Mini Mafia Down Under 3 - Page 4

On July 29 2015 03:09 KelsierSC wrote:
I think I gave 3 good reasons why palmar is likely town this game

Plus the fake red check and follow up to it with rsol felt town. I feel pretty strongly he is town

@GB I noticed the first few points you raised but you have ignored other points that make palmar town. Plus point 4 palmar comes up with reasons to scum read rsol and then you say he has no original reasons to scum read people? That point 5 seems really stupid to me.

On July 29 2015 06:54 KelsierSC wrote:
Clarity would have been a fine lynch yesterday and is a good lynch today

"forming quickly" is stupid

On July 29 2015 08:26 KelsierSC wrote:


I was responding to GB's comment that clarity can't be scum because the "wagon" formed too quickly. Clarity did play scummy rsoul, myself and others gave reasons why he had been scummy. then he didn't post anything. So it wouldn't have been a bad lynch and the fact it formed quickly is irrelevant to his alignment.

On July 28 2015 23:43 Palmar wrote:
The AWOLs and why we shouldn't lynch them.

Clarity and Onegu

Unfortunately we have two people not participating in the game. Both of those players are prime vigilante targets.

But the most important part is that there is no reason to actively really believe that either of them is mafia. We have no flipped blue roles so there's no real reason to doubt that Onegu is named townie, and while I wanted to lynch clarity yesterday for not contributing, his post tonight and the fact that HTS is looking for a replacement for this game probably means he's telling the truth that he can't play. It's a bit shitty I guess to talk about it, but it's the next thread to this one...

If time constraints stop him from contributing, that fully explains my main gripe with him, which was that clarity is a good player who is not trying to solve the game. Solving the game is much harder when you don't have time to solve the game.

So yeah, unless someone can bring up a real reason why one of the two is mafia, we're basically taking the easy way out by lynching them. If they happen to be town it'll be an idle lynch on a lurker, and I generally don't like those after day 1.

Like I'm not kidding about clarity, the reason I wanted to lynch him was I had just played with him in voice mafia where he was insightful, talkative and very committed to winning as a townie, and then there's literally nothing this game. But this is 100% explained by simply being absent this game.

It sucks, and if he's mafia I'm basically giving him a lurker pass for nothing, but I don't want to lynch him today.

Check/Shoot. Use the lynch on someone who might at least respond.

On July 29 2015 08:27 Snickers wrote:
its prty weird how palmar has so many posts to use as "references"

its also weird just how he goes about presenting them

On July 29 2015 21:34 KelsierSC wrote:
We should consolidate

Anyone who voted ft is off the table
I don't want to lynch rsol at all I think she's town.

So hopeless,GB or Bf are your choices,
I think Bf is town though.
Hopeless has done absolutely nothing and his play is uninspiring. Fits scum profile.
Le go

On July 30 2015 04:29 boxerfred wrote:
that's bullshit obi

go lynch gb

On July 30 2015 04:44 rsoultin wrote:
47/80

lol at least prof cancelled lab

wth are you people running around like chickens with your heads cut off? we have over 2 hours left before the lynch

order of business:
- hopeless claimed cop. if you are the real cop and you're not ccing him, you are wrong
- scott could be gf but statistically the chances are higher he's town assuming hope isn't cc'd. off the table in a 2 hr crunch
- slam needs to hard claim jailer/banisher if he is one. he's getting shot tonight if he's town and doesn't claim it anyway, and it removes the ridiculous ambiguity snickers started in the first place

i am not lynching gb
i'm not scum

if slam doesn't hard claim, i'm sorely tempted to lynch him, but will consider leaving it another day for him to get caught up

we need to discuss the lynch, be organized, and consolidate

i'm thinking bf but it's more poe than anything. what does everyone got?

On July 30 2015 05:20 Snickers wrote:
If slam is the jailer and gb flips scum definitely jail Rsoul if a jailed mafia can't carry out a kill.