[M][N] Onegu is the Best Host Mafia Part 2

On August 06 2016 22:42 nnn_thekushmountains wrote:
Game starts in .

On August 09 2016 05:27 Grackaroni wrote:

This Lunatic post is a post that I think would draw a lot of unwarranted suspicion just from disagreeing with the current lynch targets and proposing people not currently being suspected while also avoiding the most useless people. I think it's more likely to be his actual way of reading the game than mafia play.

Also Glowingbear's continued push on Disinfo reads a bit red to me just because he didn't comment on anything at all that's happened since he was last here and Disinfo has been posting quite a bit since he was gone.

Kush is definitely my favorite lynch of the bunch right now.

On August 09 2016 03:56 Stutters695 wrote:


What makes you like the Luna lynch? It actually feels like he doesn't have the time to me.

On August 09 2016 05:37 Shapelog wrote:

Lol, I don't either XD.
I just say what ever is off the top of my head, and get the sweet rush of success when i find out post game, I have 2-1 mafia right Day 1.

On August 09 2016 05:39 Grackaroni wrote:
You ready to get on the Kush wagon HF?

On August 09 2016 05:54 mderg wrote:

No?

On August 09 2016 06:04 Shapelog wrote:
Urg......

3-3-3-2

That is the votes rn.


Can I ask Why?

Both were the leading wagons, so voting for each other early on makes sense?

On August 09 2016 06:09 mderg wrote:

Be careful, you're going into strong wifom territory here.

On August 09 2016 06:10 Holyflare wrote:
Also luna can you tell me why you said that comment earlier about 1 mafia on someone and 1 not voting? Talk me through what went through your mind

On August 09 2016 06:15 Shapelog wrote:

I understand the bold a bit, but...It was what? A few hours into the day cycle?

and about the [u], if the person who is against u is town. then wouldn't u sacrificing yourself be 2/0 if u were town.,...

On August 09 2016 06:25 disformation wrote:

Actually not sure between grack and kush.
in their exchange i like grack more. but grack had this really bad part in his exchange later with me.

On August 09 2016 06:36 Damdred wrote:
Honestly here's where I stand, lunatics little suspicion on me is borderline cute. But I can probably see a newbie town fall into a narrative instead of a scum who's trying to survive. I still don't like the soft pushes with very little substance to back it up or a real push on who he wants to lynch. But I think it's enough for me not to want to kill him today and 're evaluate tonight tomorrow with a clear head and more information.

Gb while I agree I dislike the play he is doing I also don't know if it's worth a lynch yet. I've seen him do this a few times as town and he matched my thought process at points and lives scum reading me as both alignments. So I am a little pocketed.

All in all I think kush is the best lynch, we gain not Mich in the way of information but if you compare his last few town games he has done nothing like this in any. Even when he was super ark and for lynched he at least had some reads in the thread.

Anywya vote kush

On August 09 2016 06:49 Damdred wrote:


What you are doing is nothing but soft pushes really

On August 09 2016 06:50 Grackaroni wrote:
I'm trying to decide which wagon is more likely to have scum and I can't decide.

On August 09 2016 06:59 Damdred wrote:


Not sure why exactly I pushed for the 'll synch I wanted and got it.

Vivax idk just is a null thing his play is kinda bad though.

In any case if kush flips scum I think,lunatic is basically lock town. If he's town than this post is bad for,trying to attribute blame to for no real reason.

On August 09 2016 07:15 Damdred wrote:
Meh stuff happens, it wasn't a bad lynch though in any case.

And while I understand your frustration hf just kind of not sure if Gb was scum meh.

And shape I disagree with right now.

On August 09 2016 07:55 sicklucker wrote:
were actually in the twilight zone. I dont even care if grac is town im killing him because its way too creepy

On August 09 2016 16:57 disformation wrote:
Good morning.
As time progresses GB is wandering down towards the bottom of my list. Unwillingness to change ones reads is a good scum indicator in my experience. Not that he really has any reads besides me. Might be a bit biased therefore though.

I want to completely reread/reevaluate grack and luna.

@Luna: I still have no idea why you want to lynch me. Plus now you are saying that the other guy who wants to lynch me is a good shot? You are making very little sense to me.
Also it is night time your current vote is invalid.

TBH Luna might just be one of those ppl I can't read for shit, but let me look at his filter later.
Also not going the VCA at work, so you guys have to wait for this evening for that.

On August 09 2016 17:11 disformation wrote:
It is like you are refusing to take responsibility for your filter/past actions. Which screams scum to me.

On August 09 2016 17:45 disformation wrote:

If you think kush was obv town then you have TMI.
You are also admitting that a no-lynch would have been better than the kush lynch?
I agree on Vivax. Have to reread Damdred.

