EPTNew Smurf Mini Mafia - Page 17
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
keanuisgod
271 Posts
| ||
|
nnn_thekushmountains
1501 Posts
On February 13 2016 03:07 keanuisgod wrote: Ehmm, yeah, can't really answer that. why not | ||
|
keanuisgod
271 Posts
But as for your question specifically (without the meta stuff), no, I don't really see it. | ||
|
nnn_thekushmountains
1501 Posts
| ||
|
nnn_thekushmountains
1501 Posts
| ||
|
nnn_thekushmountains
1501 Posts
On December 30 2015 10:26 NocturneMage wrote: Can you explain this post when you can? You are saying that you agreed with the read on GigyaS, and thus you scumread him (????) but then you are making a like to like comparison to Shapelog who you are townreading? Can you explain if this affects your townread on Shapelog or whether it should because I don't otherwise understand what you are getting at here? On January 05 2016 04:02 NocturneMage wrote: FF, I had to read his list post several times to understand and I'm not sure I understand your analysis of your last post. the way I read that day 1 was him trying to look at it f<script id="gpt-impl-0.4290662574845557" src="http://partner.googleadservices.com/gpt/pubads_impl_79.js"></script>rom two different perspectives particularly on the Irish read: (1) you have a new player not familiar with scott or TL for that matter scumreading scott under his own set of criteria and then (2) you have Fidei who knows Scott and uses his own knowledge of Scott (see null list) to read him. Furthermore Fidei uses other criteria to townread Irish. The question should be, what read/approach should make sense for Irish given his background and knowledge of the players and I can't see how Fidei's prior knowledge of Scott causing the difference in reads is a problem. Basically I'm trying to understand what wording in that range of reads is reading as "paranoid" or even trying to appease someone. The Cow interpretation - I am assuming the "weak read" comes from the ordering of the reads, so I had to read the Shapelog post again, to see if that justified a "stronger' townread from his worldview. Having gotten coached as town before I've been told that list posts don't go over well with people so I'm not sure if Fidei has an inherent bias towards that, but I could argue at least between the Shapelog and the Cow posts, the Cow should have been ranked above Shapelog, since it appears that Shapelog read is based on tone, but this is also an area of extreme subjectivity for me, I know some people on this site really rely on tone reads and especially for day 1. You might need to break it down to me line by line. Fidei could be mafia, don't get me wrong, but it wouldn't be for this. | ||
|
nnn_thekushmountains
1501 Posts
| ||
|
keanuisgod
271 Posts
If we are still on the "lt's shit on Valdi a little bit", I found it somewhat scummy that he didn't really interact much with the thread. He kind of just came to the thread, dumped all his reads and "attempts at understanding" and then just waited, ocassionally responding to someone about saita and stuff. Didn't see him engaged with the thread at all (like Bhaal was for instance). That's the same feeling I get from Warty too. For instance, Garga doesn't give me that feeling for exmaple (he felt engaged in the thread for a while), though in Garga's case I'm not sure if it gives him town points, but rather makes it NAI. I find lack of engagement with the thread pretty indicative of scum | ||
|
keanuisgod
271 Posts
| ||
|
nnn_thekushmountains
1501 Posts
This is kind of a dumbtell. It shows an unscumlike state of mind to mix people up. I think scum is more likely to pay attention to who scumreads them. It meshes with his idgaf attitude. + Show Spoiler + On February 12 2016 15:20 Wartrukk wrote: wait what I thought saitama posted the other thing oh well On February 12 2016 15:20 Wartrukk wrote: yeah it was you, saitama is the probe Here he comes in the thread pre EoD and shits on the lynch. This is kind of a weird, tooscummytobescum point, but I don't think scum would come out against the lynch like this. They would be afraid it would look like tmi when he flipped town. + Show Spoiler + On February 12 2016 07:39 Wartrukk wrote: Wow this wagon looks like trash On February 12 2016 07:41 Wartrukk wrote: Scumtama and lying LS on the same wagon on a lurker. Wowie | ||
|
nnn_thekushmountains
1501 Posts
| ||
|
keanuisgod
271 Posts
I get the feeling he's too confrontational and "in-your-face" to be scum, but based on PoE he's up there, at least considering the facts (the vote on a lurker without many other contributions regarding scum, etc) | ||
|
Mr Darcy
73 Posts
| ||
|
Mr Darcy
73 Posts
I value my reads. | ||
|
nnn_thekushmountains
1501 Posts
On February 13 2016 04:25 keanuisgod wrote: Now that you are here, what about Gargy? I get the feeling he's too confrontational and "in-your-face" to be scum, but based on PoE he's up there, at least considering the facts (the vote on a lurker without many other contributions regarding scum, etc) Yes. It is suspicious how he showed up right after bhaal mentioned him, deflected onto 77, then fucked off. But I don't see him as especially scummy actually. He had solid points against 77. Awkward opening, bad vt claim, late to the party, etc. Plus you can't really fault someone for a lurker lynch.. It's a very weak read. Hopefully garg gives us more content to judge him off of. | ||
|
nnn_thekushmountains
1501 Posts
On February 13 2016 04:27 saitamaofonepunch wrote: Lol kush who am I? You are cocky as hell so I'm gonna say SL. | ||
|
keanuisgod
271 Posts
On January 27 2016 06:46 Onegu wrote: Activity: You must post in this thread once per day/night cycle and vote every day while you are alive. If you fail to do so, you will be modkilled. If you are town better not get modkilled Valdi | ||
|
nnn_thekushmountains
1501 Posts
On February 13 2016 05:42 keanuisgod wrote: If you are town better not get modkilled Valdi once per day/night cycle, not once per day and once per night. | ||
|
Iwasrobik
190 Posts
| ||
|
nnn_thekushmountains
1501 Posts
On February 13 2016 05:48 Iwasrobik wrote: So we're in MYLO if there is no save during the game. Will read the thread now this is gonna be good | ||
| ||
![[image loading]](http://vignette3.wikia.nocookie.net/smurfsfanon/images/8/88/Panicky_Smurf_Glovey_Story.jpg/revision/latest/scale-to-width-down/200?cb=20130729184250)
