|
On August 06 2015 08:36 Damdred wrote:
Why would grok be suspect near the end but not suspect near the start for the same thing?
For example I think his reaction to RS is quite bad but you don't even talk about that cake so why does all this make him town now but scum later
I saw that CopCake answered the first part, his answer was pretty good. But unless we have strong mafia reads at the end of Day 1, I'll still want to lynch a lurker because we'll get more information on later days by watching people we think might be scummy but aren't sure about.
My reaction to Tina is pretty strong because claiming to not be in thread, and then being in the thread, is a huge scumtell for most people. You get to have activity to avoid being called a lurker, but you don't contribute much (if anything) to conversation. If you get called out for fluff (by the way, to whoever asked, "Fluff" is a post that has no significant content), you can claim that you were busy and you told the thread that you would be.
Multiple times, Tina said she was lazy and was leaving the game until tomorrow, and then continued to post fluff in thread. This is scummy, fluff is not activity, and for these reasons, Tina is my #1 lynch target at the moment.
##Vote: rsoultin
|
Actually you are wrong. Rsoultin while saying I'll just afk actually did stuff and poked at you. Which actually isn't scummy its more towny than not and you just don't know how to read RS I think.
And ff is bad, I'm easiest town read in the thread and have been on a rather nice streak nicely. So this angst towards me is a bit meh, and we both know why I expect more from you because I respect your game.
|
On August 06 2015 10:39 Damdred wrote:
Actually you are wrong. Rsoultin while saying I'll just afk actually did stuff and poked at you. Which actually isn't scummy its more towny than not and you just don't know how to read RS I think.
And ff is bad, I'm easiest town read in the thread and have been on a rather nice streak nicely. So this angst towards me is a bit meh, and we both know why I expect more from you because I respect your game.
She didn't poke at me, she called me mean a couple times, and called me scum a couple times. That's not poking, there's no pressure there.
|
Pokeing doesn't mean pressure at all, she was fishing for reactions by posting lurk lurk lurk.
Its actually more towny to say she was leaving the thread and coming back to give some form of opinion and re evaluation of ksc for instance.
|
And I gotta say your reaction is quite....interesting with the halfway case that doesn't make her scum.
and its also against your initial reasoning of lynching lurkers which rsoultin isn't In this case.
|
Rels and EAP get a pass until they post once, or 24 hours have passed. Until then, they have a pseudo-valid excuse of having not started playing yet.
Scott is the only true lurker at the moment. If Tina starts posting actual content, I'll shift onto him. Right now Tina looks very scummy, for the reasons I stated at the top of this page.
|
Well your wrong and not relooking at anything anyone posts who has played a good chunk with her anyway. Just confirmation bias at this point especially since I don't think most of it makes anyone mafia honestly.
|
Canada11355 Posts
I agree with damdred tht coming back to the thread after giving an excuse to leave the thread is more towny than scummy. However, I also agree with igrok that coming back just to post fluff is scummy.
This is not what rso did, though. She came back and talked with a number of people, while giving reads. iGrok can you elaborate on what posts from rso you refer to as fluff and, unless you're positing that all of her posts have been fluff, why those posts outweigh the rest of her posting?
|
Canada11355 Posts
I have to say, this lack of filters shit is going to seriously hinder my scumhunting ability. My entire midgame is based around filter diving people
|
igrok if you want to actually discuss things with me you may, because as it stands i'm not really seeing any reason to townread you. i'm not getting lynched because people who can actually read me are in this game ^^ fair warning
nh...i dunnae about cake. i've played with her once in forum and she was mafia there...never seen her town play. inclined to just trust rayn on her, really, i think, at least insofar as i ever trust rayn lol
ff and yama pending
|
Tommorownim going to have us makeshift filters.
I like ff posts
|
|
|
Canada11355 Posts
If I had rfreshed a little earlier I would have been. About to close up shop and take my mom out for her birthday dinner
|
confirmed town:
scott31337
rsoultin
just town:
FecalFeast
Damdred
KelsierSC
idk:
everyone else
mafia:
RuXxar
|
On August 06 2015 11:07 Fecalfeast wrote:
I agree with damdred tht coming back to the thread after giving an excuse to leave the thread is more towny than scummy.
In fact it's not. If it was mafia would always do that.
|
On August 06 2015 15:52 raynpelikoneet wrote:
confirmed town:
scott31337
rsoultin
just town:
FecalFeast
Damdred
KelsierSC
idk:
everyone else
mafia:
RuXxar
Why is Scott confirmed town?
Why is Igrok not on your town list?
|
Because of dick move analysis.
Because someone saying something townie does not automatically make them town. Especially when it has nothing to do with reads.
|
Mm, coppy not responding too well to pressure IMO, but still feel it's kinda towny.
|
On August 06 2015 08:49 Damdred wrote:
I've talked about it a bit before but, the first hint was his disagreeing with rayns opinion on ruxx and pushing his own.
I have absolutely no idea where you get this.
|
Don't understand Igroks case against rs, it was really bad IMO.
Still think he's most scum so far, but this game is hard.
##vote igrok
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
