EPTI'll explain it in detail later on a PC, in short I think you are saying he said things that he didn't actually say.
For example he didn't actually call rsoul mafia.
I'll give you clear thoughts in some hours after work.
Desert Center Mini Mafia - Page 51
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
ruXxar
Norway5669 Posts
I'll explain it in detail later on a PC, in short I think you are saying he said things that he didn't actually say. For example he didn't actually call rsoul mafia. I'll give you clear thoughts in some hours after work. | ||
|
raynpelikoneet
Finland43268 Posts
On August 07 2015 18:42 raynpelikoneet wrote: like the fact that he said he doesn't know what to think and then he votes for iGrok in the next sentence is pure mafia. | ||
|
ruXxar
Norway5669 Posts
Don't see how you interpreted his words that way. What I see is a person weighing two options and going with the one he liked best. | ||
|
Rels
France13467 Posts
On August 07 2015 19:29 ruXxar wrote: For example he didn't actually call rsoul mafia.. No he said she was pushing for a mislynch, which is a soft scum accusation: On August 07 2015 16:17 EdgarAllanPoE wrote: There is a breakdown in thought process here and it looks like you were just happy to jump onto a mislynch wagon. Which is why I asked him to clarify: On August 07 2015 16:28 Rels wrote: @edgar what is your read on rsoultin ? On August 07 2015 16:39 Rels wrote: Before you go: do you think rsoul is scum ? He didn't answer but he answered another question posted after. | ||
|
raynpelikoneet
Finland43268 Posts
see you guys on sunday and occasionally before lynch edgar, or yamato. | ||
|
ruXxar
Norway5669 Posts
On August 07 2015 19:44 Rels wrote: No he said she was pushing for a mislynch, which is a soft scum accusation: Which is why I asked him to clarify: He didn't answer but he answered another question posted after. I also want him to answer, but I think he is less likely to be mafia than Yamato. I really don't feel good about lynching him right now. | ||
|
KelsierSC
United Kingdom10443 Posts
| ||
|
rsoultin
Netherlands15308 Posts
On August 07 2015 16:17 EdgarAllanPoE wrote: I don't know if there is somehow a breakdown in English which you quite clearly can read but how does any of that answer my question at all? You have simply repeated questions towards me that are irrelevant since you and ruxxar are the people I was "parroting". I will make this as plain and simple as I can for you. Since my post is just a parrot of YOUR points and your town read's points, why am I your top mafia read? Apparently you think having the same reads and sheeping does not make people mafia so why is it different for me? Furthermore, why am I the top of your scum reads when all I've done is parrot you but Yamato isn't when you say he's playing exactly like his mafia meta? There is a breakdown in thought process here and it looks like you were just happy to jump onto a mislynch wagon. ... you are basically asserting two things: 1. mafia cannot use other people's reasons that they've read in the thread to make reads - do i really have to explain how this isn't true? 2. i should townread anyone who has the same opinions i do - uhhhh, no. i can be wrong. mafia can buss your line of thinking is bad. your push/argumentation in this direction is irrelevant, because you keep repeating that i should for whatever reason not be scumreading you based on these two false! assertions i did not spell it out because i generally assume (especially given the pretty, long words you've been using) that people aren't morons until proven otherwise. if you're halfway intelligent you should already get what i'm saying i do not find it townie for someone's one and only post to express that much uncertainty while blatantly sheeping not just a read but the exact reasons for a read you proceeded to do it again with your pretty "false dichotomies" bit, which focused in on rayn's questioning of igrok's reasoning the next time i have seen nothing original from you except for the assertions toward me that i highlighted above where you keep insisting that i should be townreading you and somehow miss that yamato is my second preferred lynch...you are acting like i'm townreading him lol >< which is clearly not the case i asked you the questions because you parroted ruxxar and myself and i want you to explain: 1. why the case that you said was bad is bad 2. what exactly he said was "coatchingesque" and why that makes him scum because i want to see if you actually believe these things. i want to know your thought process when you made these blanket statements to see if they're anything but just blatant plagiarism it's amazing that you don't understand what the problem is and that you keep dodging something this simple to answer. you said the words. why can't you elaborate? | ||
|
rsoultin
Netherlands15308 Posts
the only actual original thought i've seen that isn't blatantly stealing others' ideas is a horribly fallacious assertion that tina should townread anyone who agrees with her, which is a ridiculously stupid point to not only bring up but continuously push answer why you're saying what you said so i can judge whether any part of those reads were made independent of other players posting in the thread ^^ | ||
