Horn of Africa Mini Mafia - Page 55

On February 05 2015 07:20 justanothertownie wrote:

It's a legitimate question. He is your only scumread now for some reason.

On February 05 2015 07:20 Eden1892 wrote:

what is your point

On February 05 2015 07:01 Holyflare wrote:


man i was so on point like an hour into this game

rs has just been really really reactive and not digging enough from what i've seen in her town game so i'm happy with these 2 being mafia for now

On February 05 2015 07:22 justanothertownie wrote:

Well, from defending someone to that someone being your strongest scumread is quite the jump.

On February 05 2015 07:25 Eden1892 wrote:

there are 2 possible points to this question that I can see:

(1) you think I'm wrong about Damdred and are questioning me so that I'll post my thought process and you can convince me I'm wrong about Damdred
(2) you think I'm mafia and are questioning me so that I'll post my thought process and you can convince others to vote for me

what. is. your. point

On February 05 2015 07:24 Eden1892 wrote:

I'd have to go reread, this wasn't my impression but I wasn't looking very hard at that

On February 05 2015 07:28 Damdred wrote:
Well i'm home slowly reading through filters, i'm not sure you read all of Linux Marv I was really sure about most of my reads I posted look at my early trfel read that I threw away after awhile. Until I finally settled onto Eden being scum and b uilt my case there, lately I've been generally presenting my reads as very sure even if I change my mind later so I really hate that read of yours.

On February 05 2015 07:31 Eden1892 wrote:

I read through 2 pgs of her filter and she's proactively questioning sicklucker and Damdred. Admittedly most of her stuff to this point is reactive but there's some digging there

on p4 there's some proactive comments, the one thing I note in particular is that she made the exact point Breshke did about LS immediately before he made it. further on p4 she's questioning Onegu, there's some more digging on p5 too

She had a reactive start but I think she's fine as of now. Go back and read her filter again for me HF, I think you're coasting a bit on your initial impression

On February 05 2015 07:31 justanothertownie wrote:

The point is that you are very sure in a case you shouldn't be sure at all.

On February 05 2015 07:32 Damdred wrote:


Go look at what I wrote on Trfel in Linux Mafia even if I went back on it later, the only difference here to ther eis i'm getting town read there and scum read here. If the reads were reversed people would listen to me instead of scoff at what i'm saying

On February 05 2015 07:28 Holyflare wrote:
lol eden you're in the wrong here and you are the one being defensive when all you need to do is explain how you go from defending everything damdred to scum reading him

On February 05 2015 07:31 Eden1892 wrote:

I read through 2 pgs of her filter and she's proactively questioning sicklucker and Damdred. Admittedly most of her stuff to this point is reactive but there's some digging there

on p4 there's some proactive comments, the one thing I note in particular is that she made the exact point Breshke did about LS immediately before he made it. further on p4 she's questioning Onegu, there's some more digging on p5 too

She had a reactive start but I think she's fine as of now. Go back and read her filter again for me HF, I think you're coasting a bit on your initial impression

On February 05 2015 07:32 Holyflare wrote:


well, again, you're wrong, so get on my level

On February 05 2015 07:34 justanothertownie wrote:

No. Just no. It has literally nothing to do with how people read you.

On February 05 2015 07:28 Damdred wrote:
Well i'm home slowly reading through filters, i'm not sure you read all of Linux Marv I was really sure about most of my reads I posted look at my early trfel read that I threw away after awhile. Until I finally settled onto Eden being scum and b uilt my case there, lately I've been generally presenting my reads as very sure even if I change my mind later so I really hate that read of yours.

On February 01 2015 00:40 Damdred wrote:
I was looking at Trfel filter again and a few things popped up at me that raised a red flag.

Really hard disbelief/doubt on robik claim when it happened. This is interesting to me because of the difference in what Trfel did and thread. People were mad at Rob claiming but believed it, brownies generally believe claims due to it adding more information and game being slightly easier even if it's bad. Mafia already knew partial setup, and disbelief to robik claim could be a Scum slip from to much info.

Moving on thread presence is really down and lots of excuses about why he's not posting much.

Lastly a pretty decent sized list post with no conclusive reads no Scum reads just really noncommittal reads,

Trfel is scum

On February 05 2015 07:38 Damdred wrote:


Yes, yes it does. People have a conditioned response to how they view things. In this case people are looking at me as scum so everything I say is tinted for the thread which is fine but it is the truth.

Im to sure of my read? Palmar was to sure of his read on me but nobody jumped on him for that obviously, who cares if i'm right or wrong about LS obviously I believe/believed it at the time and he is angrier to me than he normally is. And he is playing marginally different as is RS, and mind you LS was caught in a lie about Rsoultin that he normally wouldn't make because he is so hung up on meta reads and people sticking to that specific meta but ok.