Generic Boring Mini Mafia - Page 8

On May 18 2015 07:40 sciberbia wrote:
##vote Zealos

Best read for mafia so far. He does a ton of filter-diving on Damdred to make it look like he's hardcore contributing, but he's super wishy-washy in his conclusions. Just look at the amount of hedging his bets here:






Like why even post all your research if you are this unsure in your conclusions? Looks like a good candidate for someone who is trying to look like they are contributing but isn't.

On May 18 2015 07:25 Vivax wrote:
Well I read my role PM now so I'm sure I can post this:



This is a question that looks like it's coming from scum Obi.

On May 18 2015 07:41 sciberbia wrote:

lol yes I object. What do you think of my post?

On May 18 2015 07:40 sciberbia wrote:
##vote Zealos

Best read for mafia so far. He does a ton of filter-diving on Damdred to make it look like he's hardcore contributing, but he's super wishy-washy in his conclusions. Just look at the amount of hedging his bets here:






Like why even post all your research if you are this unsure in your conclusions? Looks like a good candidate for someone who is trying to look like they are contributing but isn't.

On May 18 2015 07:33 sciberbia wrote:
@Damdred
I agree with Vivax that Palmar could still be scum. What if he is scum and he's just calling you scum to make it look like he's doing something? He may not necessarily be hoping to get you lynched.

On May 18 2015 07:53 Damdred wrote:
Because i'm only answering things haphazardly and in such a huge game I miss things from skimming.

Theres not really an objective answer at this time, could Palmar be mafia? Objectively yes, could he be doing this as scum? Quite possible.

Just a gut reaction/read with some other things that I feel *shrug*

On May 18 2015 07:45 Vivax wrote:


I see nothing scummy in not being completely confident into your conclusions, cause that's what it sounds like. Not that "wishy washy" buzzword you just used.

As I see it he actually tried to deepen analysis on Damdred but doesn't feel too strongly about his conclusions. That's townie.

You're starting to worry me scib. But let's let this play out for a bit.

On May 18 2015 08:06 sciberbia wrote:

That's interesting because I was expecting you to scumread him with me. As I'm sure you'd agree, there's a difference between being wishy-washy and posting unsure conclusions. If he had concluded, "I have found some small reasons to suspect that Damdred is scum", then I would have been more-or-less fine with his post.

What is wishy-washy is saying something and then immediately retracting it or modifying your previous statement to make it less forceful.
"I'd lean slighty mafia BUT I'm not convinced honestly."
"Having said that, he has been forced on the defensive."

This sort of posting is typical of scum who want to look like they are saying something of substance, yet either fear retaliation from a town Damdred, fear looking bad if/when Damdred flips town, or are trying to delicately play a bussing situation.

On May 18 2015 07:46 Zealos wrote:
It can only help town to have all the information in front of them, hiding it until I'm sure is at best a gloryhunting strategy, and at worst, damaging to towns chances of winning

On May 18 2015 08:05 Damdred wrote:
I'm not sure how i'm lacking motivation lol?

On May 18 2015 08:12 Vivax wrote:
Okay, I'll move him back to null cause you made me unsure.