Newbie Student Mafia XI - Page 5

MoosyDoosy

United States4519 Posts

June 13 2015 20:33 GMT

#810

On June 14 2015 05:32 batsnacks wrote:
Bat Traps™ mafia traps. The highest quality traps for your scum hunting needs.

We'll see how right we are after Sulfurus, Rels, and getrip.

MoosyDoosy

United States4519 Posts

June 13 2015 20:47 GMT

#821

batsnacks I understand your trap. ^.^ Just saying we'll see how right it is after we get him. If me, you, and WaveofShadow are right about getrip and Trfel is right about Rels, that's two of the Mafias.

MoosyDoosy

United States4519 Posts

June 13 2015 20:53 GMT

#825

On June 14 2015 05:51 n00bKing wrote:
The last couple of hours are such a disappointment. Had 6 votes on one player and 5 on another. Now there are 4 different players with at least 3 votes on them, none of which have more than a 1-vote lead on any other. Who wants to post a trainwreck pic?

Do you seriously not think geript is Mafia at this point?

MoosyDoosy

United States4519 Posts

June 13 2015 21:02 GMT

#836

I think the better thing to discuss in terms of roles now that we're all voting for geript is finding who the doctors should save for night time.

MoosyDoosy

United States4519 Posts

June 13 2015 21:04 GMT

#838

On June 14 2015 06:03 Trfel wrote:

Show nested quote +

We should definitely not talk about this.

Let the blue roles decide how to use their abilities. Talking about it openly only gives scum more information, which can be extremely valuable.

Oh true, didn't think about that. What about the cop tho? Shouldn't we talk about who he should investigate during night time?

MoosyDoosy

United States4519 Posts

June 13 2015 21:09 GMT

#842

On June 14 2015 06:06 n00bKing wrote:

Show nested quote +

On June 14 2015 05:38 batsnacks wrote:
Here is geript saying he will sheep Trfel's amazing case on Rels:
+ Show Spoiler +

On June 14 2015 04:54 geript wrote:
Actually, I think I'm going to sheep too.

Here is sulfurus's bold post defending Rels:
+ Show Spoiler +

On June 14 2015 05:00 Sulfurus wrote:
I didn't want to say anything about trfel before because his vote on Bats was protecting me but he is just straight up wrong on Rels. He makes a post here where he says rels made a bad town read on ruXxar even though (IMO) ruXx is one of the towniest players in the game.

He also keeps saying that Rels is tunneled on Plant's only post and he basically dismisses the rest of his filter when in fact it's really good and shows a town who is focused on trying to solve the game.

Here is me saying sulfurus's post is bold, I ask why mafia would post such a thing:
+ Show Spoiler +

On June 14 2015 05:04 batsnacks wrote:

Show nested quote +

This is bold. Why does mafia post this?

Here geript explains that sometimes mafia like to defend town poorly. geript knows that Rels is town, yet he would sheep Trfel's case on Rels:
+ Show Spoiler +

On June 14 2015 05:08 geript wrote:

Show nested quote +

It's not uncommon for mafia to defend town badly. Especially newer mafia.

How is any of that supposed to be difficult to explain? Geript has at times thought Sulfurus looked scummy. And he has at times thought Rels looked scummy. Most recently, his vote has been on Rels, so that is presumably his top scum read.

You ask geript why Sulfurus would defend Rels if Sulfurus were scum. geript at this point participates in a discussion that PRE-ASSUMES Sulfurus is scum. And he hypothesizes that Sulfurus could be defending a Town player poorly. This would require him to be wrong about Rels being scum. I see nothing wrong with geript acknowledging the possibility that he could be wrong about Rels being scum, and answering a hypothetical question about why Sulfurus would act as he has if HE were scum.

This is almost as hollow as the reasoning Trfel used against Rels. Not quite as hollow. But almost.

That's a lot of assumptions about what geript is thinking which he can only explain. His initial reaction afterwards leads us to believe it was a slip on his part and that the above wasn't what he was thinking. He said it was one of his dumbest posts ever which leads us to believe that he did still think that Rels + Sulfurus was scum at that moment and he contradicted himself there. So getrip kinda just killed your argument there by himself.

MoosyDoosy

United States4519 Posts

June 13 2015 21:10 GMT

#845

On June 14 2015 06:10 geript wrote:
Hey batsnacks. Since you're so concerned with teaching noobs, I'll teach you something you should've learned by now. "Scumslips" that are caught never are.

Lynch Rels or Sulf next

That was the plan. Which one would you prefer?

MoosyDoosy

United States4519 Posts

June 13 2015 21:15 GMT

#853

On June 14 2015 06:13 geript wrote:
Oh and BTW. Vigilante. Shoot Batsnacks tonight. You'll realize why once I flip. In the least, you should to it to raise the overall intelligence level.

