Mafia in the Himalayas - Page 61

On June 18 2015 07:03 Holyflare wrote:


no since hts said if he doesn't confirm that other guy on the replacement list will replace in his slot

so bill murray confirmed and then replaced

so bill murray confirmed received his role pm and quit

so bill murray was probably mafia

On June 18 2015 07:20 ritoky wrote:


could be a breast pocket too, shouldn't assume things son.

i don't have a particularly clear mafia today if i am being honest. i am probably going to be more prone to sheep one of my town reads unless i find something solid i like.

i think the most anti-town players are LS and bugs; but they could both be town cuz of stupid claiming and effort respectively.

On June 18 2015 07:22 Holyflare wrote:


so despite you using the read of "when hf and rsoultin bicker one of them is mafia" you don't remember any of the talks between myself and rsoultin and can't make any judgement then using generic meta reads on people like your onegu "can't claim vt any more" and the bickering thing and defending bf as being new without reading any of his posts and trying to shut down an argument you now believe mig put forward??????

if you remember me going after boxer why the hell did you say mig said the stuff which made you read boxer when i've been writing that all day, you'd think you'd want to read someone you've been scum reading right?

On June 18 2015 07:31 LightningStrike wrote:

Because I was lazy about reading filters because the thread was much more interesting ans only read filters when prompted by others. Will look at your filter when I get back from Pokemon/Smash to judge you on content only.

On June 18 2015 07:30 GlowingBear wrote:


Why bugs is but rsoultin isn't?

On June 18 2015 07:09 Damdred wrote:
I actually think Fiede is mafia here guys and is a really good vote today.

If you look at his filter and compare it to HG which just finished a lot of the things he talks about in that game are really fluid and confrontational at parts trying to figure out the truth on players or get his view points into the thread. Also when he doesn't like what players are doing he is going to get into their face.

Look at what hes doing here, hes really not trying to rock the boat overall. He is trying to pocket/buddy up to people and is being noncommittal and not really following much up at this point or talking about anything worth while.

I'm pretty sure this guy is mafia.

On June 18 2015 07:30 Damdred wrote:
...whatever

Threads not fun to read at all and I was really looking forward to this game.

I'll probably just sheep Ritoky or HF when the time comes. Any questions for me just ask

On June 18 2015 07:30 Holyflare wrote:
gb you gonna do anything?

On June 18 2015 07:30 Holyflare wrote:
gb you gonna do anything?

On June 18 2015 07:38 Fidei86 wrote:
@Damdred This is not really an excuse, but I want to talk a bit about how I've played this game so far. HG in total went for 120 pages, all the way to the end. A couple of people were generally inactive over the first couple of days, so the post count was manageable. Towards EOD2 I actually did a complete re-read of the entire game, which was only something like 60 pages (and therefore totally do-able). This time, we've made it to that in a single day. This is only my second game of forum mafia ever and I just am not quite sure what to do with this much content. I can't get a read on anyone because everyone already has six or seven pages of filter and everyone has also just been BMing each other, or making single-line posts which make no sense when you read them as part of a filter. Plus most of the players here are people who weren't in HG, so I have no idea what to look for in them. Right now, I'm just hoping that things settle down a little so I can start to get a grip on everything. If you look back over my filter in HG, I think you'll see that I spent the first day literally deer in headlights. I feel that way again, except even more so. That is how I feel right now. I admit, I'm really not much of an asset to the town because I don't have any strong reads at all. I have read every single page of the forum, on my phone and at work, but it's just moving too quickly for me.

In terms of people who were in HG, I think it's fairly well established that NHM has either undergone a character transplant in the last 24 hours, or has rolled town this game. The difference is night and day. Ritoky looks like the same as he was before - he mostly posted commentary on other people's posts last time, and it got more substantive towards the end of D1. IE, I don't think he has done much that is alignment-indicative yet, but the next day or so will be helpful. You seem similar to last game as well, but I don't give that too much credit because I hated how you played on D1 and D2 and D3 (obviously D4 you rocked pretty hard). That's not a pocket - I'm not giving you a town read, you're just clearly an experienced player and meta reads probably won't take me too far with you ("I shit on my meta", etc). But going straight into this game after the last one is quite a big thing - I'd just got used to reading you based on a certain set of interactions, and now I have to throw them all away.

The reason for posting all this is that I'm acutely self-conscious at how I've played so far. I really want to contribute. I've got an hour or so this evening and I'm going to try and re-read some stuff and give some reads or at least post some useful thoughts. But please don't scum read me for genuinely being over-awed.

On June 18 2015 07:37 ritoky wrote:
yo HF, gimme yo read on me? you still fencing me cuz of mind melds?