EPTOn August 31 2015 01:30 Mr. Cheesecake wrote:
Palmar is scum because of his relative disinterest in the game. His contributions to the game arent what id expect from a town palmar. His push on JAT was pretty bad and his refusal to reevaluate the game after a day 1 mislynch and just call people mafia is infuriating, and shows no actual game solving attempt.
Palmar is scum because of his relative disinterest in the game. His contributions to the game arent what id expect from a town palmar. His push on JAT was pretty bad and his refusal to reevaluate the game after a day 1 mislynch and just call people mafia is infuriating, and shows no actual game solving attempt.
This is a "for the record" type of defense. I'm just informing you why you're wrong in case you're actually town.
There is no disinterest, in fact, compare this game to my last few games and I've probably shown more interest.
The push on JAT was justified. I admit I've kinda come around on JAT (I gave two reasons as early as back on day one as to why he might be town) but I still think it was an extremely weird attack to make on Trfel.
The reason I don't reevaluate is that the gamestate doesn't offer it.
Marv's claim is important in that sense.
I still think Trfel is town
I still think Marv is town (I would probably have waffled but as the single claimed bluerole in the game and having had reasons to believe he is town from earlier in the game, I am definitely just taking this)
Decon is town based on marv's check
I'm not actually pushing JAT
There are reasons to believe VE is town (his frustration when I was forcing him to go along with my reads seemed genuine).
I still believe Moosy might possibly be town based on being sort of straightforward and easy going on day 1. This is one of my weaker townreads.
This leaves:
Vivax
CC
Hopeless
Of the three, I have the least reasons to believe Hopeless is town. Vivax might very well be mafia because I would have assumed he'd have taken a passionate stance at this point in the game, but it's a meta read and I don't really trust those.
CC is just a complete null to me, I have no idea if you're mafia or town, like the sole reason I'm not sheeping marv and voting hopeless over you is I feel your push on me makes me extremely likely to be town if you're mafia, maybe I'm reading too much into it.
