Aperture Mafia 4: This Time it's Personal - Page 22

On April 01 2015 06:06 batsnacks wrote:
*everyone goes and PMs exo instead of taking it to the thread and actually getting a good lynch going*

On April 01 2015 06:28 Keirathi wrote:
Oh hey look I was right. Hapa wasn't mafia after all.

Yay for people ignoring me!

On April 01 2015 06:43 Keirathi wrote:
Also, FWIW the only way I see BH being mafia in this game is if both Lestrad and Moriarty are mafia. And I'm not really sure that I think they both even CAN be mafia. It would be strange for the mafia team to have 2 separate role-check'esque abilities.

Well, I guess there's the possibility that there's a third FACTION, rather than just a solo 3p.

But yea, town Moriarty and scum Lestrad in this situation, as claimed, doesn't make any sense.

On April 01 2015 06:48 Keirathi wrote:

I'm not sure.

I just got home, give me a while to go through the thread and collect my thoughts again. I did a lot of ruling people out last night, but not a lot of actually narrowing down my suspects.

On April 01 2015 06:51 Holyflare wrote:


nahhh day 1 before he even posted anything

On April 01 2015 07:11 Keirathi wrote:

Also, it comes to me that for someone who is being extremely town-circle'y and town-leader'y, I have absolutely no idea who YOU want to lynch.

That's kind of scary.

On April 01 2015 07:17 Keirathi wrote:

That's weak.

I mean, I get that I'm not being included in the town circle jerk for whatever reason. But this is still a game of mafia and we still have to lynch scum.

On April 01 2015 08:03 Blazinghand wrote:
it seems probable someone, probably scum, used a power to end the day after 24 rather than 48 hours.

I'd like to note that if everyone just blindly followed my lead we'd have lynched VA right now

On April 01 2015 08:05 Keirathi wrote:

He feels pretty town.

My only small reservation is that during the night, he said something like "I read Chezitwo's and VA's filters, and at least one of them is probably scum." But then after Chez flipped town and people started saying that VA was probably redchecked, he didn't want to lynch VA.

On April 01 2015 08:04 rsoultin wrote:
meh -_-

btw if anyone pms me i can't respond

...how did we end up on night 3? i know that's a weird thing to ask but...no night 2 :/

nvm i doubt asking is going to get me anywhere lol ><

On April 01 2015 08:17 rsoultin wrote:


dunnae

just can't :/ some ability or item or other probably but yeah i dunnae

On April 01 2015 08:44 Keirathi wrote:

I could almost believe this scenario, except it's just so....convenient?

Like, the Moriarty (who is probably mafia because why the fuck hasn't he claimed to anyone yet) just happened to check Crossfire (of all people...not one of the people who mafia will actually NK anytime soon), who happens to have an ability that confirms his role to the thread when he revives?

Meh. Confusing.

On April 01 2015 08:49 batsnacks wrote:


He said his ability is to fake his own death. That implies, to me, that he wasn't actually targeted by KP.

Unless you know something.

On April 01 2015 08:51 Keirathi wrote:

To find out if said person has a way to stop the kill from going through?

I dunno, maybe that's no optimal and you could check lesser priority people to see if they had powerful roles that might be more beneficial to kill than the high-priority townies, but I think as scum I would probably rather make sure my kill on the high-priorities could go through than check someone who's just on the sidelines.

Also, things like role-assassin, while I dont remember ever being used in a GreYMisT game, are possible. In that kind of scenario, the mafia role-cop would probably check a higher priority person so the assassin can shoot them.

On April 01 2015 08:55 Keirathi wrote:

I don't remember because YOU KILLED ME NIGHT 1 /sadface

I know there was a mafia role-assassin in Boardwalk Empire, but that was PYP. It's definitely not an unheard of role on TL.

On April 01 2015 08:56 Crossfire99 wrote:

As I said in my big post most people talked in pms so I couldn't read that obviously. For what it is worth, everyone including yourself who posted in thread about me seemed to take it at face value and I could discern no extra knowledge coloring your reads.