On August 09 2016 21:40 mderg wrote:

How do we all know you're town? I don't see what would make you town over anybody else?

On August 09 2016 21:43 mderg wrote:

I don't think GB's unwillingness to change his reads points towards him being scum. It looked like he had a scumread on you for your opening and then didn't bother to play the game. That's fucking lazy and bad as either alignment.

On August 09 2016 21:57 mderg wrote:

I don't know but I for sure don't like your position in this game.

On August 09 2016 22:19 mderg wrote:


Tell me what makes you not scum mister I didn't like the kush lynch therefore I'm town.

On August 09 2016 22:38 mderg wrote:

I don't want to write anything that could get me into trouble, so I'll just say this condescending attitude of yours doesn't make me like you more.

On August 09 2016 22:58 disformation wrote:
okay sweetheart, prolly last attempt to reason with you, cause your attitude is horrible and I might make as much progress when talking to a wall.

TMI means too much information. Basically since Scum knows the alignment of everyone in the game, they sometimes do stuff like super hard TR one person, not really defend them and then pretend to be super towny for having know that a person was town while having done nothing to prevent the lynch.
kinda sounds familiar somehow, but I cant put my finger on it...

also no idea where your "read" on damdred comes from. i think it is as good as your "read" on me. hint: not very good.
if you want to scumread everyone voting kush, you have 9 scummers this game. gl.

On August 09 2016 22:56 mderg wrote:

How about you start explaining why you are town, so a stupid 3 year old like me can understand?

On August 09 2016 23:04 disformation wrote:

also no idea where your "read" on damdred comes from. i think it is as good as your "read" on me. hint: not very good.

On August 09 2016 23:36 Damdred wrote:
I actually answered that question.

It's the same answer every game this game slightly different because of majority.

Holding a vote isn't inherently scummy that's just a arbitrary flag you are trying to attribute to my play that doesn't make anyone scum

Also as you call me lurking most people would know I'm just not here. I really don't lurk as scum.

On August 09 2016 23:44 Damdred wrote:
I explained why I wanted to Lynch Kush several times.

On August 09 2016 06:36 Damdred wrote:
Honestly here's where I stand, lunatics little suspicion on me is borderline cute. But I can probably see a newbie town fall into a narrative instead of a scum who's trying to survive. I still don't like the soft pushes with very little substance to back it up or a real push on who he wants to lynch. But I think it's enough for me not to want to kill him today and 're evaluate tonight tomorrow with a clear head and more information.

Gb while I agree I dislike the play he is doing I also don't know if it's worth a lynch yet. I've seen him do this a few times as town and he matched my thought process at points and lives scum reading me as both alignments. So I am a little pocketed.

All in all I think kush is the best lynch, we gain not Mich in the way of information but if you compare his last few town games he has done nothing like this in any. Even when he was super ark and for lynched he at least had some reads in the thread.

Anywya vote kush

On August 10 2016 03:27 Tumblewood wrote:
if you hate someone it usually means they're town
luna is too anal to be scum

On August 10 2016 05:48 Shapelog wrote:

You passed my test.

On August 10 2016 05:55 Shapelog wrote:

We talking about HF's progression on his read on you.

What I am saying is basically this: HF comes and pushes you. Calls you 100% mafia, and basically just really up for your death. You come back and start posting, and HF somewhat quickly loosens up on his read on you. Quickly enough, to where I feel that it is too quick for scum (I feel scum would continue it for a bit longer). And, during a time that you were viewed as a good lynch. So instead of pushing you, when he could easily do during then, and drop off later if needed. He changed his mind, and even pushed another lynch instead.

On August 10 2016 18:42 disformation wrote:
Eh, kinda too late. xD
SL had that super wasted vote D1 though.

A pool of: Stutters, mderg, GB and SL still makes sense though I think.

On August 10 2016 19:07 Holyflare wrote:
Why do you want to lynch disfo over the guy that basically just claimed gb is miller?

On August 10 2016 19:14 Holyflare wrote:
No, it makes 0 difference, SL is extremely likely to be mafia.

On August 10 2016 19:28 Holyflare wrote:
How the shit do I know if there was one or two? SL just claimed and formulated a plan to lynch me, the claimed cop if GB flips miller, without any CCs whatsoever for what reason? 0 unless he knows GB is town and I am town which he can only do if he's mafia.

Basically he claimed mafia but we still lynch GB to put the final nail in his coffin.

