Newbie Student Mafia VI

On March 02 2015 14:08 Eden1892 wrote:

I'm judging the Kelskynegu slot on all 3 players' efforts put together. I'd probably give the bulk of the analysis to Kelsier for pretty obvious reasons, but I'm secretly hoping Onegu will spew glorious townie vibes so I can call the slot town and coast

I don't know what I think about what you said about Probulous's case on FF because I didn't read Probulous's case on FF enough to remember it well enough to evaluate your comment about it. (I remember it happening so I must have read it, but I definitely didn't pay any attention to it.) I will however go back and read it and assess your comments from there. If you're saying his case didn't have to come from town, I'm open to him being mafia, so I'm predisposed to agree

Not really any change in read on Tormented. Confession, I was kinda hoping I would die and y'all would figure him out instead. I can't tell if his paranoia about me is genuine or not; if he weren't a newer player I would think it's manufactured, because I think I should be pretty obviously town by now, but he's attacking basically all the lines of argument I would expect from a paranoid newer townie ("you never live to d3 and yet here you are" comes to mind in particular).

If I had to change that list I would flip Fecalfeast and sicklucker's spots on it. Actually...

sicklucker, were you roleblocked last night?

On March 04 2015 17:58 Fecalfeast wrote:

I'm excited.

On March 05 2015 09:19 sicklucker wrote:
Also by poe I only like see two people it can be and this is by far the better case. Just concede?

On March 05 2015 19:18 yamato77 wrote:
well onegu

if you're mafia I would just concede

##Vote: Onegu

On February 26 2015 09:23 The Shining wrote:
See, thank you, Kels. This is the 2nd game in a row I've been resigned and detached for whatever reasons. Last game, not 1 but 2 D2 replacements almost took me out of the game. This time, its my late start.

Want to see my help? Let's help, then. I want to see final vote, too, and I'll get through some more filters before I leave work tonight

On February 27 2015 08:10 The Shining wrote:
Actually I take back what I said about the inactivity/lurking thing regarding SL. He's the odd one out.

Node AFKs without explanation. Want to see why
Artanis posted about being lazy once, havent seen him after. Could really just be lazy or waiting for day.
SL continues to post nothings showing he's here but...doing...nothing lol.

On February 27 2015 09:44 The Shining wrote:
Ugh yuck I'm never a fan of these things. Thist post isn't to say I don't believe Artanis could be scum, as I can see it and I've had suspicions myself, but guys. Unless its super early pressure, the last thing we should be doing right now is setting an auto lynch at the beginning of Day Phase. If you sure he's scum, let him prove it or prove who he isn't over the next 48 hours.

Tormented's instavote right after Eden looks like a way to cruise D2 on auto pilot btw

On February 27 2015 11:06 The Shining wrote:
Light or dark beer? Cheers mate.

Its not hard to figure me out at all. I'll even do it for you. As scum, I'm a lurker and like to sheep as easily and quickly as possible. As town, I have a slow game due to my hatred for D1 and not having learned my way around it. It picks up after voting analysis(which I learned from Damdred ironically) and after players start being inconsistent or not contributive. This is why I am willing to vote Artanis. I just won't do so right away, especially with 3 votes already on him. It won't be me but I'm interested in seeing who, if anyone, will defend him.

I do like those points on Artanis, though meta isn't one of my biggest strengths. As a newbie, have to ask, how do I verify that he was in fact not mislynched in any of those games? In my newbie games here, diving 1 or 2 old games was easy but how do you find all of those?

And welp, there is the possibility Node afks D2 as well and gets modkilled. I only mind that if he flips town.

On February 28 2015 05:38 The Shining wrote:
Tronak, I felt that way last night. It can be frustrating being the only one in the thread at times.

I should clarify that I have had my fair share of weak cases, as well. Weak cases are not alignment indicative. However, the way you seemed to not want to commit to it is what worries me. A townie can have a weak case and gut feeling and still commit to it.

And meh. I am a passionate player. I would be more worried if I was emotionally detached. It is my play style, not sure what to do with that.

And I meant you have no vote up on me. I like that you're sticking with your scumread in Artanis, at least, but I wanted to see his defense before I made a final call on him. I've already said I'm leaning more towards Yamato than Artanis. But your response about Artanis does nothing to disprove my thought that your case on me is a soft push to see if my wagon could gain traction. You don't have to nevessarily vote me right away to get me mislynched if enough people believe your case.

And since when does thinking someone is scummy but wanting to see their defense because too many people jumping in the wagon doesnt feel right and not voting = jumping on the wagon?

And you just told a guy who started late and had to read a ton of pages to catch up(that were pretty spammy, mind you) to not spam. I'll post what I want. I referred to a past game because I'm a newbie and like I said, ppl here have hardons for meta. It was a town game for me. And it isn't really League of Legends spam if it is also the same post that explains why I'm leaving thread and unable to answer questions immediately afterwards.

Last thing. I should have updated my list post that I was asked for, even though I don't like list posts? To change one read on SL to town? Why? It's clearly in my filter that I did so.

On March 01 2015 07:17 The Shining wrote:
OK, Tronak. The haste with which you switched your vote was just odd to me and the tone with which you just defended yourself seems...well, overly defensive. Did me telling you to read the thread that one time get to you that much? I mean, I did say in my last post that you were sheeping Prob onto FF. But you said you wouldn't move off of Artanis unless he showed he was town. You moved off of him so I needed to see if you thought Artanis was town or not. You moving off the wagon you claim to have started because he hasn't offered us anything to a guy who is here and doing something before EoD doesn't line up. And it might just be wording but "easily" being willing to switch off of your main wagon to another just doesn't fit the tone you've had regarding Artanis.

That being said, I really am thinking we should give Artanis a chance here. There are quite a few players who had much more content and posts D1 as opposed to now. Artanis, yamato, Snarfs, Kelsier are names that come to mind as driving forces D1 and almost non existent D2.

And if that is alignment indicative, I'm really bad at this game because there are four names there.

On March 06 2015 19:14 Fecalfeast wrote:
ok onegu and why does the shining vote the roleblocker D3? Can you give me an analysis of his D3 specifically?

On March 05 2015 12:07 Onegu wrote:



Who is the other? Better be shining

On March 05 2015 12:07 Onegu wrote:



Who is the other? Better be shining

On March 05 2015 12:07 Onegu wrote:



Who is the other? Better be shining

On March 05 2015 12:07 Onegu wrote:



Who is the other? Better be shining