Newbie Student Mafia XXII - Page 4

On August 02 2016 06:03 Rels wrote:
Scum team is very likely to be in this pool:

mderg
Celestial / KSC / Stutters
BTDT

On August 02 2016 07:49 Stutters695 wrote:
Scum doesn't hammer themselves. Just saying.

On August 02 2016 07:54 mderg wrote:

Why else would I change my vote to silent other than staying alive. I'm not stupid enough to play the "I'm hammering myself" card

On August 02 2016 07:56 Stutters695 wrote:

Scum also have a tendency to think things through a bit more than town.

On August 02 2016 08:14 J Roc wrote:



I am mobile with shit internet. When I was typing out my vote it was 3-3 by time it was posted silent voted mderg and mderg unvoted.

After I voted in cote thread I came here and said what I did. Internet made another delay and I posted after deadline

On August 02 2016 11:33 J Roc wrote:



Oh so you are scum. Cool. Nothing to refute or anything.

Next time just post baby seals.

On August 02 2016 11:39 Stutters695 wrote:
What was your last scum game grack?

On August 02 2016 10:51 Stutters695 wrote:
Going to get my thoughts out there so people can argue them in case I get shot tonight. My main two scum reads first.

Grack: Looks pretty bad from the day in general. Even worse after the flip. Doing a re-read as I post this.


#234 - it's weird that he has a town read on RB, but null.

#237- Want to note his "mafia play more subdued" comment.

Moving on.


+ Show Spoiler +

This post bothers me. At best this is lazy scumhunting when he should know better. This post lacks any justification into why scum mderg would push those people, just that he should be lynched for having different reads.

#326 slight positive for calling out skynx, petty easy thing to see and no real follow-up to be found.

+ Show Spoiler +

Has dropped Mderg without any new scumreads of merit or even real suspicion.

#358 His case is built on Btdt's case while only contributing that L didn't comment on C's point against grack, however in the quote L thinks he "is probably town" in direct contrast to C's scum lean.

Followed by some omgus on me, but I consider that pretty null.


Now onto crunch time:

Says he's going to re-read Lunas filter from a previous game.
OMGUS vote on me with no actual intent to push me.
Doesn't follow up on the Luna meta read.

Sheeps Rels on Mderg. Again, nothing original.

+ Show Spoiler +

This post especially bothers me. He doesn't acknowledge the clear distinction between a plynch and normal vote which is especially odd considering I was his vote before sheeping Rels.

Second point again is wrong. Just soft defending.

Although I disagree, I can understand the third point as a difference in philosophy. I'd recommend reading Ver's analysis because what I'm accusing Silent of is strikingly similar to what Grack is doing.

The post as a whole comes off as a soft defense of Silent, which looks bad with what happens after. Again to emphasize, he is not contributing to finding scum, but softing town reads and slight pushes for non-indicative things . One might even say it's subdued play.

Not spoilering these because they're the most important.



Pre-flip associations that accomplish nothing. It's also worth noting how he's just on board with a town Rels with essentially no doubt despite Rels just showing up.

He does backtrack on the associations in his next post, rendering this null, but still a lack of any real contribution.

With 3 minutes remaining, he finally accepts C and my argument that scum more than likely wouldn't vote how Mderg did, but he "waited too long for shennys" then apologizes to Mderg. It comes off as him being very worried of his appearance after the flip.

This dude scum. I'll check his meta tomorrow, but to be frank, I don't think it's even needed.

On August 02 2016 08:09 -Celestial- wrote:
*slow clap*

How about that mderg/Celestial/Stutters scum team guys? They're looking really twitchy and defending him really hard! *facepalm*

On August 02 2016 11:18 -Celestial- wrote:
Also in fact in every case Grack would make a change and then silent would follow that change.

Kelsier - Grack at 01:51, silent ~10 hours later
Stutters - Grack at 19:57, silent ~2 hours later
mderg - Grack at 22:30, silent an hour later

On October 06 2014 13:00 Alakaslam wrote:
NOW WE START

YOU JUMPEE GUN YOU DID

On October 06 2014 13:00 Alakaslam wrote:
Ssup mijos

I am back

I am nobody special

On August 02 2016 12:35 -Celestial- wrote:
But what? Moosy apparently spotted something on you and silent in the votes and drew attention to it and I wrote it down? What about it?


Also:


I brought up a possible shenanie target a solid 27 minutes before EoD.

I then again brought up the possibility of shenanies onto either myself or KSC thirteen minutes before EoD.

Stop trying to pretend that nobody had starting looking into it before it was too late when its easily proven to be a lie.

Nobody expressed real interest. In either. Until mderg said about it eight minutes before deadline. Both were with plenty of time for anyone to start saying "alright, I'd be up for that". I didn't start any actual movement myself because at that point I was sitting on the next-highest wagon in the hopes there was a chance to still save mderg.

On October 07 2014 02:16 Alakaslam wrote:
Hello Bamcis chef of the east side of the west.

You said I was skummi earlier with no reasons

I wants your reezinz