Like I'm literally done playing mafia here. It's fucking stupid. Every time I role mafia, people have no clue how to read me and I wreck face. Every time I role town the stupids think something I've said actually makes me mafia. It gets more fucking ridiculous each and every time.

Maybe because you put more effort into it when you're Mafia? I don't now, from the start it seemed you had a idgaf attitude which just got progressively worse where you contributed little or nothing and then to this contradiction. If you actually were a townie (which I highly doubt btw) I would recommend you actually put effort into finding the Mafia.

MoosyDoosy

United States4519 Posts

June 13 2015 21:20 GMT

#856

On June 14 2015 06:16 ruXxar wrote:

Show nested quote +

If you are town with a role you should claim it now if you want to make a defense.

Even if he is a townie, it shows he wasn't a role with this post. He clearly wasn't vigilante and I doubt that he was doctor.

MoosyDoosy

United States4519 Posts

June 13 2015 21:21 GMT

#857

eh, geript is letting things slip more and more.

MoosyDoosy

United States4519 Posts

June 13 2015 21:38 GMT

#862

Wait, guys I'm actually confused. getrip was voting for Sulf but switched to Rels once Trfel made his post. It seems he was suspecting both at some point. It's unfortunate that they're both the most suspicious people as well and our strongest cases for Mafia. I am so confused.

MoosyDoosy

United States4519 Posts

June 13 2015 22:57 GMT

#874

On June 14 2015 07:37 Damdred wrote:
Also day post is at 18:06 for,me and it's 18:36 now Sooo it's right just sucks.

Anyway, who do you think is town/scum

Lol, I don't think anything is certain after this. getrip was fine with suspecting both Sulfurus and Rels when necessary and he even voted for both at some point. Not only that, but both Sulfurus AND Rels were two of our top suspects as Mafia. I can't shake off the feeling that getrip just really screwed up by accident and we were jumping on it for no reason.

Either way, I think that everyone should look over everything again.

MoosyDoosy

United States4519 Posts

June 13 2015 23:15 GMT

#878

On June 14 2015 08:11 n00bKing wrote:

Show nested quote +

Kinda going pretty far out of your way to ignore the fact that geript said the Vigilante should KILL BATSNACKS tonight, aren't you?

I don't see that post and mine have any relation?

MoosyDoosy

United States4519 Posts

June 13 2015 23:50 GMT

#885

Oh damn, my bad. Did not see that the ID of the player was revealed when they were lynched. Lol, I'm blind af.

Disregard all I said folks. That means we should still go back to the drawing board but I think either Sulfurus / Rels is Mafia.

MoosyDoosy

United States4519 Posts

June 14 2015 00:05 GMT

#887

^ I actually like this post. Good thoughts n00bKing.

MoosyDoosy

United States4519 Posts

June 14 2015 00:10 GMT

#891

On June 14 2015 09:09 n00bKing wrote:
The point of all this is that Moosy's post is bad. Even he has now asked everyone to please disregard it. Hopefully other people will get it, even if WaveofShadow does not.

If you re-read my post with the mindset that we didn't know what geript was then you would understand why I made it. I honestly did not see that line until your post which said that geript was a townie. That made me look back and I finally saw it. -.- Again, my bad.

MoosyDoosy

United States4519 Posts

June 14 2015 00:15 GMT

#894

On June 14 2015 09:13 WaveofShadow wrote:

Show nested quote +

Wait you didn't realize Geript flipped?
Moosy I absolutely love you. You're the cutest.

+ Show Spoiler +

(If you are scum I will hate you for all eternity)

yeh, sorry to pull the newb card again and for not reading properly. I feel like a fool. :\

+ Show Spoiler +

bb, don't worry you'll love me

MoosyDoosy

United States4519 Posts

June 14 2015 00:16 GMT

#895

On June 14 2015 09:14 Oatsmaster wrote:
Let's get moosy tmr

Let me guess. I fell for n00bKing's trap -> revealed I'm Mafia -> fact I'm agreeing with n00bking afterwards is desperate attempt to cover it up -> continuously pulling newb card -> lynch him?

MoosyDoosy

United States4519 Posts

June 14 2015 00:19 GMT

#897

On June 14 2015 09:16 MoosyDoosy wrote:

Show nested quote +

Let me guess. I fell for n00bKing's trap -> revealed I'm Mafia -> fact I'm agreeing with n00bking afterwards is desperate attempt to cover it up -> continuously pulling newb card -> lynch him?

^ Actually what I just wrote against myself sounds pretty convincing. Wouldn't even be mad if people voted against me. If you guys want, I can defend myself tho.