|
I don't even know what the fuck the Onegu rule is. The reason is to try and get something out of him, he's turning into the player with the least amount of posts while not posting anything that has value to it. And The Shining posting about Foot with out even reading the thread when Foot accidentally posted under his main and just started to reply to the most recent postings.
Bats, vote all you want for me, but if you're saying you may know who priest is, then why the fuck did you switch vote to me?
All in all Shining is looking more scummy to me, bats vote against me looks scummy as fuck and Onegu's play here isn't scummy yet, but it could be a different route than what he played his last game with me as scum.
|
On June 12 2015 02:27 FreezingFoot wrote: ##Vote: Shockey
Just cause I was scum last game doesn't mean I'm scum this game, don't help us lose, help us win.
|
On June 12 2015 03:17 FreezingFoot wrote:Show nested quote +On June 11 2015 21:59 ShoCkeyy wrote:Wait till tomorrow, let's see what happens. If you're right on the priest that would mean that there would be a 9/1 ratio by D3. On June 11 2015 11:28 yamato77 wrote: Is there a plan for this, Shockey? Yes. On June 11 2015 12:04 FreezingFoot wrote:
Can you tell me what are your reads right now and why you want to lynch someone completely out of discussion? You just answered your own question. @Bugs, you're saying that the above post, for instance, is definetely coming from a townie, and I fail to see why. If you could enlighten me with your supreme knowledge, I'd be pleased
On June 12 2015 03:13 FreezingFoot wrote:Show nested quote +On June 12 2015 02:45 ShoCkeyy wrote:On June 12 2015 02:27 FreezingFoot wrote: ##Vote: Shockey Just cause I was scum last game doesn't mean I'm scum this game, don't help us lose, help us win. Dude, you asked me questions without actually having any follow up to them, and when I ask you questions you simply say I answered myself when I answered NOTHING. Your apathy added to your initial two posts in the game fits a careless mafia perspective that does not care for the game when not up to for the lynch. Your play in that game we played together was completely different from here. Nonetheless, you're presenting another classical scum behaviour without any signs of town traits (at least for me) here.
Because you don't read the thread.
On June 12 2015 00:50 ShoCkeyy wrote: I don't even know what the fuck the Onegu rule is. The reason is to try and get something out of him, he's turning into the player with the least amount of posts while not posting anything that has value to it. And The Shining posting about Foot with out even reading the thread when Foot accidentally posted under his main and just started to reply to the most recent postings.
Bats, vote all you want for me, but if you're saying you may know who priest is, then why the fuck did you switch vote to me?
All in all Shining is looking more scummy to me, bats vote against me looks scummy as fuck and Onegu's play here isn't scummy yet, but it could be a different route than what he played his last game with me as scum.
Now Onegu, your first read list didn't say anything about me:
On June 08 2015 22:50 Onegu wrote: Going through all filters and giving my reads on them
List Post:
Shockeyy: No Posts LS: Dont really like he is commenting on things but not giving actual reads on those things. Shining: No Posts Stutters: Meh 1 post wanting a blue role. Yamato: 2 posts one troll post and one meh post. Know he is working. FF: Most likely town. Liked his defense and refusal to claim identity. His/her posts are chok full of info. Unless I know who they are and if that person is a very capable scum player will keep my town read on them. TS: 2 posts. The second one is kinda meh to me. Not really sure why he thinks tunneling is a scum tell. BM: really wierd turn around on WBG. Says he isnt tunneling then votes him for no reason dropping his read on bats for 0 reasons. Bats: look fairly townie making reads and stuff brsheke: Looks fine also. His early sheep onto FF looked kinda wierd but his later reasons were fine. WBG: Most active, not sure if I have played with him before or not but seems townie. Didnt really agree with his smurf thing but meh. KS: Also very active. Liked his layed backness at the start. Has orginal reads. Would town read again.
Now I want you to update your read on me.
