2016 04:04 marvellosity wrote: you have 13 and i think much the same. so de facto you're scummier. except i don't particularly think you are, so meh. Comparing yourself to others is a common thing for you, mmk. Surely you remember my posts. Just think of Shitposts, Powerpuff Girls and "bad". | ||
|
NeverUnlucky
Canada1622 Posts
On October 08 2016 03:57 marvellosity wrote: Palmar isn't being supertown despite his own proclamations, so i can basically conclude he's unable to give any reasonable explanation for his actions Ok, but why are you voting him? "Not supertown" != Mafia | ||
|
NeverUnlucky
Canada1622 Posts
Quote it at least. No reason to act anti-town. | ||
|
NeverUnlucky
Canada1622 Posts
On October 07 2016 06:31 marvellosity wrote: might as well elaborate on palmar a little, pros and cons: flicking through his filter just now, there are quite a few posts that look decently like flippant town palmar but he criticised the lynch while doing absolutely nothing about it. it's an awfully long time ago now but it reminds me very much of rockband where he shat all over the prplhz lynch d1 while doing absolutely nothing about it. he voted for hf instead (on nothing) having previously kinda townread him, and then subsequently townread him (????). like he says hf looks fine, votes him for a total non-reason at deadline while doing nothing to dissuade the bats wagon, and then calls him town after. it's all just nonsense and palmar doesn't generally do nonsense of that variety as town. plus there were one or two other things i picked out on day 1 that i don't remember now but hey if he's town he can so easily turn things around, because i'll always listen to him (which he knows) The bolded is a decent argument. But it's really all there is to your case. "plus there were one or two other things i picked out on day 1 that i don't remember now" isn't really helpful. | ||
| ||
