Aperture Mafia 4: This Time it's Personal - Page 6

On April 08 2015 00:38 Half the Sky wrote:
Basically my opinion is at this point is if for some reason either of Bats/Crossfire are alive at daybreak and somehow the game isn't over by that point, whichever of them are alive should be auto-lynched.

On April 08 2015 08:51 justanothertownie wrote:

Depends. In this game they made the game unwinnable for town (losing in the process) but had they worked WITH town instead then scum would have had a hard time.
If slam works with town we do not lose a lynch, we get rid of VA (probably) etc.
If Holyflare works with town we get rid of BH 100 %
Both would win and be removed from the game so there wouldn't be so many question marks left. Everyone is happy. Except for mafia.

On April 08 2015 09:03 justanothertownie wrote:

Did he know you were a medic? Because he told me that he expected to be shot and had I been a medic I would have saved him. But I only had this shitty warrior bodyguard power.

On April 08 2015 09:03 gonzaw wrote:
Xfire, why did you derail the D4 lynch by openly siding with anti-town 3P, pushing the lynch OFF confirmed scum and ON to a somewhat likely townie?
Well, other than "I thought she was very likely scum and town would instantly lose by not lynching her"

On April 08 2015 09:15 Holyflare wrote:
Kitaman don't even talk to me about flaming. It was lylo and I gave you free mafia and was literally the only player in the game trying to analyse anything only for a bunch of afk tits to say lololol let's lynch hf. I pleaded about 500 times for people to stop and actually talk about my analysis and instead you didn't.

It's also ridiculous for me to claim day 1 when there's a sherlock a watson a lestrade and i have no idea what any of their win cons or powers are.

On April 08 2015 08:51 GreYMisT wrote:
My next game with either be a PYP/PTP (GreYMisT style) or another game that me and a few others have in the works

On April 08 2015 11:34 Onegu wrote:
JAT you told me to trust OwS so he was the only one I shared everything with . Also I tried to play town leader last night I kept everything as close to the vest as I could except with Obi, while getting as much info as I could from everyone else. I started to trust HtS toward the end but couldn't PM directed OwS to bus me and sepulchre.

On April 08 2015 12:07 gonzaw wrote:
I think people may have relied too much on "confirmations" using roles/PMs/etc.

Obi was basically assumed confirmed town because of a town check from someone
BH was basically assumed town the last phases because of some PM thing with Onegu (that I still don't understand)
HTS was basically assumed mafia for a while because of some weird night action stuff with Damdred and kita or whatever.

Just ignore all that shit, specially in a Greymist game. I mean, obviously dwell on that stuff and have all the fun you can get with 5th party House Chezinu and sleeper cell and self-redirecting magic-bus-driver and whatever. But for lynching and figuring out alignments....yeah, leave it out.

On April 08 2015 10:59 Crossfire99 wrote:
Sorry guys

I played pretty terribly. Definitely felt pretty lost most of the game and even when I thought I was sure I was wrong LOL. Probably shouldn't have signed up. I didn't have enough time to play to my standards especially with the amount of posts this game. Probably won't play mafia again at least while the spam is this high. It's just not my thing and I don't like playing with that many posts. I also didn't like pms, but I never played with them so it was something different to try.

As for why I did what I did during the last day. I really thought town was in a 4-5-2 situation and that VA was 3rd party and really had to kill bats. I figured town had to take a risk and not lynch bats because if not they would lose due to the amount of KP. I actually thought HtS was mafia and was super sure of that. Obviously, I was wrong. And it was pretty much only hubris that caused me to stick with HtS over Sep who I also agreed was mafia. That was dumb.

Even playing terribly, I still had fun. Thanks for hosting GreY! I know it is difficult work and you do a great job!

Random fact: During day 3 I death framed VA to get a list of the actions performed on him, so we could figure out once and for all whether or not he was scum. I thought I would get the results immediately, but I misunderstood and would only get results if he was targeted by scum which never happened, so it ended up being for naught. GG everybody.

On April 08 2015 12:59 Onegu wrote:
Kita going to observe bats. VA going to shoot kita. BH checks speculre. Snarfs medic save you.Crossfire says he only has passives. Me mask to you lightning rod item on bats forcing VA to shoot bats. Then what you decide to do. I told HtS to do her thing on BH but guessing she is scum so. Speculre hasn't responded. I'm missing someone I think...

Original Message From ObiWanShinobi:
So what is everyone claiming as their night action? Is that finalized?

Show nested quote +

On April 08 2015 18:23 marvellosity wrote:

why do you have to be confident? I was a really obvious shot, even without knowing who i was.