On April 28 2015 08:48 sicklucker wrote:
Guys are we really just gonna nominate hf so they can kill are best town and are fight promoter in one go? Theres no way one of are better towns should be the fight promoter.

I nominate yamato. Hes a sensible person who will listen to Hfs orders and if he does not we simply kill him.

Mafia can not kill him without revealing vote info and if he is mafia who cares if he does not make the fight who we want we hang him to a tree

Like I really don't ever see a scum Sl posting this when he seems to be worried about establishing his innocence which he has also done this game but this is a gem. This is really insightful especially if he actually didn't understand HF's role.

sicklucker

Canada16987 Posts

April 28 2015 01:19 GMT

#1968

No shit im town

sicklucker

Canada16987 Posts

April 28 2015 01:20 GMT

#1969

Like plz put scum on me I might be murdered im scared

Holyflare

United Kingdom30775 Posts

April 28 2015 01:21 GMT

#1970

Lol bit late to the party there

Breshke

Australia3749 Posts

April 28 2015 01:22 GMT

#1971

better late than never

Breshke

Australia3749 Posts

April 28 2015 01:27 GMT

#1972

HF I still think it isn't the right idea to vote you for fight promoter.

For one scum might want to kill you anyway for how hard you campaigned for sandrobas lynch so giving them extra incentive even thought it results in one of their deaths seems wrong as they just get more benefit for actually putting kp on you.

Secondly if they weren't planning on killing you but you being the fight promoter would make them want to would it not then be better to give the fight promoter to someone like yamato or another townread maybe one you are less sure of as we can just get them to pick the fight you want and we don't give scum the extra incentive to kill you

Holyflare

United Kingdom30775 Posts

April 28 2015 01:29 GMT

#1973

Uhhhh so you're saying you'd rather 2 random people take crap all damage in a day fight rather than just trading me for a mafia or two.
No thanks.

Breshke

Australia3749 Posts

April 28 2015 01:31 GMT

#1974

I think if you're town mafia are probably considering night killing you weather or not you are promoter. I'm fine with having you as promoter I just think we can get more out of it if you weren't

Fecalfeast

Canada11355 Posts

April 28 2015 01:32 GMT

#1975

On April 28 2015 10:27 Breshke wrote:
HF I still think it isn't the right idea to vote you for fight promoter.

For one scum might want to kill you anyway for how hard you campaigned for sandrobas lynch so giving them extra incentive even thought it results in one of their deaths seems wrong as they just get more benefit for actually putting kp on you.

Secondly if they weren't planning on killing you but you being the fight promoter would make them want to would it not then be better to give the fight promoter to someone like yamato or another townread maybe one you are less sure of as we can just get them to pick the fight you want and we don't give scum the extra incentive to kill you

Uh, how does losing yamato, who hasn't claimed to be a hazard for scum, benefit us? If they kill yamato as the fight promoter we still lose the fight don't we? I don't understand the idea here. If HF is lying scum still has to take the gamble and shoot...

Do we actually even know how the scum KP works?

Holyflare

United Kingdom30775 Posts

April 28 2015 01:32 GMT

#1976

Not adverse to forcing yamato to do something i guess?

Holyflare

United Kingdom30775 Posts

April 28 2015 01:33 GMT

#1977

Ff if yamato flips we get a lot of info about the wagons, is the theory at least

Fecalfeast

Canada11355 Posts

April 28 2015 01:34 GMT

#1978

IDK maybe I'm not looking at this from all possible angles but isn't taking the chance on a pgo always a dumb idea? If mafia has ANY investigative roles wouldn't they just use it on HF instead?

I think that HF is actually the best bet for promoter regardless of the validity of his pgo claim. Any gamble/indecision scum has to go through is good. I guess they could also have some kind of RB as well....

Give me a second I need to work this out

LightningStrike

United States14277 Posts

April 28 2015 01:35 GMT

#1979

Okay guys I back and saw people saying to vote HF when he's most likely a NK and now he claims Paranoid Gun Owner who is pretty much a Veteran on SC2 Mafia and Town of Salem also I agree to have Vivax as one of the fighters as the way he tried to persuade others to go on Yamato when scum!sandroba was being the other wagon might actually makes him scum and he not doing conspiracy theories either.

Breshke

Australia3749 Posts

April 28 2015 01:35 GMT

#1980

On April 28 2015 10:32 Fecalfeast wrote:

Show nested quote +

Yamato was probably a bad example since he is msot likely town. I should have thought of someone before suggesting this but the diea was give it to one of the townier question marks and then if they are killed we still lose the fight but we remove a question mark. I see it as kind of directing scums night kills?

Also i kinnda assumed scum kp would just be outright not based on HP since lynches are outright kills. Could be wrong