On June 11 2015 23:47 Onegu wrote: Would lynch Shockyy for Onegu Rule
Now, I seriously don't know if this really means something, but seriously is there really a Onegu Rule? lol...
|
On June 12 2015 03:51 wherebugsgo wrote:Show nested quote +On June 09 2015 01:49 ShoCkeyy wrote:On June 09 2015 01:49 ShoCkeyy wrote:On June 09 2015 01:22 LightningStrike wrote:On June 09 2015 00:25 ShoCkeyy wrote: ##vote wherebugsgo
Bugs posts in the beginning are trollish, but who knows just following the hype train from reading the thread atm. Anymore thoughts outside of Bugs opening? I've only gone through the opening, but Kickstart's and Breshke posts seem legit, Onegu is hiding to not get sniped first day. I'll sheep BM just cause I want to atm. It's the first day, hard to tell anything about anybody. Especially when there is other people who have yet to really post. Then there is the smurf, but he's been active so w.e I liked Kickstarts opening, very part of the game, he went ahead and started with some roleplay basically saying he's town which is why I quickly can say he's town (obviously it's still the beginning, the posting can get worse) and he went ahead and started questioning bugs cause of this: On June 08 2015 08:15 wherebugsgo wrote: anyway I am kinda sad I didn't roll scum this game but you guys should elevate me to Greater Demon status cause that'll be baller
also if you guys could fill me in on who I should expect to suck this game and when I should be disappointed for someone sucking that would be great It's an opening post, but it's just so ugly for it being one of the first opening posts. Breshke - You can just tell he's playing a townie, then why all the questions that force others to really give their opinions of other players? On June 09 2015 14:57 Breshke wrote:On June 09 2015 14:53 FreezingFoot wrote: Onegu is much more a coin flip than anything. He should definetely not be lynched today. I think LS is the same. He always is this passive regardless of alignment why is shockey not a coin flip as well then? Is he not new? I'm not new to these forums. I've definitely have played Mafia here before, but it's been a long time since then, so in a way I am new once again and I change my play style every game no matter what role. Then what's the point of continually playing when others have such a great read on you? This is why I started playing again, brings enjoyment. Onegu: He brings points, then leaves - hiding to not really get sniped. BM: I've played games with him before, always town. So I just rather sheep some one with more knowledge atm. This was my opening post, now I've explained myself about it because most of you instantly think scum if I don't. This post is w.e from LS: + Show Spoiler +I don't like it, why do you link so many previous games to make sure people know how you play as a townie or mafia? And the fact that Bugs asked you makes it strange. Especially when he can just dig around himself, theres a database thread with ctrl + f. On June 09 2015 15:20 FreezingFoot wrote:On June 09 2015 15:06 Breshke wrote: Actually foot never mind that's a shit question. Would be nice if shockey would come back to the thread Ok And Shockey, when you come back to the thread, I ask you catch up and tell who we should lynch I'm still going to stick to bugs, he's obviously angry about being called out so early into the game that he decides to leave instead, what kind of town motive is that? The google spreadsheet? It's ok, points as BM mafia because he's on an all out against bugs and LS even though they never had another interaction again after the game list above. If the train decides to lynch a lurker (stutters), I doubt he would pull so much attention to himself if he was mafia by just not posting. yo why the fuck has this post been edited
Early mistake in the game, I normally don't post much since I've been back in the Mafia forums and hit edit instead of quote (touchpad), I had immediately PM'd hosts about it and let them know I changed it by accident, but it still contains the original quote and post in there.
|
1) Onegu - I'm 50/50 about him, but I really just want him to post more. His last game he posted a ton compared to what I see now and with a lot better value in the small worded posts - what irks me the mosts is that he makes one list post early in the game and that's it, everyone looks away lol... 2) The Shining - The way shining's posting says town a little bit, but his votes feel like they say another thing. He's a coinflip. 3) Yamato77 - Hard to say even with all that posting. 4) FreezingFoot - Either he's mafia or just some what slow in reading the thread. 5) Tubesock - I like these posts from him, paints him town for me + Show Spoiler +On June 11 2015 12:47 Tubesock wrote:Final Vote Tally Day 1. Show nested quote +On June 10 2015 08:00 Blazinghand wrote:Day 1 Vote Count LightningStrike (8): wherebugsgo, Yamato77, Onegu, ShoCkeyy, Kickstart, The Shining, Breshke, batsnacks Bill Murray (1): FreezingFootStutters695 (3): Tubesock, Bill Murray , LightningStrikeNot voted (1): Stutters695 Currently, LightningStrike is set to be lynched! Day 1 ends in at 23:00 GMT (+00:00).With 13 alive it takes 7 to lynch. Remember to vote in thread, and cast withcraft votes via PM
