Like if we're lynching people for doing dumb shit we would have to lynch half the town, so I don't know if we should use that as a parameter. I'm really struggling with some posts to try to determine if they're from mafia or just lazy/apathetic/bad townies.

Also I'm tempted to lynch scott for this:

On July 26 2015 07:13 scott31337 wrote:
Scotty's shitty spreadsheet at the moment -

1 KelsierSC null - questioned me on the VT claim, but it felt weird how he did it.
2 FirmTofu null/scumlean - little posting, nothing sticks out.
3 Onegu named town no CC, going after rsolutin for being angry too early, but she doesn't seem that angry (scummy angry) YET.
4 Snickers others like him but I don't see why? (notably Clarity, rsoul) Calls me mafia - suspicious
5 raynpelikoneet Started off good but has faided, slight town lean
6 Clarity_nl null / slight scum? Wants to lynch me
7 boxerfred Nothing special, six posts of meh - scumlean
8 ObiWanShinobi Didn't see scum motivation from his post to me - little posting - null
9 rsoultin Slight townlean, not too angry - keep an eye to see if she does the magic trick if not just lynch D4.
10 GlowingBear second part d1 looking better, not too angry either - asking townie questions - townlean
11 Palmar townlean for a Palmar d1 day.
12 scott31337 town
13 Hopeless1der scumlean, first post was bad - but suspicious/scummy voters on him so need to watch for that.

He claims to be using a spreadsheet to help him determine people's alignments, but some of the stuff here is just complete fucking bullshit and 100% made up. Like I don't believe anyone who keeps a spreadsheet would do it in this way. Also check this out, detective Palmar is on the case:

Things that bother me about the format of this thing:

I would have removed the numbers in front of the names (these are exactly from the playerlist)
There is no progression in the reads. This was all clearly written in a single sitting as evidenced by Glowingbear's commentary about his second part d1 looking better.

However on the other hand this is clearly copy pasted from a spreadsheet so if he is lying about using a spreadsheet he at least opened up google docs or something and pasted this in.

meeeeeeeehhhhhh~~~~

Maybe I should give him a pass based on that?

Don't know, it actually feels like I should.

It's so bad though...

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

July 26 2015 09:38 GMT

#456

On July 26 2015 18:31 Snickers wrote:
if people would like to tell me why boxer isnt mafia and give actual reasoning that would be really nice.

I think he might be, there was a serious tone thing in one of his posts. But I haven't played with him before, maybe he's just timid in general.

Gonna have to re-read

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

July 26 2015 19:08 GMT

#515

On July 26 2015 21:38 rsoultin wrote:

and tofu's push on palmar was horrible. it's not a bad lynch. it could be a wrong lynch. i'm hoping palmar can articulate why he doesn't want to pull the trigger on it

Everything you say is essentially correct and the bolded basically answers your own question. I feel there is a very real possibility he is just a baddie.

Although maybe I should worry less about that and just lynch him for saying stuff that makes no sense.

Im also heavily considering lynching clarity

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

July 26 2015 19:17 GMT

#522

This kelsier case is actually good

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

July 26 2015 19:20 GMT

#525

I think we lynch one of clarity kelsier and scott.

I would love to lynch ft for being awful... But it feels like a revenge lynch to me

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

July 26 2015 19:23 GMT

#527

Yeah for now im gonna vote clarity

I need to run but will be back before the deadline

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

July 26 2015 19:30 GMT

#540

On July 27 2015 04:24 ObiWanShinobi wrote:

Show nested quote +

Why?
I feel like I've asked like 3459863498 times but nobody has answered me.

Because he's not trying to solve the game or really helping much at all

And unlike FT I know he's not awful.

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

July 26 2015 19:31 GMT

#543

Btw after some more consideration I will only vote kelsier or clarity today

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

July 26 2015 19:33 GMT

#547

On July 27 2015 04:26 raynpelikoneet wrote:
goddamn Palmar. At least comment on what i said about FT?!?!?

why is noone i expect to play is playing?

Without going back and re -reading I think everything you said was both essentially correct and could alternatively be explained by FT being a dumbass

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

July 26 2015 19:48 GMT

#570

On July 27 2015 04:46 raynpelikoneet wrote:
So you're shit at reading Palmar but i am wrong on him?

If you think it's possible I'm mafia when I'm tryharding like this as town you're also shit at reading me

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

July 26 2015 20:32 GMT

#624

Mehh I don't really care.

Logically I shouldn't fight FT's lynch. If he is even a remotely viable human being he is definitely mafia because his entire storyline regarding me is trash and bullshit.

I'm just not sure he is a viable human being.

So whatever. I think clarity has a better chance of flipping scum and my vote stays there, but I'm not gonna defend FT when the only defense to be made for him is "he barely counts as a sentient life-form".

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

July 26 2015 20:33 GMT

#626

On July 27 2015 05:32 FirmTofu wrote:

Show nested quote +

Wait why?

You're not, snickers is bad.

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

July 26 2015 20:37 GMT

#630

On July 27 2015 05:35 GlowingBear wrote:
Palmar, lynch Scott
Or, if you want to do the correct thing, lynch keksier

I'd much rather lynch kelsier than scott.

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

July 26 2015 20:44 GMT

#637

On July 27 2015 05:43 KelsierSC wrote:
This game makes me sad

lynch me if you want

You're not helping yourself.

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

July 26 2015 20:48 GMT

#639

List post, because I feel like it:

Probably town:

GB
Snickers

Maybe town:

rayn
Onegu
Hopeless
scott
rsoultin

meh:

Obi
Firmtofu

maybe scum:

kelsier
boxerfred
clarity

Disclaimer: I always, always, always miss like 1 mafia who I think is town for some shitty reason.