Student Mafia XVI - Page 5

On October 23 2015 03:53 GlowingBear wrote:


Failure to vote usually means you get modkilled. Wait for it

And kill Moosy anyway. He is a nuisance.

On October 18 2015 09:15 GlowingBear wrote:


You suck.

On October 18 2015 09:55 GlowingBear wrote:
Moosy, why are you looking so handsome today?

On October 18 2015 10:54 GlowingBear wrote:
(1)Farah looks townie for her posts. She is objective and her opening is straight forward to the point, asking "what is a bus" when she saw something she couldn't understand in thread. A little bit of WIFOM argument: I don't think she would ask what is it directly to the thread, but in the scum QT. As a first-timer, I would expect that she would be a little cautious before posting things in thread and be agressively scumhunting if she was scum.

The only thing that is making me wary of her is that she is not trying to see players coming through all perspectives even when I inquired her to do so. Being that aggressive and tunneled already in the beginning of the game isn't townie, and it's very rare on townie first-timers.

(2)The Shining's opening is horrendous IMO. It felt forced and tried to hard to give us the idea that he is town. The "someone be obvscum" thing isn't convincing. I don't like it. Also, these posts doesn't add up: + Show Spoiler +

If the TL meta UNFORTUNATELY have the joke phase, why participating in it? I mean, if you don't like it, why estimulate it? It doesn't make sense to me.

This post is very okay, tho:
+ Show Spoiler +

(3)MoosyDoosy is being stupid, which isn't alignment indicative for him. But this post isn't good: + Show Spoiler + ... It's just a fluffy post that doesn't make sense. I can't understand what he means with "choosing a meta". There is no "choosing", you play the way you think is better or funnier, and your meta will be a consequence of it. Why is moosy considering "not caring for the game"? Again, it's just a post where he says nothing, and I don't like it. He answered me but I don't think it was satisfying.

(4)KelsierSC can't do this as town:



Kelsier is a very logical player, saying something this bad as town isn't his fashion.

(5)Vonthin, I wasn't liking this guy too much. Especially because he said this:



(i) he opened the game by saying town should not care to survive and go scum hunting, but then (ii) he does nothing in order to scumhunt and (iii) participates in the jokes just to say this.
Reading this post in a vacuum, however, conveys town vibes it really seems he is struggling with the terrible start. I'm not sure what to think.

---

That's all I have for now.

So, basically, Farah townlean, Kelsier scumlean, others null-ish.

I'd like people to talk about things I've brought here.

On October 21 2015 06:37 FarahBlackwing wrote:
So that leaves me with a pool of six people and three of them are scum.

Gb is the next person I would eliminate from the lynch list. She has been looking for scum it seems, initially it looks like she is also trying to get me to look at alternatives when early when I was interacting about moos. Some of it I disagree with but her reaction to ff voting Scott was interesting as scum has little motivation to jump on and off if Scott is scum.

This leaves us with a lynch pool of ever, Vonthin, fecal, boxer, moos.

This is where the game gets really difficult for me.

On October 25 2015 02:42 Rels wrote:

I thought you were considering a GB + Fara scumteam ?

On October 24 2015 22:49 boxerfred wrote:
Would prefer GB since I am 100% sure to have located scum while I still have that tinfoilhatty shit with Farah. I had her so fucking locked as town and her entry to this day (the idea of "wait, everyone show that he's town") is actually a good idea IMHO. We need three fucking correct lynches in a row if it's not for a doc. Right?

On October 23 2015 18:57 boxerfred wrote:
I didn't trick anyone. The most likely scenario is that scum Shining/Vonthin want to push me because they're running out of mislynch targets. Tbh I thought that I'd be the nightkill since I feel like I'm being town read a lot in general and also have decent reads. Thing is that since I started soft-pushing farah, I get pushed a lot, even Rels now says that "maybe I tricked" him - why? Can't save myself from the night kill. I can see scum pushing me so they can safely kill of the one confirmed town player in this game which would be Rels.

On October 21 2015 19:52 boxerfred wrote:
I like Vonthin's response to my questions, I dislike that he scumreads me. He's not the lynch for today though imho.

Let me bring his scum read on me up:


I think you refer to one big, seemingly confusing post only and this is a post that is built up quite logically: I caught up, and while I was catching up, I quoted posts that I deemed interesting. I even said that on top of that post. Go have a re-read of that post.
Regarding my Moosy read: I contradicted myself in that read. I was wrong, that's about it. That's why I later said that it was bullshit. I also refrained from my Moosy scumread although it really bothers me that he's not around. So no, I have not continued pushing Moosy, you're misrepresenting the facts. However I still do not have a townread Moosy, although I liked his posts N1 a bit.
Third, regarding the "I just skimmed" case - it was simply honest, sorry if that makes me look bad. Read into that whatever you want, I don't care.

____________


I'm wondering why Farah pushes a MD lynch since her case on ES was/is good. Why the preference now that MD apparently isn't here? Also why that townread on Shining? I don't get the "emotional" argument at all, one can fake his/her meta. Elaborate please. Then again, I wonder why Farah removes GB from her "remaining scum" list. I think your reads of shining and GB are really weak.



I also dislike that Fecalfeast comes into the thread once he's under pressure. Why not do this before? Not interested to solve the game? If so, why not? I strongly think there's scum in between GB and FF, maybe MD but I don't have a solid case on that. I guess MD will break my neck the longer I survive in that game because I cannot tell if he's town or scum but I still have that scum feeling. I had the same fucking feeling in the game we played when he was scum and talked everyone into oblivion, however I was mislynched before being able to get him lynched. I actually have a good grasp on that game, SL and MD are the only ones I don't have at least a reasoned opinion on. That, among with my standing as a townread person, will probably get me shot soon. Well, some casualties cannot be prevented.

Fecal as of now I don't have the time to really look at the games you mentioned towards me. Hold me at it, I'll try to do so this evening.

The lynch should happen in between FF/GB/ES/Shining. I think those guys have the highest chance to flip scum. Second tier lynches are MD/SL(though GB scumreads him which actually makes me rethink that)/VonThin. Don't lynch: Farah. Never lynch: Rels, boxerfred.

On October 26 2015 01:44 FarahBlackwing wrote:
FF claims first but goes on glowingbear who is the person boxer has pushed all day. Boxer continues to say glowing bear is scum, but counter claims fecal saying he's the doctor.

There's no reason if you know ff is scum and your the doctor to claim in this situation with the rb still alive when your top scum read is still alive.

Its an obvious sacrifice so that the rileblocker who,is probably eversince can live block ff and kill him. I'm nit voting him because either think we kill the other scum,and hope they are the rb.

On October 26 2015 01:48 FarahBlackwing wrote:
I've played the game you haven't ever, and talking about discrediting you've done nothing but either try to pacify me or discredit me.

He's obvious scum gb, rels and fecal give me this lynch and we kill boxer tommorow. We then have to,do figure out last scum.

On October 26 2015 02:02 GlowingBear wrote:
##Unvote
##Vote: boxerfred

We lynch obvious scum today 100% of the times.

I'm sorry Farah, but there is the possibility that BF was just going to the easy win (cc'ing) instead of trying to protect the roleblocker

On October 26 2015 02:08 FarahBlackwing wrote:
He never reevaluated anything about you gb.

Well he's scum but I'll keep my vote here idc about "cred" I'm on the right lynch.

On October 26 2015 02:11 GlowingBear wrote:


No it doesn't confirm me as nothing.

The problem isn't your counter claim per se, but the scenarios you bring with it. Instead of just pushing FF, you make a team where I'm still scum. And I've been almost the only one scum reading FF the entire game.