VII Titanic Mini Mafia: I Have a Cunning Plan... - Page 63

On February 16 2015 10:58 rsoultin wrote:


I can definitely see a difference, just as I can see a difference between your play this game and your town play from Horn. (Granted, I think you're trying to be less spammy, but it's like night and day.) What I don't understand is why you CCd immediately if you're actually the JK. If you know that you know that you know that BH is lying because you're the JK, then why not reserve that so that you can still use your abilities later? It's not a good play as town and I'm struggling to understand why you would do it now ><

Like, if it were me, I'd target him as JK and see if that effected the night kills, lol.

On February 16 2015 11:04 liancourt wrote:
tp's the goon so it'd be pointless jking him. Why would the RB/jan/GF CC, that is absurd

On February 16 2015 11:04 liancourt wrote:
tp's the goon so it'd be pointless jking him. Why would the RB/jan/GF CC, that is absurd

On February 16 2015 11:06 Town Puppy wrote:

Do you actually believe what you're saying? I'm contemplating posting my role PM and blacklisting you forever. You are intolerably bad.

On February 16 2015 11:04 Town Puppy wrote:
Tbh rob you're probs mafia bc you should know I never claim here as scum. So idk why I'm even answering you. Hijole

On February 16 2015 11:13 Blazinghand wrote:
I've been paying attention to TP's play.

To an extent, I've been trying ot understand his claim. Why would he do that? It makes almost as little sense as me claiming JK as scum would. For me to claim and get put on the block like this as scum would be an error since I'm a skilled player and probably MVP of any scumteam I'm on. TP isn't as good so it might be more worth it, especially in a trade for me, but... why not just shoot me, as he said? No, the more I think about it, the more I realize that TP would have to be even more not-on-my-level to claim as he did.

But then I realized: TP is so obviously below my level, there's no way he's scum. His scum-team-mates wouldn't let him do this, and he wouldn't even try. A 1-for-1 would only count in a situation that's not where he would get lynched first (and that's where things are going; I'm a much better arguer than him). He and his scummates would KNOW that he's not on my level. They wouldn't try this.

The only explanation that makes sense is that... we must have 2 JKs. It's stupid and our hosts are awful for doing this, but even TP and his scummates must be aware how weak TP is comapred to me in terms of knowledge, skill, and convincing power. As a sacrificial lamb he's not cut out for this strat.

We're both town. We're both JKs. By admitting this, I am basically conceding that I'm going to get lynched, since I won't push him further and will unvote him. I won't succeed in convincing the 2 JK setup, because the only explanaiton for doulble JK is that the HOSTS aren't on my level. They don't know how to balance.

By stopping pushing TP, I am probably letting myself die.

But when I die and flip JK, don't lynch TP. He's also a JK.

When I flip, don't lynch him.

Liancourt knows we're both town. How? Well, he must be scum, and trying to profit after the 2nd one of us flips JK.

Liancourt is the scum. He knows too much. His knowledge doesn't make sense.

After I die, DO NOT lynch TP. lynch Liancourt.

TP is a JK.

Sigh.

##unvote
##vote Liancourt

Palmar, where are you?

On February 16 2015 11:13 Blazinghand wrote:
I've been paying attention to TP's play.

To an extent, I've been trying ot understand his claim. Why would he do that? It makes almost as little sense as me claiming JK as scum would. For me to claim and get put on the block like this as scum would be an error since I'm a skilled player and probably MVP of any scumteam I'm on. TP isn't as good so it might be more worth it, especially in a trade for me, but... why not just shoot me, as he said? No, the more I think about it, the more I realize that TP would have to be even more not-on-my-level to claim as he did.

But then I realized: TP is so obviously below my level, there's no way he's scum. His scum-team-mates wouldn't let him do this, and he wouldn't even try. A 1-for-1 would only count in a situation that's not where he would get lynched first (and that's where things are going; I'm a much better arguer than him). He and his scummates would KNOW that he's not on my level. They wouldn't try this.

The only explanation that makes sense is that... we must have 2 JKs. It's stupid and our hosts are awful for doing this, but even TP and his scummates must be aware how weak TP is comapred to me in terms of knowledge, skill, and convincing power. As a sacrificial lamb he's not cut out for this strat.

We're both town. We're both JKs. By admitting this, I am basically conceding that I'm going to get lynched, since I won't push him further and will unvote him. I won't succeed in convincing the 2 JK setup, because the only explanaiton for doulble JK is that the HOSTS aren't on my level. They don't know how to balance.

By stopping pushing TP, I am probably letting myself die.

But when I die and flip JK, don't lynch TP. He's also a JK.

When I flip, don't lynch him.

Liancourt knows we're both town. How? Well, he must be scum, and trying to profit after the 2nd one of us flips JK.

Liancourt is the scum. He knows too much. His knowledge doesn't make sense.

After I die, DO NOT lynch TP. lynch Liancourt.

TP is a JK.

Sigh.

##unvote
##vote Liancourt

Palmar, where are you?

On February 16 2015 11:21 liancourt wrote:
you know BH if you didn't make that post i would have continued to fight your battles. That post just looked desperate.

Desperate scum.

##unvote
##vote BH

On February 16 2015 11:18 liancourt wrote:
I like to play devil's advocate.

When everyone says yes, there has to be that 1 person that says no and analyze everything in favor of it being no. It's a coin flip really. Total wifom. I can uderstand tp claiming and yet i don't understand why he would put himself to his death. 1 for 1 is good for town? Why not survive and use your superior analysis and help town in later days and lynch scum. You know BH is scum them you can see who he is defending and see who he is pushing and who he is out right ignoring. When you die later town will automatically know BH is scum so why CC? You could have been more useful being alive and having that JK power and your power of analysis, why would you give all that up and just die n1? i really just don't understand.