|
On August 05 2015 14:23 rsoultin wrote:
well...yeah it's kinda convenient for palmar to suddenly agree and lynch bf, but what would have happened if he didn't?
he wasn't getting lynched over bf at the time, so only
1. mislynch bf and look better for not being on another mislynch
2. mislynch someone else
i fail to see how his read change benefited him as scum?
I proved he wasn't caring for the lynch and he immediately had to do something.
He suddenly read things and thought boxerfred was Mafia
If he didn't do anything he could've been lynched, maybe.
I will counter-question: why does a town let a lynch on someone he thinks is 100% Mafia go on and rant on it in the next day? Why does a town keeps pushing a lynch on someone (you) and does NOT try to lynch you when he can, but instead he decides to read the game ON DEADLINE and completely flip his read?
|
If I am alive with rsoul in lylo I will lynch her 100%. Until then we have another lynch and she isnt the lynch tomorrow. Obi/palmar is most likely... Will look into them if I had a filter but I dont....
|
On August 05 2015 15:57 Onegu wrote:
If I am alive with rsoul in lylo I will lynch her 100%. Until then we have another lynch and she isnt the lynch tomorrow. Obi/palmar is most likely... Will look into them if I had a filter but I dont....
 you won't be alive
|
|
|
6 players, 1 scum
no
eh, i'm not gonna defend palmar. he's capable of defending himself. if he really was rereading the game which he seems to have been, though, then that's not an instantaneous thing, gb. at the very least he'd have to skim for that quote from ows -shrugs-
like, you say it's a reaction test and he suddenly felt the need to do something...what stops him from just lynching me if he's scum? why is mislynching bf better for him than mislynching me? i don't really get it
|
can the framer frame mafia green?
|
|
|
framer was dead d1
only way scott is scum is if he's gf or cop goofed bad
too many townreads though @.@ i'm missing something
|
of course, my bad.
also scott is like 99% town.
I'm sorely tempted to just drop whatever scumread I may have on you rsoultin because if you are mafia you deserve to win with all this work you're putting in.
|
On August 05 2015 15:57 Onegu wrote:
If I am alive with rsoul in lylo I will lynch her 100%. Until then we have another lynch and she isnt the lynch tomorrow. Obi/palmar is most likely... Will look into them if I had a filter but I dont....
What about scott?
|
I don't really think scott is as town as you're saying he is Palmar.
Your read seems kinda reachy.
|
ye, i'm prob not gonna get through a reread before EoN which is why i asked the question on scott?
99%...that has to be more than just the cop check then? can you explain your read to me, palmar?
and that doesn't really help the who is scum problem -_-
also...just saying, kinda one of the most active scum players on the site...pretty sure that isn't a great way to read me lol ><
kinda got a wild theory but i can't test it yet :/
|
On August 05 2015 14:23 rsoultin wrote:
well...yeah it's kinda convenient for palmar to suddenly agree and lynch bf, but what would have happened if he didn't?
he wasn't getting lynched over bf at the time, so only
1. mislynch bf and look better for not being on another mislynch
2. mislynch someone else
i fail to see how his read change benefited him as scum?
I still don't really understand how this matters?
Like, what was his alternative? Bf was getting lynched.
|
On August 05 2015 22:01 ObiWanShinobi wrote:
I don't really think scott is as town as you're saying he is Palmar.
Your read seems kinda reachy.
1) alternative wagon to 2 scum on day 1 (me and rsoul wanted to kill clarity, rayn and a few others wanted to kill FT).
2) Reacted like he had nailed GB. He looked like he genuinely believed my check
3) checked green by a cop.
Yeah no, he should be the last person lynched this game.
I wish we had filters because I'm much more motivated to go back and read GB again. While GB's attitude feels more likely to come from town, he has an exceptionally awful reads record this game. He has basically been tunneling me since day 2 while still agreeing to lynch other people a bunch in the meantime. He wanted to kill scott on day 1 too I think. I can't remember which side of the day 2 wagon he was on.
|
On August 05 2015 22:04 ObiWanShinobi wrote:Show nested quote +On August 05 2015 14:23 rsoultin wrote:
well...yeah it's kinda convenient for palmar to suddenly agree and lynch bf, but what would have happened if he didn't?
he wasn't getting lynched over bf at the time, so only
1. mislynch bf and look better for not being on another mislynch
2. mislynch someone else
i fail to see how his read change benefited him as scum? I still don't really understand how this matters? Like, what was his alternative? Bf was getting lynched.
Not conform and call everyone bad (hint, that's what mafia palmar would have done. I had already established a platform where I thought Bf was town, and if I had been mafia I'd have known I was right on that).
|
@OWS
I don't think I'm good enough as mafia to react in different ways to the same thing.
When townies wanted to lynch snickers I was a stubborn asshole. When townies wanted to lynch boxerfred I conformed with the hivemind.
If I am mafia I already have perfect information so I'd have figured that one of the two strategies (sheeping town OR being right and calling people bad) is the better one, so it's more likely I'd have used the same strategy twice. Unless I'm smart enough to plan to use this exact line of reasoning to argue I am not mafia... I don't know if I'm that smart though. Maybe I am?
|
any side not him...he was the counterwagon to the d2 wagon
yeah, obi. bf was getting lynched
he could be right and not vote bf or
wrong and vote bf
what's the incentive for scum to vote bf there? i'm not saying it clears him. i'm just saying i don't see what's so scummy about it. there's no perceptible benefit from changing his read there
while theoretically he could have kept up his "i'm awesome y'all are wrong lynch rsoul" bit interminably
|
Tbf I am awesome. I just sometimes doubt myself and become less awesome as the game goes on. The longer I live in a mafia game the shittier a player do I become.
|
I'm going to do a first post analysis because I'm bored and I have no filters.
|
Oh shit, the good thing about not having filters is that the mods have to manually count posts to know if we're above the limit!
WE'RE FREE NOW BOYS, TIME TO SHITPOST
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
