Newbie Student Mafia XIV: Firefly - Page 170

On September 21 2015 09:55 MoosyDoosy wrote:

Look at the answer I already gave you and my expectation of your question.

At that point in the game, I was pretty hard tunneled on CopCake. Like, I even made the deal post about her and n00bKing because I was 100% sure she was Mafia. Then GB did his fake claim shenanigans and with most of my town circle giving good points on him, I accepted that he was Mafia. But I was only ~90% sure because I actually hadn't looked into him in depth because I was working on my CopCake case.

It seemed a hell of a lot better for me to push someone that no one was reconsidering into the light rather than just sheep rayn on GB mindlessly.

On September 22 2015 05:58 scott31337 wrote:
#1 - His quick push on me Day 6 - If he was town - he would take a wider view of the situation and the game of what's happening.
#2 - His reluctance for GB and voting CopCake since he knew they were both Mafia but he comes out like roses after the red check (or when if/when we finally lynch them)
#3 - His Blue hunting on N2 and not believing Rayn's fakeclaim after we lynched GB and flipped Mafia - There was no town agenda here.

On September 22 2015 06:12 Fidei86 wrote:

If it's actually MD, I feel that rayn is literally going to fly to the UK and kick me in the nuts

On September 10 2015 10:14 Fidei86 wrote:

Like, what even is this post? You've been scum reading Cake all game, and I feel like you've been softing me for a while. Then you come out after Rayn says he thinks we're both town (idk how doctor would even confirm someone when the night kill went through n1), and basically say "oh cool, I've been wrong all game, but happy to take your word for it!"

And then you include yourself in the possible scum list?!?

...

Ugh. If you're town, you're playing such a weird game, I don't even know. I thought you were too dumb to be Mafia, but you're testing that read now.

On September 10 2015 11:34 MoosyDoosy wrote:

the rest is self explanatory but since gb let it slip we have a doc, that means we also have a cop. and i was saying and agreeing with you that the cop shouldn't claim in order to have 2 more nights.

On September 10 2015 11:58 raynpelikoneet wrote:

First of all you ahev absolutely no idea what would "fit my character" or what does not.

Second, if you were town and you believed you are right here (that i am fakeclaiming), you would be happy about it and shut up, because that would result in mafia shooting me (as NOONE except you in this game believes this is the case) and the real doctor doccing me. So yeah, what you are saying here doesn't make a single bit of sense from town perspective.

Third, i have never implied i think Cake is the cop. I don't bluehunt when i am town. When a blue flips or outs i see if it makes sense or not.

On September 10 2015 10:31 scott31337 wrote:


So GB still interacts with me through the whole thread, even though he thinks I am mafia. Gb didn't interact for shit with fidei except here (if you call it that) but he tHinks he is mafia also. Hmmm

More filter reading.

On September 10 2015 11:55 MoosyDoosy wrote:

ok. i already provided reasoning early on as to why your claim would have been false which apparently also falls into your whole timeline of GB convincing me about you. like sure if you want to think that lol. it’s completely in your character to do a fake claim in order to force a lynch that you’re positive in whether you think that of yourself or not.
-shrugs-
if this was your case i’m kind of disappointed. all it provides is: “lynch these people and then do this based on the results”

i’d also like your reasoning as to why you think copcake is the cop?

On September 22 2015 06:39 scott31337 wrote:


Remember when I made this post?