|
rsoultin
Netherlands15308 Posts
On August 07 2015 20:42 raynpelikoneet wrote: okay now i gtg. see you guys on sunday and occasionally before lynch edgar, or yamato. ye i'm still onboard with this @ruxx what exactly is good about edgar's posting? | ||
|
Alakaslam
United States17336 Posts
Since Xata's vote counter is actually pretty bamcis, find a post from the person you are voting and then format your votes exactly like that so it registers. When I am at a PC later this morning, I will go through and redo the counter with your names done correctly, and will update the front page as well. | ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
I'd sorta be ok with Scott, Yamato and maybe Edgar I'm not so sure about the last one anymore. | ||
|
rsoultin
Netherlands15308 Posts
| ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
I could see town doing this to though is the only thing. Yamato might be a better lynch or even grok who has went back to lurker land | ||
|
rsoultin
Netherlands15308 Posts
i have a hard time...how to phrase this? words like "dichotomy", "impasse", "applaud", "cite", "validate", "appease", "formulaic" i see words like this and they make me think that either he is quite intelligent but still drawing conclusions that should be obviously awful to people of the intelligence he's trying to project or he's prettying up his posts to seem more reasonable by using words like these there's a chance he's town trying to play up his intelligence by using big words, but why? what's he actually saying or pushing with it? dunnae it makes me itchy. the pieces don't match. not sure how to explain this any better @.@ | ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
| ||
|
Rels
France13467 Posts
- yamato (if he continue to AFK or if his posts are bad) - scott (if he continues to AFK or if his reasons to vote ruxx are bad) - maybe igrok (if he still lurks at EOD) - maaaaaybe cake (she would have to scumslip though) Would absolutely lynch edgar if deadline was now. Still waiting for an explanation of that: On August 07 2015 18:12 ruXxar wrote: His rebuttal to rsoul was really good. And this: On August 07 2015 05:58 Rels wrote: Are your reasons for voting ruxxar the same as before ? Hope you finish to go though "more pages" soon so you can start discussing things with people. @Damdred: would love an in depth explanation of why edgar's post are decent. | ||
|
Rels
France13467 Posts
On August 07 2015 16:43 Rels wrote: It doesn't make sense. 1 - Edgar thinks ruxxar is scummy 2 - Edgar thinks ruxxar is right though: igrok is pushing for rsoul's mislynch Edgar is voting igrok based on ruxxar's read, which is that igrok is pushing rsoultin's mislynch: He reaffirmed here that was part of the reason of his vote: 3 - Edgar thinks rsoul is happy pushing for his mislynch And now he's saying rsoultin may be mafia pushing for a mislynch: So he believes at the same time: - ruxxar is scummy - ruxxar is right, igrok is scummy for pushing rsoul's mislynch - rsoul is pushing for edgar's mislynch This guy is mafia. On August 07 2015 16:46 Rels wrote: Plus: - he's not talking to anyone except rsoul - he's not talking about anything else in the game - he answered my second question but not he first, maybe he doesn't want to say too mych that could incriminate him - another excuse to lurk and survived the day with 9 posts On August 06 2015 17:35 Rels wrote: This post is super scummy. The vote does not make sense with the reasonning. PLUS, it is the first post of EAP. And he talks about different things, as if he didn't know what to post in his first post: 1 - whining about filters 2 - reads 3 - vote igrok 4 - will no be active 5 - wary of Damdred and Kelsier Talking about different subjects in his first post is scum indicative, 'cause it means EAP had difficulties entering the thread. PLUS he does not explain why Damdred and KSC are weird. PLUS setting up to not be active in a all vanille setup. On August 07 2015 18:42 raynpelikoneet wrote: like the fact that he said he doesn't know what to think and then he votes for iGrok in the next sentence is pure mafia. | ||
|
ruXxar
Norway5669 Posts
On August 07 2015 22:41 rsoultin wrote: ye i'm still onboard with this @ruxx what exactly is good about edgar's posting? I liked his rebuttal against rsoultin because it makes sense. rsoultin shouldn't try to lynch people that agree with her opinion. If she's confident in her ability to find scum, then she shouldnt want to lynch those that agree with her because they're helping her push through her lynches. So what if it's a bus? a dead mafia is a dead mafia, bus or no bus. | ||
|
KelsierSC
United Kingdom10443 Posts
I don't think his early play is scummy, people have different styles and his is mechanical , his thing about rsol...well he isn't really the first to have issues with how rsol posts/plays. It's probably a clash of styles or ideas. I've been in his position where it just looks like she is spouting nonsense into the thread and until you get used to it it just looks nonsensical. He has been around giving thoughts and I agree with some of it. and there are better lynches Scott or Eap are good lynches | ||
| ||
