[T] Jack of All Trades Mafia - Page 136

On March 08 2015 03:31 Tubesock wrote:
Thoughts before I leave for work. Let's examine some scenarios that have been pushed.

1. Geript's defense of Sandroba

Syllogism MUST be town spirit. (Turns out true)
Syllogism MUST find Sandroba town. (Turns out true)
Syllogism MUST think Sandroba best for PR. (Apparently True)
Sandroba MUST be town.

That's a lot of things that need to happen.

My idea. (Sandroba is mafia)

Sandroba MUST be mafia. (wait and see)
Sandroba MUST want to avoid try harding. (ample evidence)
Syllogism CAN be either Spirit.
Syllogism CAN Scum Sandroba.
Syllogism CAN give PR to ANYONE.
Sandroba CAN fake/real check ANYONE.

Basically, to argue successfully with me on my point is prove that Sandroba would not mind try harding and do some other play. OR show how his Day 1 is town and something that mafia can't fake.

My idea is not stupid. Given an outcome X or Y, would be be more likely to be true? X which needs 4 things to fall into place (we didn't know about them during this debate), or Y which needs 2?

As mafia, why would I work so hard to find out a scenario that is so relatively simple, versus a scheme that with out much indepth analysis seems plausible but requires 4 at the time unverifiable things to fall in to place? Mafia knew who was the scum in the cell. Why would any town do nothing but fight this idea? Kithaman27 and IamRobik both thought my Theory was bad. See how they reacted? They continued to ask questions, they even asked questions from topics I BROUGHT UP. They investigated. Others did nothing but bring up why my scenario was so unlikely and stupid.

Think about these things in the context that Onegu was Framed or Godfathered. How many unverifiable things need to fall into place for this to happen? How many things need to be true for Onegu to be an excuse for night kill survival. ONE.

Onegu is TOWN.