Failure to vote in either category will result in a modkill. This is the world you think we live in. That Bill Murray and I are the most likely scum. That LightningStrike was our partner and we not only defend him but vote the same guy at the end. I get that I'm too stupid and bad to see that I should blend in and just vote LS, but uh you think Bill Murray is going to bounce around like that at the end and NOT cash in on town cred? That he would not have already decided to bus LightningStrike till 30 minutes before hand? The same LightningStrike that has a really hard time posting as mafia on D2+? Really? Bill Murray. The same Bill Murray who is famous for his bans. That one. That guy doesn't seem like a dude who would have any trouble being forceful if he was mafia. It is laughable that you think he would be hesitant. But I am the stupid convoluted one that sucks. Uh huh. You think that FreezingFoot would choose Bill Murray over LightningStrike in this case? Sure it's possible to have 2 mafia up for lynch. I mean Wherebugsgo is fucking baller baddass then clearly top town player on this sight if he caught not just 1 but 2 mafia on D1. On June 11 2015 16:19 Tubesock wrote:Show nested quote +On June 11 2015 16:07 yamato77 wrote: Tubesock why are you convinced Bill is town when literally everyone else thinks he's mafia? I like Bill because of his commentary on Bugs. I don't think scum Bill Murray would act like he did all of D1. I think he would have been far more decisive and forceful as scum during the second half of the day. I don't think that he would jump off Lightningstrike if he was a teammate onto stutters like he did. I don't think Bill Murray would not have a plan on how he would conduct himself as mafia. You really think this world exists? Stutters695 (3): Tubesock, Bill Murray , LightningStrikeThat mafia Bill Murray would do that in an effort to save LightningStrike? Is the blue kp really that important to have all three mafia on one target?
6) Bill Murray - Possibly mafia, his posting has started to go down hill, as mentioned I sheeped him in the beginning due to playing other games with him. 7) batsnacks - We'll find out with his "priest" posting, if it ever shows up, he can possibly be scum with onegu?? 8) Breshke - His posts come off as town to me 9) Wherebugsgo - I seriously sense you're town, my opening posts against you were just to start the game as others also do.
Bill Murray (3): Yamato77, The Shining, Onegu
One of these players are scum in my opinion, including BM - Yamato's case against LS was way after Bugs case, I feel like he could of easily added his thoughts to look town since scum knew LS was going to be gone D1.
|
On June 12 2015 04:28 yamato77 wrote: Lol you get 0 points for not calling me town
That's the most scum post I've seen in a long time
Yea, or are you just going to get on the "Let's lynch shockeyy train" because I labeled you as possible scum?
|
Sorry for the confusion, was looking at the wrong mother fucking vote post when I wrote that bit on yamato for his read and ending (I think he's town). Now I still definitely think Tubesock is town, but BM just looked scummier as we went on.
Stutters695 (3): Tubesock, Bill Murray , LightningStrike
One of these three have to be scum and I definitely think it can be BM, but I'm willing to lynch either Shining or BM depending on what will be posted in the future.
|
Well, if it's like that, I'll just bounce. I have a lot of business I should be dealing with, but I thought this would entertain me in some way outside of business. I can't really provide the effort and time that most of you put into this. Sorry if my reads are "worthless", but they're my honest opinions on people after reading through the thread. Remember, I'm playing from a town point of view, any of you can be mafia to me still. I rather have many coinflips than many town players and end up getting fucked.
|
LS.
Anyways, I'll check back tomorrow.
|
D1 votes: Kickstart, Bugs & BM
|
##unvote ##vote Bill Murray
|
I voted as asked. I'm not scum.
|
Hmm, I would like one of them lunches, what did you bring?
Also, yea, don't fuck around with these lynches - I seriously think it's Onegu or Foots.
|
This would be a flawless vic and 2 - 0 for me since I've returned!
|
Yea, definitely will, too much has changed since my games years ago. I remember clues used to also be part of the day/night posts in regards to who was mafia (you were forced to add info into your profile to create clues, don't know if this still happens?).
|
I voted bugs and breshke.
|
I voted Kickstart day 1 for witchcraft.
Also, it's funny how the person who wrote the mafia guide was some one I played with consistently in the beginning ;p
|
See like right now is perfect for me to play, no gf at home, all my business is taken care of and I actually have time to post. Activity is what really kills me and my posting ;\
|
Hmmm 2-0... I'm probably going to obs the following games I join. But I had decent reads on people. I know what meta is, but how can you really tell, especially so early in the game? My scum and town are pretty similar (but that's also because I work a lot).
Anyways GG guys.
|
|
|
|