On August 10 2016 20:05 Holyflare wrote:
No he slipped man. There's wifom and then there's "I have too much information and need to make it fit"

On August 07 2016 07:29 disformation wrote:

hm. thought so. Lots of ppl I haven't played with before in this actually.
I am also noticing quite a bit of brevity on your part. I do hope your <insert local time of day here> is okay. Or are you unhappy with which fate RNGesus provided you?

On August 07 2016 23:53 disformation wrote:



Where is sicklucker in the second post?

On August 11 2016 19:49 Holyflare wrote:
Why not just post the major post to begin with?

On August 11 2016 20:17 disformation wrote:
fun fact: my name is not disformation.
cant do extensive filtering/quoting reading at work. hence why i put that shit on my todo.

aaaand your last game was ongoing until recently.

tbh i think your just trying to fit stuff together to paint me red, as indicated in the last part whete you say that i am scum regardless of gb, after basing a huge part of your "case" on me being scum with gb.

*yawn* back to work

On August 11 2016 21:00 disformation wrote:
also: if you thought i might be blue. why the fuck did you vote me d1?

On August 11 2016 23:03 sicklucker wrote:
well if gbs scum lunatic is probably scum with him

On August 11 2016 23:28 Grackaroni wrote:
Also Lunatic, are not you afraid of the SILENT mafia? The most deadly mafia of them all, you know.

On August 12 2016 02:40 disformation wrote:

no its not. its scum indicative for you to have voted someone who you thought might be blue.

On August 12 2016 02:55 disformation wrote:

So if I was like a doc or a cop or whatever, you would have been okay with scum just shooting me for free N1?
Amazing plays.

On August 12 2016 03:08 Damdred wrote:
Disf is coming off really Towny in this situation

I'm curious lunatic you were voting disf even today and why would he claim a role when he's not up for Lynch at that point?

On August 12 2016 02:58 disformation wrote:
YOU VOTED ME D1

On August 12 2016 04:52 Shapelog wrote:

That was actually something I was going to include in the meta discussion lol. the fact you were working 24 hours during that game.

[u] part, Onegu is prob bleaching his eyes over it.

On August 12 2016 04:54 disformation wrote:




Okay, maybe I should have made it more clear for stutters: I thought the wowzers would imply that I am taken aback by how different the filters are.
On your activity: lo and behold, I said the same thing.

On August 12 2016 04:56 Stutters695 wrote:

Protip: I've played over 20 games. There are ways to catch me as scum, but activity is quite literally the worst one to pick.

On August 12 2016 17:00 disformation wrote:
nah, luna has a few mentions of mderg in his filter.
from a real quick glance: suspicions early/mid D1 into a TR/lean later. seems to be a tr currently.

On August 13 2016 04:45 Grackaroni wrote:
Lunatic why did you vote dis during the start of day 1?

On August 13 2016 04:59 disformation wrote:


touché

On August 13 2016 20:00 sicklucker wrote:
I almost want to give town points for grac and mderg for snap voting. this should be 7 snap votes its like his partners are believing in him

On August 14 2016 03:40 Holyflare wrote:
I don't think I'm particularly shitting up the thread either, I've given you all game relevant information to my thought processes, why SL is mafia and why I thought Luna/Dis etc were town. I've given you my check of Stutters (green) etc etc, not really much shitting.

On August 14 2016 04:07 Holyflare wrote:


That doesn't mean you have to stop playing the game. You can clear up your alignment to the other players.

Explain to me why you thought Disformation's first post was him claiming blue?

On August 14 2016 06:02 Grackaroni wrote:
lol thanks for visualizing it Lunatic.

One question:
Would it throw a wrench into your read if I said that Disfo could be a vigi?

On August 14 2016 06:34 Shapelog wrote:

What about Dis-i-land?

On August 14 2016 20:38 Holyflare wrote:
I am European but I'm sure it feels like you're the only one when you ignore all of my posts :/

On August 15 2016 07:12 mderg wrote:

I don't think that's the point when you should have gotten me. That was 100% an act.

On August 15 2016 07:17 Half the Sky wrote:


The thing is - and this is partially aimed at GlowingBear - you are going to need more than "bad entrance" to say someone is mafia and further more convince others that they are mafia.

There are players (like me, since I have somewhat of a dry personality in game admittedly) that have poor entrances as either alignment. A better case will have a combination of elements. Poor entrance plus suspicious vote switches, plus whatever else. That's what gives you a better push.

On August 15 2016 07:22 Holyflare wrote:
Nah Lunatic, I would have read your case on disformation and talked about it more if it wasn't based on things that don't really make anyone mafia. It seemed like your case was based a lot on GB and a lot on things that didn't make sense to other people other than yourself.

On August 15 2016 20:01 Skynx wrote:
Never lynch kush D1 boys.